5 ms·
Just as an FYI, in terms of deaths per terawatt-hour, nuclear is about an order of magnitude safer than the next safest contender, solar, and two orders of magn
by arcticbull 7y ago
Just as an FYI, in terms of deaths per terawatt-hour, nuclear is about an order of magnitude safer than the next safest contender, solar, and two orders of magnitude safer than coal. [1, 2]
Also consider that the worst ever accident in the history of nuclear power, Chernobyl of course, is expected to in the full course of time, kill 4,000 people (including those who killed themselves because they thought they were "contaminated"). On the other hand, the worst hydro accident, the Bangqiao dam failure, killed 171,000 people in the span of likely about 10 whole minutes. [3, 4]
It bears calling out separately for emphasis since you mentioned it, if you're going to get any cancer, just pray it's thyroid cancer -- it has a 98% survival rate [5]. The thyroid is removed and you take thyroxin for the rest of your life, but otherwise, you're good to go. If you're in an affected area adding it to your routine screening should be more than sufficient.
[1] https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy
[2] https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2011/03/deaths-per-twh-by-energy-source.html https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2011/03/deaths-per-twh-by-ener...
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deaths_due_to_the_Chernobyl_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deaths_due_to_the_Chernobyl_di...
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banqiao_Dam https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banqiao_Dam
[5] https://www.cancer.net/cancer-types/thyroid-cancer/statistics https://www.cancer.net/cancer-types/thyroid-cancer/statistic...
- roenxi 7y agoIn this instance, order of magnitude would mean in a team of 10 people killed producing solar energy 9 of them get to live if we use nuclear. The data you sourced doesn't consistently support that in link [1]; it suggests more like 1 in 2 so isn't really fair to call that an order of magnitude. It is just much better. But don't mind me, I remain as confused as ever about why people don't feel these statistics end the argument over nuclear.
- arcticbull 7y agoI usually use [2] as my source (where the order of magnitude is fully supported -- 0.04 vs 0.44 deaths per terawatt hour for rooftop solar). I believe [1] is referencing the totality of the solar market, including both rooftop and industrial solar. Rooftop solar is more dangerous due to the risks associated with installing and servicing panels on an incline a couple of stories off the ground. [1] notably excludes the Bangqiao dam as that would raise the hydro number probably an order of magnitude by itself. Their biomass number also likely excludes air pollution. Either way, to your point, the results are pretty darn clear no matter how you slice and dice the numbers.
- notahacker 7y ago[2] is pretty cranky, to put it mildly. Guy is quite insistent that thyroid cancer deaths even the nuclear industry acknowledged were down to Chernobyl shouldn't count, but on the other hand he's quite happy to attribute an arbitrarily large proportion of roofing accidents to solar power and scale that up by the TWH requirements of a nuclear plant because obviously there's nowhere other than pitched roofs to install solar panels. If we're looking at the peer reviewed stuff, nuclear isn't an order of magnitude safer than renewables, it's broadly similar to modern renewables after taking into account the evacuation of entire cities to mitigate the nuclear casualty figures...
- brutt 7y agoIf Sun will blow and destroy whole Earth, it still will be the safest form of energy generation per TWh, so solar energy wins again.
- arcticbull 7y agoI mean, it isn't, because the data says it isn't but that's okay too :) nothing's risk free, many solar panels have/had cadmium and rare earth metals which are mined in horrifyingly toxic pits across China, and generate piles of e-waste that need to be disposed of. The panels themselves are large and heavy and need to be cleaned, serviced and replaced over time. That doesn't mean it's at all bad, just it's not perfect either.
- thawaway1837 7y agoIt killed 4000 people because they basically shut down cities and villages to allow it to do so. If they hadn’t obliterated those places the death toll would be a lot higher. I haven’t heard of entire cities being shutdown due to solar accidents despite the far greater prevalence of solar farms than nuclear facilities in existence. Edit: Also, heroic efforts by ordinary Russians, who almost certainly compromised their own lives so that people much further away wouldn’t be affected.
- vermilingua 7y agoYes, because even despite the mismanagement of the disaster, the timescales involved allowed them to implement the protections needed. You’re arguing for the GP.
- notahacker 7y agoPersonally I think may require evacuation of entire cities for decades to mitigate casualties is a risk factor worth taking into account, except perhaps when building nuclear reactors in deserted areas. Similarly, the fact that we've largely contained it by shutting entire countries down is not an argument for COVID-19 actually being one of the least harmful pathogens humanity has encountered.
- DagAgren 7y agoDefinitely worth taking into account! But when you do, it's still a lot less damaging overall than things like coal.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tsukikage 7y agoSo, what I'm hearing in this thread is that we should evacuate entire areas around coal burning power plants for decades, but we choose not to.
- Retric 7y agoRooftop solar is #6. Grid solar built on the ground is #1 and nuclear is arguably #2 based on specific models of the dangers associated with widespread fallout. Though windmill deaths during construction are front loaded, so it’s likely to drop as current windmills age. PS: Hydro power is actually negative deaths per kWh if you include the lives saved from reduced flooding. But that gets into tricky definitions.
- arcticbull 7y ago> PS: Hydro power is actually negative deaths per kWh if you include the lives saved from reduced flooding. But that gets into tricky definitions. It's very positive if you count the Bangqiao Dam ;)