4 ms·
> Personally, I like to make RAID mirrors with drives of different brands, or at least different models. Even it it is not ideal for performance, it helps makin
by yellowapple 7y ago
> Personally, I like to make RAID mirrors with drives of different brands, or at least different models. Even it it is not ideal for performance, it helps making sure that not all drives fail at the same time.
This is exactly my approach lately, and it works great for RAID10 arrays (where you only need 2 or 3 different vendors - one per side of the mirror - to mitigate shared bathtub curves). I usually go with SSDs nowadays, though (half Crucial, half Kingston), both for performance reasons and because they rebuild faster (and also because the limited lifetime of flash memory makes some sort of RAID essential for longevity, though this has been less of a problem with modern flash tech); if I really needed the capacity of magnetic media I'd probably opt for a WD / Toshiba split.
- aspenmayer 7y agoWhat do you recommend for Crucial and Kingston SSDs? I’m familiar with Crucial BX500 and Kingston UV500. They are both SATA and are decent performance considering the limitations of SATA 3. If price isn’t a factor or performance is important I’d go with a Samsung 860 EVO or Pro on SATA. I’ve also used a smaller number of SanDisk by WD SATA SSDs and they work fine as well. Had a bad Samsung 840 series but I think failure to implement proper overprovisioning was to blame. Also had a bad Intel SATA SSD but it was an older generation product and had a small sample size of only a few Intel SSDs, so not writing Intel off; yet it’s suffice to say their products don’t seem price competitive with Samsung’s offerings. As for NVME SSDs I have used and installed probably ten so far but I think every single one so far has been a Samsung 9xx m.2 and I’ve been extremely satisfied with all of them, especially the 960 series EVO and Pro and moreso the current gen 970 EVO Plus and Pro.
- yellowapple 7y agoHonestly I just go with whatever's cheapest for a given target capacity (which, judging by my Amazon and Newegg purchase history, would be the Crucial MX500 and Kingston V300). Any SSD's almost always "fast enough" for my purposes (even with SATA instead of NVMe), and Kingston and Crucial have both been consistently reliable enough that I haven't felt the need to splurge much (and if they do fail... well, that's what RAID's for, right?). Both the desktop on which I'm typing this comment (my personal "gaming" rig) and my work laptop (a Thinkpad T470) are using Crucial MX500s (1TB, M.2); the former has a couple extra M.2 slots, so I'm considering migrating to a Crucial P1 + Kingston A2000 combo (thus biting the bullet and switching to NVMe, and getting RAID going on this machine). Most of my 2.5" purchases tend to be Kingston V300s unless the MX500 happens to be cheaper (e.g. most recently for an old XP computer I'm rebuilding for a family friend) or I'm specifically buying both for the aforementioned purpose of RAID diversification (which is a bit tricky, since Crucial and Kingston use different increments for capacity, but I'm also perfectly willing to pull a bit of a SSD "no-no" and use the leftover space on whichever drive for a swap partition, or else just let the space sit unused, or perhaps use it for temporary files where I don't care about any sort of data preservation). In any case, no complaints with any of 'em. I haven't tried the P1 or A2000 yet (let alone Kingston's pricier KC2000), so I can't attest to those, but the MX500 and V300 have both proven to be reliable workhorses. I'll definitely be sure to try Samsung again at some point; the first SSD I ever bought was a Samsung (at Fry's), and I had pretty awful experiences with it, but that was back when SSDs were a pretty new concept so I'm guessing things have generally improved.