3 ms·
Doreen, I usually read your comments with great interest because they are always insightful. I think in this case you're mistaken though, your personal experie
by the_af 7y ago
Doreen, I usually read your comments with great interest because they are always insightful.
I think in this case you're mistaken though, your personal experience notwithstanding. Are you from the US? The police in many countries is inherently incapable of treating the defenseless well. This sometimes has to do with the local political leadership, but often times it's simply intrinsic to the force. I live in Argentina and the political leadership is desperately trying to get the cops to enforce the lockdown in a gentle manner, yet there are cases everywhere of them simply abusing people in poverty-stricken areas. The police over here prey on the weak because it makes them feel powerful (and yes, usually because there are little consequences -- and that's political). But the point here is that the police and the politicians are at odds in this case.
I think the causes for police misbehavior are multiple and indeed systemic: giving guns and power to people unqualified for it and who get a kick out of having power over people; police forces with undemocratic traditions (as in Chile and Argentina, where the force was shaped by our dictatorships; this doesn't apply to the US) don't understand how to behave in a democracy; over here the police often comes from the same low-wage background as the people they harass, and harassment becomes a form of differentiation ("I'm not like them, they dress funny, and are dumb and violent"); discrimination based on perceived skin tone of course, and this is probably a lot like in the US.
Not sure if in the US it's exactly the same, but from what I read, in many cases it's pretty similar.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI wrote you a longer reply and then deleted it. I've simply been up too many hours at this point and I feel like we're probably talking at cross purposes. I need to either finally get to sleep or just shut up. No good will come of me continuing to post in this state. Sorry things are so bad where you are.
- lonelappde 7y agoYour lowest quality posts are far far higher quality than the average on HN, even when people read uncharitably and reply aggressively and your frustration rises. Thank you for all you share.
- the_af 7y agoI hope you're not implying I replied aggressively to Doreen. I was civil and I appreciate her posts, I just disagreed on this issue. We must learn to understand that disagreement does not equal fighting.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI seriously doubt it was intended to say anything about you. As for our exchange: I'm not saying that the police are all paragons of virtue or should never be criticized. I'm just saying that stress tends to push people towards absolutist thinking in a way that actively worsens problems. In most cases, focusing on "this behavior or outcome is undesirable and needs to stop" will be more productive than framing it as "these people are simply bad people." That second tends to entrench problems and should primarily be used to justify removal of specific people after efforts to remedy the matter by other means have failed. You are more likely to find effective solutions if you approach it with some understanding for why the police fail to behave at all times like paragons of virtue. Simply branding people as bad people tends to yield no path forward for finding better approaches to the problem. When upset, people tend to exaggerate and to make more damning claims than they might otherwise and we should be cautious about where that leads, especially during a global crisis. Now more than ever, we need cooler heads to prevail. Generally speaking, being fair and evenhanded is most needed when it's the hard choice to make. This is part of why police forces behave badly -- because they are asked daily to take the high road while dealing with awful stuff and they get jaded and burned out. In their case, they are often dealing with the threat of imminent physical harm to themselves and the physiological responses that elicits, a la an adrenaline rush that causes a fight or flight reaction. That's especially hard to overcome. Public discussion in a forum doesn't involve those same elements. If it gets too harried, we can step away from the keyboard. Surely, this is a place where we can work at having cooler heads prevail. Some of the first few comments on this piece were sweepingly dismissive of the police as simply straight up bad people who don't care. You showed up later, so you may have missed that context. By the time you showed up, there was meaty discussion and a variety of views. But there mostly wasn't when I left my remark urging people to not forget that cops are human. I think you could have added your observations about police behavior where you live without asserting that I'm wrong. I don't think I'm wrong, but I also don't think my point really says what you seem to see it as saying. The discussion here is about police behavior in a specific time and place. It's not wrong to feel that it's appropriate to talk about police behavior across the globe as part of that discussion, but it's also not accurate to act like I was suggesting "Police in Argentina are all paragons of virtue." That's a bit of a stretch and leaves me not knowing how to reply because it seems like such a far fetched interpretation of my remarks. I was actually homeless in downtown San Diego for six months and in San Diego county for more than two years. I have first-hand experience with engaging with police while homeless in San Diego. My above anecdote comes from a police encounter that occurred while I was homeless and camped in San Diego county. So I think it's directly pertinent to the discussion here. I've never been to Argentina. I wouldn't presume to say much, if anything, about policing there.
- panzagl 7y agoWait- Argentina was a dictatorship for many years and the police were thugs enforcing the will of the ruling elite. To extrapolate from their behavior that all police everywhere are just waiting to put the boot in at every opportunity seems myopic at best.
- the_af 7y agoI mentioned that, but note at this point it's not just that. Democracy here returned in '83. While there is a structural problem of the police force still employing people from the dictatorship era, it's mostly fresh blood now. Police officers behaving brutally are a thing of new democratic governments here. Democratic neoliberal pro-business governments like our recent former president took a hardliner stance for police enforcement, encouraging a "heavy hand", but even supposedly "liberal" governments have a difficult time with police brutality. These are young officers harassing the poor, the homeless, student organizations, etc. Other countries like the US also have a history of the police harassing the poor, activists, blacks, etc. I see it in the news and reading about the history of the US. It's not specific to Argentina.
- panzagl 7y agoThe difference comes in the meaning behind words like 'harassing'- when the police here harass the homeless it's shining a light on them and telling them to get moving, not usually a kick or a poke in the ribs. Of course there are other issues in the US, mostly centered around race, where we don't look that good...
- the_af 7y agoOh, I agree it's not exactly the same situation. Though I believe the power difference between someone in uniform wielding a stick and a gun and a homeless/poor person is more universal and tends to lead to abuse. (In some cases, not even a poor person, just an unarmed one, can lead to police excessive use of force. We have seen this many times, even in the US).