4 ms·
Theranos was a scam.
by nabla9 7y ago
Theranos was a scam.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- isoskeles 7y agoHindsight is 20/20. Investors couldn't just step into the future and ask someone whether or not Theranos was a scam and why.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThey could have asked to see the proof that it worked and asked an independent third party to verify it. That's usually what happens when people do due diligence, and it happens every day in the business world.
- ashtonkem 7y agoAlso, experts raises the red flags years before the scam was finally revealed. The fraud was trivially discoverable; investors let their goals cloud good judgement.
- lalos 7y agoYou could claim the same about Tesla, it has a lot of expert criticizing their financials but it is still up in the air if they are right or wrong. I guess if it does fail people will claim that it was obvious all along...
- ashtonkem 7y agoTesla sells a product. Whether or not their business model around the product will work and whether the company is well administered is debatable. With Theranos the experts were skeptical that the product was theoretically even possible, and they never demonstrated it working to anyone. All the “demonstrations” involved cheap tricks of shuffling people from room to room so lab techs could manually process the samples. Furthermore anyone doing basic due process could’ve gotten a traditional lab test and compared to the Theranos tests, exactly like investigative reporters did later. Such an obvious test would’ve revealed problems much earlier, and nobody on the inside decided to try that. At least with Tesla you can actually buy a car and actually drive it.
- astura 7y agoNo, you can't say that about Tesla, nobody ever said making an electric car was literally impossible. Quite the contrary, the technology is well understood. The experts raised the red flags very early that what Theranos was trying to do didn't appear to be scientifically possible based on current knowledge.
- isoskeles 7y agoBut they didn't. And there is zero guarantee it won't happen again to healthcare companies. The whole point here is making some generic statement about an entire industry being a good investment is a simple-minded opinion. If this made any sense, the entire economy should be made of only healthcare companies, they're just so good, right?
- viklove 7y agoInvestors chose Theranos for the same reason they chose WeWork. It's not because they're making sound investments, it's because they have more money than they know what to do with, and it's becoming increasingly obvious that they don't deserve it. Must "unicorns" are taking advantage of various levels of market fraud, on one side you have Theranoses, somewhere in the middle you've got WeWork, and far on the other end is Uber. All unproven, ridiculous ideas that are not making society better, but rather serve solely to funnel money into the hands of a few wealthy investors. The American dream is finally dead, and it's SV that killed it.
- bsder 7y agoTheranos was fine until they LIED. Lots of VC backed companies fail. Many try to pivot. Had Theranos not been lying through their teeth and were actually developing tech, they probably could have pivoted to a slightly different direction or application. Sure, maybe you can't diagnose an individual disease from a fingerprick, but maybe you can get useful data by doing it every time someone hits the doctor and looking at trends. Maybe you can get okay information from much smaller blood draws. Maybe you can optimize where the blood is drawn. Maybe you can get information from other fluids than blood. There could have been useful science coming out of Theranos, but with con-people in the driver's seats, that was never going to happen.
- catalogia 7y agoTheranos was never fine because the tech they wanted to develop simply wasn't possible. Had they not lied, they would have crashed and burned anyway. > Many try to pivot. Theranos did. Originally they wanted the machines in every home, then they changed tack and tried to make more conventional testing equipment with fewer capabilities. Even then, what they wanted to do wasn't possible. Theranos was lead by a college dropout. The chance of them ever doing anything productive in the biomed industry was nil. They turned to fraud because everything else they tried failed.
- icedchai 7y agoI have read "Bad Blood" and am convinced Elizabeth Holmes believed they could actually make the tech work, given enough time and resources. It was fraud, but it didn't start off that way. I felt it was "fake-it-til-you-make-it" that got out of control. FYI, lots of great companies were built by college dropouts. Microsoft, Apple, Facebook... on and on. That has nothing to do with it.
- avgDev 7y agoAll the companies you listed are different though. Early on people were telling Holmes that whatever she wanted to do WAS NOT POSSIBLE. It became a fraud very early on.