This is an example of condescension and holding contradictory beliefs. This person implies that this study is a replication of “known” things and that replicat

This is an example of condescension and holding contradictory beliefs. This person implies that this study is a replication of “known” things and that replications like this are not useful. But the replication strengthens the claims of 1, 2, and 4. This is a contradiction. The sense of condescension comes from “oh great”, “absolutely nothing new”, “foolish”, and claim 5. Claims 2 and 5 suggest some kind bias but I’m not sure how to classify it. Whatever it is, they give me a gross feeling.