5 ms·
Yikes, I was afraid there was a new tweet, but this is still the infamous 2018 one. Still, I'm a bit confused -- as much as I think he deserved to be fined/pun
by crazygringo 7y ago
Yikes, I was afraid there was a new tweet, but this is still the infamous 2018 one.
Still, I'm a bit confused -- as much as I think he deserved to be fined/punished for it, the $20 million SEC fine did that.
It seems like he should be subject to an SEC fine or a shareholder lawsuit, but not both -- isn't it redundant? I would assume that the SEC fine was calculated as an "appropriate" punitive amount -- not a punitive amount minus what they expected a shareholder lawsuit would also result in?
- H8crilA 7y ago$20M is probably at least two orders of magnitude less than the total losses people suffered as a result of this lie. It is almost certainly not "appropriate" in the damages sense. It may be a sensible fine ($1k may be a sensible fine to someone who has no money); it does not cover damages whatsoever.
- papermachete 7y agoWhy are people so fucking entitled?
- H8crilA 7y agoYou'd make an entertaining but an unsuccessful attorney. Imagine defending a robber: Why are the plantiffs so entitled to compensation for damage? Whatever happened, happened - stop dragging the subject!
- papermachete 7y agoMore like getting kicked out for failing your mortgage despite knowing what you're getting into.
- H8crilA 7y agoDude, it was a fraud, in the most speedy "fraud segment", that is M&A. It's so speedy because M&A directly links a security against a price ($420), but it was all a lie. It really is just a robbery.
- papermachete 7y agoHe conveyed no intent, he was supposedly "thinking". A bunch of millenials got burned and Musk paid for babysitting.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gamblor956 7y agoWhy are people so entitled to be made whole for harm caused to them by someone else acting with the intent to cause harm? Because the law says they are. You're arguing against more than 200 years of Western law that underpins the basis of the Western economic system.
- KarlKemp 7y agoThe shareholders that were supposedly wronged didn't get anything from the SEC action. It's comparable to criminal and civil law existing side-by-side: if you run a red light and someone gets hurt, you'll be fined for the traffic violation. But the victim is also going to sue you for medical expenses, work income missed, and compensation for any suffering. Of course any compensation here is going to be paid by Tesla to shareholders of Tesla, who own the company anyway. It might make a difference for individuals based on when they are/were shareholders and when not. But absent such effects, it's a really strange system. I wonder if Elon Musk will join the lawsuit. He's the single largest victim here, after all. That would be fun.
- djannzjkzxn 7y agoIt’s common for entities to face legal action in multiple theaters from different entities stemming from the same events. A well-known example is OJ Simpson first fighting a criminal case, and later a civil case. Here, the SEC is an administrative entity (part of the executive branch) with the power to levy fines. Now shareholders are filing a civil suit for damages. Sometimes, the SEC will participate in a multi-party settlement that can resolve administrative, civil, and even criminal charges at the same time - but that didn’t happen here.
- xkjkls 7y ago$20 million for someone with a 11 figure fortune is a speeding ticket. We have to remember that he harmed people with hundreds of millions at stake on the price of the company by faking the largest corporate buyout in the history of the stock market. This kind of blatant fraud needs to be assessed extremely punitively.