2 ms·
Interesting concept, but I fail to see how it can model the whole universe. Describing it, maybe, but the universe being a graph, well for a start, what is the
by hutzlibu 7y ago
Interesting concept, but I fail to see how it can model the whole universe. Describing it, maybe, but the universe being a graph, well for a start, what is the graph made of?
Is it "material" is it "information"?
- crazygringo 7y agoAny fundamental theory of the universe will have to posit a bottom, base structure that everything else is "made" out of... ...but therefore that base isn't ever going to be made of anything itself, by definition. It just is. It is what it's described as -- no more, no less. It's not going to be material or energy. I suppose "information" is probably as good a word as any if you want to think of it that way.
- akvadrako 7y ago> Any fundamental theory of the universe will have to posit a bottom, base structure that everything else is "made" out of... I think that's being too closed minded about what a fundamental theory of the universe will look like. The only way it could be like that is if that fundamental structure is the only fully general option available.
- rytill 7y agothere could be no bottom ... there would also never be any way to prove that the proposed bottom is truly the bottom and not just an event horizon
- crazygringo 7y agoIf a theory's predictions are 100% consistent with experiment, then it becomes the bottom for all practical purposes, since all we have is practical knowledge. Saying we can't prove it's the bottom would mean as much as saying we can't prove the universe is on the back of a stack of giant tortoises. Technically true, but of no practical importance. Of course, if a theory doesn't agree 100% with reality, then there's more to find in a practical sense, in which case "not having reached the bottom" is true by definition.
- plutonorm 7y agoThat is philosophy, not physics. We describe what matter does with physics, not what it is. Personally I think the "void", the Buddhist concept, fits the bill nicely. Objects are created from the void and from those objects all possible objects are created. All of mathematics is expressed, and in one corner of that infinite structure lies our universe.