3 ms·
EU can't do much. Poland (radical right government) and Hungary (far right government) have a pact where they veto any EU actions against one of them. Members
by nabla9 7y ago
EU can't do much.
Poland (radical right government) and Hungary (far right government) have a pact where they veto any EU actions against one of them.
Members of EU are sovereign states. I think kicking them out of the union is only way to proceed if their system does not fit into the EU anymore.
- squarefoot 7y ago"Poland (radical right government) and Hungary (far right government) have a pact where they veto any EU actions against one of them." Same will happen in Italy in a few years. "I think kicking them out of the union is only way to proceed if their system does not fit into the EU anymore." To keep the EU clean, yes, but it won't accomplish anything locally: far right governments would actually love to get out of the European Union so they can do their nasty stuff unsupervised.
- jacobush 7y agoBut if they are allowed to stay, it sets a very dangerous precedent. Realistically, they will stay.
- squarefoot 7y agoAlso a good point.
- nabla9 7y ago> To keep the EU clean, yes, but it won't accomplish anything locally It's not EUs job to do that. There is genuine grassroots support for illiberal government in both countries. People in these countries are divided and have to fight it out among themselves. The responsibility is to upkeep liberal democracy is in the hands of the people.
- kazen44 7y agoThis statement is absurd and counter to the entire basis of modern european union law. For a country to be eligble for EU membership, it has to be a democracy and be a signatory of the Charter of Fundamental Rights and acknowledge the legitimacy of the european court of human rights and European Court of Justice. While the ECHR is not a EU institution, it is a cornerstone of european diplomacy both inside and outside the union. [1] https://europa.eu/european-union/topics/human-rights_en https://europa.eu/european-union/topics/human-rights_en
- lbeltrame 7y agoIt's not a matter of left and right. The Italian government is allegedly markedly left, and locked a lot of people in their homes with two administrative acts (no action from the Parliament for many weeks), has made a government commission against fake news on the epidemic (with outside journalists, but it still smells like a Ministry of Truth), and is using quite a bit of pressure to keep people in their homes (nothing violent, but a presence and controls by the police far higher than normal). Regional governments of any sides are following up in the same manner up to threatening arrest if you are walking out if you don't have a documented reason. Oh, and the Parliament is essentially shut down, and so the judicial system for the most part: everyone is too afraid of death. Also the way they address Italians, like parents scolding children, is unbearable. The population is made up of citizens, not loyal subjects. Simply put, as far as I can see the current pandemic has brought out the worst authoritarianism from all political sides.
- nabla9 7y ago> like parents scolding children, is unbearable. The population is made up of citizens, not loyal subjects. Populations are made of children citizens. Italy voted Berlusconi into power multiple times. I'm strong supporter democracy but the idea that voters are "adults" does not hold water. You need the mechanisms of liberal democracy and institutional processes for any resemblance of rationality to emerge from democratic process. Democracy is inherently dangerous.
- luckylion 7y agoIsn't that just a fancy way to say "you need experts to make the decisions and the populace to believe they are in charge"?
- lbeltrame 7y ago> I'm strong supporter democracy but the idea that voters are "adults" does not hold water. People are indeed capable of acting irrationally. But they're still citizens and not subjects of the government, which is still accountable to them (for the good and the bad), or should be, at least. This specific government acts in bad faith, far more than what can be considered tolerable (and the meaning for the choices made is lost completely).
- frockington1 7y agoI'm going on a tangent here, buy I'm curious as to what would happen if they did kick them out. Could those nations just print euro-denominated debt in anticipation and then switch currencies once out? I