2 ms·
I don't believe that the sentence pattern which I used attributes sentiments to others. "You want ..." functions as as rhetorical idiom. "You want X or else Y
by kazinator 7y ago
I don't believe that the sentence pattern which I used attributes sentiments to others.
"You want ..." functions as as rhetorical idiom.
"You want X or else Y" roughly means "Unless X, Y, thus you will be objectively disadvantaged".
The sentiment, if there is one, remains mine; on the other hand, this "ghoulish" is in fact an external interpretation of sentiment being ascribed to me.
- tptacek 7y agoI don't know you enough to call you "ghoulish" and wouldn't be inclined to, but the sentiment itself hopes that a treatment for an illness killing tens of thousands of people per week will fail in order to secure supplies for a chronic but nonfatal ailment. I feel like the absolute morality of that sentiment is something we can actually evaluate. (It's all hypothetical, of course, because in fact HCQ does not appear to be effective for C19).
- kazinator 7y agoHave you considered that I might be thinking of the problem that it will be hoarded up by some individuals who have neither the illness nor the ailment? Few who needs it for any reason will be able to get their hands on it. That's my thinking, more or less.
- tptacek 7y agoHoping a treatment for C19 won't work --- in essence, rooting for the virus --- is a bad look. That's as far as the analysis goes. And, again, it's a moot point.