4 ms·
The guy buying up all the masks and reselling them is likely buying them in similar markets to the people who he will be selling them to eventually. His net eff
by jcranmer 7y ago
The guy buying up all the masks and reselling them is likely buying them in similar markets to the people who he will be selling them to eventually. His net effect is likely going to be doing diddly squat to the availability.
- Consultant32452 7y agoNone are available to purchase at the old, lower price, because demand at the old price outpaced production. The higher price drives some consumers out of the market, meaning there are still some for sale.
- jbay 7y agoDemand at the old price from people who bought them to resell at the new price?
- tristor 7y agoMostly, because the guy buying them all up to resell at 10x the price is a scumbag just like ticket scalpers, except worse because whether you pay $500 or $200 to get a ticket to a rock concert won't potentially kill you. The availability is primarily negatively impacted because of hoarders and gougers.
- Consultant32452 7y agoDo you believe that, absent price gougers, I would be able to walk into Home Depot, CVS, Walmart, etc. and buy some N95 masks for my personal use? I don't think that's likely, so wherever you were heading with that is irrelevant. I want to be clear I'm intentionally separating two things. The gouger is making product available on the market where otherwise there would be none. The higher price discourages hoarders or others with lower needs. This is clearly a valuable service that some, perhaps many, are willing to pay for. I feel like these are indisputable facts. There is a separate topic of moralizing about the issue, whether or not you think the gouger is a bad actor or whatever. You can keep going on about that, but I won't address it because I don't care about your feelings regarding my personal health.
- jcranmer 7y agoWhat you're missing is that, in the timescales at issue with price-gouging, both supply and demand are inelastic. So at, say, $10, you'd have 100 units of supply and 200 units of demand, while at $20, you have... 100 units of supply and 200 units of demand. Higher prices don't discourage hoarders, because a fair fraction of the hoarders are going to be people who are planning on reselling them to desperate people, so they're virtually guaranteed a profit. If you want to discourage hoarders, then enact purchasing limits: limit 1 per person.
- Consultant32452 7y agoI dismiss the idea that demand is inelastic. At $1/mask basically everyone wants an N95 mask. At $1k/mask most consumers are going to wear a bandana or alternative type of mask.
- jcranmer 7y agoSure, demand isn't perfectly inelastic. But at the price points we're talking about, the demand isn't dropping off fast enough to make the market look even close to equilibrium. But I noticed you didn't even attempt to engage with the solution of enforcing purchasing quotas instead of allowing price gouging.
- Consultant32452 7y agoEnforcing purchasing quotas does not allocate resources to where they're most needed. Pricing (including gouging) may be imperfect, but it is better than central resource allocation, price fixing, etc. at leading to efficient allocation of resources.
- jbay 7y ago> The higher price discourages hoarders or others with lower needs. Others with lower means, you meant?
- 7y ago