6 ms·
Transparency can give bad actors a way to game and workaround the system.
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 7y ago
Transparency can give bad actors a way to game and workaround the system.
- underdeserver 7y agoMore likely, ammo in a potential legal battle between GitHub and the banned party.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoSo far it's been mostly small / independent developers or organizations that were banned, and Github has Microsoft behind it, a $125bn / year revenue company with a legal team 1,500 strong (https://www.bizjournals.com/seattle/news/2019/12/02/how-brad-smith-evolved-microsofts-legal-team.html https://www.bizjournals.com/seattle/news/2019/12/02/how-brad...). I don't think fear of litigation is the issue.
- koheripbal 7y agoThe very first thing a corporate lawyer does is proactively prevent litigation through protective policies that specifically do NOT emphasize transparency.
- vbezhenar 7y agoWe're living with transparent juridical system and it works fine. Imagine that you could be thrown to jail without explaining a reason. That would be outrageous.
- toyg 7y ago> transparent juridical system and it works fine Yeah, criminals are always arrested and convicted. /s It's a balance. With something as essential as human rights and personal freedom, people (tend to) err on the safe side. Online moderation can err on the other side, since consequences are relatively modest. If you get banned on GH, move to Gitlab or host your own, that's hardly a tragedy.
- saagarjha 7y agoOnline moderation is an issue of personal rights.
- FpUser 7y agoThat is exactly what I do. I use self hosted solutions for my source code repositories. I just can't digest my code being handled by some other entity. Too important.
- endgame 7y agoAmazing that you got downvoted for this. I pay for code hosting precisely because I want to see an ecosystem of code hosts, and monocultures are dangerous.
- FpUser 7y agoWell I've never downvoted a single post no matter how much I disliked it. Personally I consider this a kind of weakness and the whole system as promoting herd mentality. But whatever floats their boat.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 7y agoExactly. Screw around and try to game/skirt the law IRL and the risk is way too high that you'll goto jail anyway. There are usually no consequences for doing this online.
- candiodari 7y ago1) You can be thrown into jail without any explanation whatsoever. 2) You can be shot without any explanation whatsoever. 3) Your possessions can be taken away, and sold off without any explanation and without recourse. Links about each of these claims: https://abovethelaw.com/2018/07/innocent-people-who-plead-guilty/ https://abovethelaw.com/2018/07/innocent-people-who-plead-gu... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Walter_Scott https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Walter_Scott https://www.forbes.com/sites/jacobsullum/2014/09/11/how-cops-got-a-license-to-steal-your-money/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/jacobsullum/2014/09/11/how-cops... (also applies to, say, cars)
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoSo GitHub should aspire to do the same?
- koheripbal 7y agoAre you willing to pay taxes for github usage!? You get what you pay for.
- int_19h 7y agoIf it guaranteed that the repos stay up in perpetuity, that sounds amazing, actually.
- bhk 7y agoHow is "game and workaround the system" different from "comply with policies"? Is compliance not the objective?
- pc86 7y agoCompliance with the spirit is the objective. Sometimes the spirit and the letter differ for any number of reasons (many of which are completely reasonable). People tend to get pretty upset when someone is very clearly complying with the letter while flying in complete opposition to the spirit, and it's not always an easy fix.
- renata 7y agoIn that case, it sounds like the letter needs to be fixed. It's not fair to expect people to follow an ephemeral ideal of what the rules are rather than what they're told the rules actually are.
- pc86 7y agoLike I said, it's not always that simple. When it's not, something less than 100% transparency allows one to look at the given particulars of a case and determine whether or not someone is simply trying to evade the spirit of a rule or not. It gives enforcement actors a little lee-way that they wouldn't otherwise have.
- yellowapple 7y ago> It gives enforcement actors a little lee-way that they wouldn't otherwise have. Which can be and often is subject to abuse.
- pc86 7y agoOne of the worst things about engineers in general and HN specifically is we all pretend that law is executed like code, in a vacuum, idempotently based on the inputs. That's was, is, and will never be the case. Abuse can be exposed and punished, and very often is.
- Notorious_BLT 7y agoSo just to be clear, are you arguing that rules shouldn't be clearly laid out, because then people would be able to follow them?
- popinman322 7y agoNot taking a side on this, but there do exist people who exactly follow the letter of the law to circumvent the spirit of the law. For example, people who harass others just within the confines of the rules so that they can't be banned from a community solely using the rules. This is why we need humans to judge the spirit of the rules.