10 ms·
10-core i9-10900F desktop CPU lags behind 8-core Ryzen 9 4900HS mobile APU
- all_blue_chucks 7y agoGeekbench is self-reported, unverified information. Anyone could post arbitrary benchmark results for any chip.
- briffle 7y agoDoes this new intel CPU have 'fixes' for all issues like spectre and meltdown, where you were supposed to turn off hyperthreading for better security? I'm just curious if the fixes for those (and other similar vulnerabilities) are starting to make their way into silicon, but also that the fixes recommended usually slow cpu's down quite a bit too.
- sidewndr46 7y agoCoffee Lake and newer has mitigations for that apparently. https://www.anandtech.com/show/13450/intels-new-core-and-xeon-w-processors-fixes-for-spectre-meltdown https://www.anandtech.com/show/13450/intels-new-core-and-xeo... I'm unsure if a "fix" is actually possible with a pure hardware solution.
- rasz 7y agoIntel "fixes" so far has been microcode level detectors for particular proof of concepts submitted by researchers. Makeup on a pig. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/12/technology/intel-chip-fix.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/12/technology/intel-chip-fix...
- titzer 7y ago> microcode level detectors for particular proof of concepts No, they don't have enough microcode space for this, and the data paths in the CPU that Spectre and Meltdown affect are not programmable with microcode. The microcode updates have been hamfisted, usually amounting to a massive hammer. E.g. the first "hardware fix" for variant 2 (branch target injection) was to make the BTB not shareable across hyperthreads. The fix worked. It was to completely disable the BTB for indirect branch predictions altogether. Ha! That'll confound any sharing of it! Intel's CPUs are completely riddled with side channels due to the way they implemented speculative rollback. They are kind of screwed.
- kllrnohj 7y ago> Does this new intel CPU have 'fixes' for all issues like spectre and meltdown It's worth noting that Spectre-V1 is likely to be with us for many many years. CPUs have so far only shown interest in addressing spectre when spectre is crossing process or ring boundaries. In-process spectre leaks (so variant 1, Bounds Check Bypass) are currently not really being considered a problem in the CPU's eyes. No privilege boundaries were crossed, therefore not a bug. As in, secure in-process sandboxing seems to just be dead. Or left as an exercise for the embedding code to figure out how to in some way handle with no CPU support.
- gsnedders 7y agoI mean what could the CPU do otherwise for Spectre v1? You clearly need a privilege boundary, which CPUs already have in multiple ways: how would a new boundary differ to those that already exist?
- kllrnohj 7y agoSome people have asked for failed speculative execution to be truly side-effect free. Like a transaction buffer that speculative execution can manipulate without evicting or impacting L1/L2 until the speculation is committed. I don't really think this is a great use of transistors, and is why CPUs will probably never do it, but theoretically possible maybe.
- kilo_bravo_3 7y agoDespite the protestations of l33t Cyberhaxxing Z3r0 Cools everywhere, you only have to turn off hyper-threading if you are sharing a machine with someone you don't trust. If someone is on your machine and you don't know it, they don't have to use side-channel attacks. They'll can just use any of the thousands of other ways of privilege escalation to read the super-secret information you have stored in RAM, or find it when it is written to disk. The OpenBSD folks disabled SMT by default because of TLBleed. A non-datacenter/cloud user disabling SMT to avoid TLBleed is like a normal person carrying a fireman's rescue saw around with them 24 hours a day in case they get into a situation they have to saw themselves out of.
- theevilsharpie 7y ago> Despite the protestations of l33t Cyberhaxxing Z3r0 Cools everywhere, you only have to turn off hyper-threading if you are sharing a machine with someone you don't trust. If you're reading this reply, you probably automatically executed `hn.js`. Are you _sure_ you know what it does? Unless you're browsing the web with Javascript completely disabled, and you also don't have any applications that automatically update themselves from a remote source (are you _sure_ you know what those various auto-updaters are downloading?), you're running untrusted code on your machine. Perhaps you don't particularly care about that risk, or you don't feel the risk is severe enough to warrant the performance hit, which is fair, but the risk is there nonetheless.
- leetcrew 7y agothis doesn't quite pass the smell test. I can't quite tell if there's a way to filter out results from overclocked parts in geekbench, but it looks like these results for the i9-10900F are significantly lower than typical results for a stock i9-9900K. hard to believe they would do worse on the same process with more cores.
- piinbinary 7y agoIt is worth noting that this is the i9-10900F, not the i9-10900k (thank you, Intel, for the lovely naming scheme). I'd expect the -k variant to be at least as fast as the i9-9900k.
- belltaco 7y agoNot sure how that will matter, F just means there are no integrated graphics. Why would that impact performance compared to a i9-9900 ?
- piinbinary 7y agoI believe the K variant also has a higher base clock (3.7 vs. 3.2)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Tempest1981 7y agoAlso, 9900 was much easier to say... how do you pronounce 10900? "Ten-thousand-nine-hundred"? Feels tortured. "Ten-nine-hundred"? Yeesh.
- charwalker 7y agoTen-Nine Hundred is what I've seen on YouTube recently and I like it.
- 7y ago
- nicoburns 7y agoI'm really hoping apple puts these AMD mobile chips in their next MacBook Pro. At the moment I'm not seeing much reason to upgrade from my 2015 model, but if I could have 8 cores, that would a different matter...
- hajhatten 7y agoIf apple ever switches CPU supplier for their macbooks, it'll probably be for their own.
- kabdib 7y agoI guess they could buy AMD. Not that it would make any sense. :-)
- Flow 7y agoI think AMD will lose its x86 license then. https://www.kitguru.net/components/graphic-cards/anton-shilov/amd-x86-license-agreement-with-intel-cannot-block-our-merger-or-acquisition/ https://www.kitguru.net/components/graphic-cards/anton-shilo...
- lolc 7y agoThe way I read it, Intel would lose it too. Neither Intel nor Apple could afford losing it for even one day. It would thoroughly damage their brand.
- sudosysgen 7y agoI wonder how feasible it would be to remove the internal instruction set translation, thus making it not an x86 CPU, and doing translation in software.
- pram 7y agoThe i9 in a 16 inch MBP is 8 cores though?
- nottorp 7y agoHmm I need some schooling please: "The TDP for the latter part is 35 W while the i9-10900F is listed at 65 W, but being an Intel desktop processor that just reflects the TDP for the base clock, with much higher energy demands required for higher clocks (e.g. maximum PL1 has been recorded at 170 W)." So where do I find the actual maximum power consumption on recent desktop CPUs then? Do I set a limit in the BIOS? Do I read each and every review to see what they measured? Pointers to relevant links very much appreciated, thankee sai.
- rowanG077 7y agoYou can't find it. Intel has obscured the measurement too much. AMD is guilty of this as well but on a much smaller scale then Intel.
- nottorp 7y agoSheesh. So the only way is to settle on a few cpu models and search for reviews that have measured the actual power consumption?
- leeter 7y agoEven that is specific to that chip/mobo/PSU/Case/CPU cooler setup. So unless you match what was used in the article your mileage will vary a lot.
- sharken 7y agoSad but true, 35W should translate to less power usage than 65W. Still waiting for Lenovo Yoga Slim 7 which appears to be at the sweet spot for battery life, power and size.
- rowanG077 7y agoI don't think reviewers measure it. It's essentially just an average power draw under real-world load at this point.
- deleted 7y ago
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoThese mobile APUs are amazing. Especially when combined with a GPU. It would be really nice to be able to use these in a standard ATX motherboard because it would make the perfect home server CPU.
- 1996 7y agoI share your interest for a silent yet powerful homeserver. Unfortunately, there doesn't seem to be any desktop motherboards for mobile zen2 yet. Too bad. I would even settle on a NUC.
- lostlogin 7y agoA common use case includes video transcoding and the ability to offload this to hardware makes the NUC a good choice. I’d love a good AMD option, but for the size and price, I can’t find anything that will transcode as efficiently. The new Ghost Canyon NUCs look excellent, but I assume pricing will be eye watering. They are also much larger. https://www.anandtech.com/show/15720/intel-ghost-canyon-nuc9i9qnx-review https://www.anandtech.com/show/15720/intel-ghost-canyon-nuc9...
- rubatuga 7y agoI've found the HP Z230 SFF to be very silent and available for only ~$150.
- jamiek88 7y agoWhat would you use the GPU for in a home server?
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoHardware accelerated h265/h264 decoding/encoding for media streaming and CCTV cameras.
- Narishma 7y agoAn APU is fine for those things, you don't need a dedicated GPU.
- sharken 7y agoThe 65W is a bit misleading, according to https://www.techpowerup.com/265695/intel-core-i9-10900f-can-allegedly-pull-up-to-224-w https://www.techpowerup.com/265695/intel-core-i9-10900f-can-... and https://wccftech.com/intel-core-i9-10900f-10-core-desktop-cpu-crushed-by-amd-ryzen-9-4900hs-8-core-cpu/ https://wccftech.com/intel-core-i9-10900f-10-core-desktop-cp... it is allowed to draw 170W in PL1 mode and up to 224W(!) in PL2 mode. Those numbers should feature prominently alongside the 65W figure. It does not look good for Intel at the moment.
- ipsum2 7y agoYeah TDP is calculated differently for Intel and AMD, usually to make Intel look better. It makes it harder to compare because hardware components are going to be different (e.g. different mobo, different memory, etc) but they should measure wattage out the wall.
- greggyb 7y agoIntel's is roughly "the thermal dissipation required to maintain base clock speeds indefinitely without thermal throttling". AMD's is roughly "the thermal dissipation required for all-core turbo indefinitely". In recent generations (since AMD's Zen architecture), AMD is much closer in testing to their published numbers than Intel is. It is important to note that this is a thermal specification, rather than a power consumption specification. There are processors that exist which can hit their performance numbers without needing any thermal solution, and as such would have an "honest" TDP of 0, despite having a >0 power draw from the wall.
- abryzak 7y agoGamers Nexus has a video & article explaining how TDP is primarily a marketing term. https://www.gamersnexus.net/guides/3525-amd-ryzen-tdp-explained-deep-dive-cooler-manufacturer-opinions https://www.gamersnexus.net/guides/3525-amd-ryzen-tdp-explai...
- wahern 7y agoI really wish they'd publish the range. Last year I built an AMD EPYC 3201 (embedded) with a 30W TDP (replacing a Xeon E3-1220v3[1]). Because it sits idle or under very low load most of the time, and though my power is effectively free (under my office lease I pay a fixed share of building utilities based on my square footage), I don't want to unnecessarily waste energy, generate a ton of heat (130-year-old building, A/C is adjusted by window height), or go deaf from the fans. Also, I prefer short depth rack mount cases which means everything is stuffed in there tight.[2] It idles at about ~20W and maxes ~45W (+/- 5W, I forget) as measured at the outlet, but if a more powerful CPU idled at 30W and only peaked to 100-150W at full load, I'd prefer that (especially for a future replacement for my VM host), as the 1% of time I need the performance it's definitely worth it. But it's hard to find reliable numbers, if any numbers at all other than the marketing TDP, so I just err on the safe side. [1] The older E3s were amazing, at least in the pre-Meltdown, pre-Spectre era. I built 2 E3-1220v2 boxes and 2 E3-1220v3 boxes, and at full load (all cores at max, with or without heavy memory transfer) both drew under their published TDPs at the outlet. [2] Supermicro's EPYC embedded motherboard is a poor fit for the officially paired short depth case, especially the power connector. The case was originally designed for their Atom, Xeon E3, and Xeon D boards. With their EPYC embedded board the power connector needs an adapter, and the adapter and wires have to be stuffed forcefully in an awkward and worrisome manner, much more awkward than is typical for a poorly designed configuration. I think I spent a day confirming that I wasn't doing something wrong, and than another day looking in vein for an alternative adapter that wasn't so large. But I really wanted the EPYC to replace the E3, and didn't want to wait any longer. And it seems I'd still be waiting if I had. For all its flaws Supermicro's solution still seems the most practical for stuffing an AMD Zen CPU into a short depth rackmount case, whether EPYC or Ryzen.
- heelix 7y agoI've got a 4800hs 8-core laptop that should be showing up on my doorstep later today. My kid is doing some heavy video/graphics work in Adobe in her undergraduate program, and going to try this as a potential desktop/workstation replacement since she is still a bit of a nomad as a student. Her current laptop just can't handle the work without trying to cook itself - but will have some apples to apples rendering comparisons based on her homework soon. The crazy thing is the cost.. about $1000 for a base unit. Will be doing some comparisons to my other desktop threadrippers just to see where it stacks up.
- formercoder 7y agoNice - assuming it has USB-C? The external USB-C SSDs are great for source media.
- heelix 7y agoI believe so. https://www.asus.com/us/Laptops/ASUS-TUF-Gaming-A15 https://www.asus.com/us/Laptops/ASUS-TUF-Gaming-A15 Is what we have on route. No SD slot... but most of the other ports one might need.
- formercoder 7y agoYeah it does. 1TB will last a while but depending on what she’s working on she could easily have 100GB of source material per project.
- heelix 7y agoSD Card slot,for transferring files from her camera. It does have room for an extra m.2 drive. I've not opened the back yet... those parts/packages have not shown up yet.
- 1996 7y agoCan you recommend a NUC-like computer? Something easy to carry around, to LAN, ideally with PCIe slots or an NVIDIA GPU
- paypalcust83 7y agoBtw, does anyone know how to buy boxed (PIB/WOF) AMD Rome EPYCs at reasonable (not full MSRP) market prices rather than OEM/tray (non-WOF) ones? I recently ordered WOF EPYCs from a small business that fronts one of the largest distributors of PC components, and they/distributor sent the no-warranty OEM/tray ones instead. (30 day warranty + 15% restocking fee is no deal at all.)
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y agoLinusTechTips recently took a look at a gaming laptop with the same APU and were super impressed with its Intel-scorching performance: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYqG31V4qtA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYqG31V4qtA
- stagger87 7y agoThe laptop from LTT and this article is the same.
- _ph_ 7y agoIs there a 4900HS laptop around already that can be recommended for Linux usage?
- jakogut 7y agoReading this now on a ROG Zephyrus G14 ($1,449)[1] running Arch. I've had a few random lockups with Linux 5.6.4, though they seem to have become less frequent with amd-ucode and a bios update. Additionally, I haven't had any problems with 5.7rc1, though the proprietary Nvidia driver (440.82) doesn't compile with that kernel yet. Otherwise, it's been running great. The screen looks great, the touchpad feels really good, and the performance is amazing. The biggest complaint I have at the moment is the lack of PgUp/Dn and Home/End keys. [1] https://www.bestbuy.com/site/asus-rog-zephyrus-g14-14-gaming-laptop-amd-ryzen-9-16gb-memory-nvidia-geforce-rtx-2060-1tb-ssd-moonlight-white/6403816.p?skuId=6403816 https://www.bestbuy.com/site/asus-rog-zephyrus-g14-14-gaming...
- _ph_ 7y agoThe machine definitely looks tempting, but based on the mostly failed attempts by Ars Technica to run Linux on it, I had stopped looking at it. But perhaps the kernels they used were too old. Still, for that price, I would expect it to work without issues, as I really would buy it as a Linux machine. How is your experience, Ars had problems with the fans running too high and the battery not lasting as long as it should?
- jakogut 7y agoI generally avoid Ubuntu, but I'm not looking for an out-of-the-box perfect experience, and I like new hardware. The unfortunate reality is that hardware vendors, not OS vendors, provide software support for their hardware. Additionally, Linux is a minuscule portion of the desktop/laptop market, and hardware vendors can't justify dropping as much money on Linux as they do for Windows. Still, plenty of hobbyists are happy to develop for, test, reverse engineer, and support good hardware, but using Linux on a new platform generally means being on the bleeding edge, which is one of the reasons I like Arch. It also means participating in mailing list discussions, diving into various software projects, and testing and submitting patches. So far, the experience has been mixed, but positive. Like I said, I've experienced a few random lockups, mostly at first. The fans have been working as expected on Linux 5.6.4. Even now, I'm compiling Chromium (for VA-API support), which usually takes an hour or two even on a Threadripper 1950X, and they only spin up occasionally. The battery life at the moment is generally either 2-3 hours (~35W-40W power usage), or 7-10 hours (~7W-10W), depending on hardware usage. This is close to what I've seen from reviewers using Windows, though not quite as good. I expect that to get better as Nvidia improves their dynamic power management, and software support for Linux gets better. Regardless, if you want to play with new hardware, use a rolling release distro, or figure out how to compile newer versions of the packages that come with your distro.
- Havoc 7y agoI really appreciate this entire race frankly. For a desktop computer even mid tier 3700X is now "good enough" even for someone with aspirations towards solid gaming. On home use front CPUs seem to have outsprinted their usage cases.
- _bxg1 7y agoFor gaming in particular, the GPU is almost always the bottleneck. It's much easier to throw in more polygons and texture pixels than it is to come up with bigger and more complex gameplay simulations. I'm still running a quad-core i5 from 2014 in my gaming desktop and it rarely has an impact.
- websg-x 7y agoThe leaked benchmark ran with single memory channel instead of dual. The multicore score is 30% lower because of that. Somebody are trying to mislead here.