8 ms·
There's a difference between price gouging and covering expenses. The guy buying up all the masks and reselling them for 10x the price is price gouging. He doe
by XorNot 7y ago
There's a difference between price gouging and covering expenses.
The guy buying up all the masks and reselling them for 10x the price is price gouging. He doesn't make anything.
If a manufacturer ramped production and billed the current inventory to cover costs, then that's a very different thing. Of course all of this is why the Defense Production Act even exists.
A perfect use of the DPA would be a mask manufacturer ramping up local production - if they had predictability of pricing beyond the current crisis, then it would let them forecast what they could and could not make, or get subsidized at the higher rate to ensure their business could ramp down gradually (or be retained at the subsidy price to ensure local availability for the next time).
- Consultant32452 7y ago>The guy buying up all the masks and reselling them for 10x the price is price gouging. He doesn't make anything. The guy buying up all the masks and reselling them for 10x the price is making availability, which is highly important in a crisis.
- treden 7y agoHe's capturing availability, the manufacturer made the availability. There is no value-adding middle man role with a 10x value here (well value to anyone other than the middle man).
- Consultant32452 7y agoThere's none available to purchase at the old, lower price. So he's providing value to me, someone who wishes to buy one.
- MisterBastahrd 7y agoBecause he bought them all. This is why, in states where disasters are probable due to natural issues (hurricanes, earthquakes), price gouging is a crime. Not only is it a crime, but it is one where there is full bi-partisan support for the continuance of the law. If you want to put a smile on the face on someone suffering from calamity, first help them, and then arrest the bastard who tried to profit off of it. The first smile will be gentle and gracious, and the second will be of pure glee.
- Consultant32452 7y agoIf the gouger actually bought them all then you have a monopoly, which is a different problem. The gauger, instead, bought some. So did many other people. The difference is he's willing to sell his. That's the value to me he's providing. Could you retry your analysis with this corrected information?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- MisterBastahrd 7y agoDoesn't matter if he bought all or some. If he is attempting to profit off of a disaster, he will be seeing a fine or jail time in plenty of states.
- Chris2048 7y agoShould for-profit grave-digging be illegal too?
- MisterBastahrd 7y agoThe fun thing about a lot of people dying is that the government will take care of the bodies for you. Try another strawman tactic, my dude. That one missed the mark.
- Chris2048 7y agoA strawman is an irrelevant argument, but this one is perfectly relevant: A grave-digger makes money in the event of death, it needn't be during an epidemic, "my dude" (or whatever patronising, PA phrase you prefer) If people shouldn't profit off disaster, why profit from any misfortune?
- Consultant32452 7y agoI think we're talking about two different things. I'm talking about whether or not a price gouger provides the service of making some product available on the market, albeit at a higher price. I feel that fact is indisputable and I personally find that valuable. You seem focused on whether or not you consider this action of making something available to me is moral/legal. That's a different question altogether. One which I'm explicitly not commenting on.
- birdyrooster 7y agoRight and yet most everyone in this thread can agree that it wouldn’t be the most prudent use of it when there are other lives more at risk than yours.
- birdyrooster 7y agoIt’s likely people forget what economy was even for. It doesn’t exist solely to serve itself, well I suppose it could if you are a true masochist, but instead a means to an end: health, happiness, freedom, etc
- Consultant32452 7y agoIn reality I have not gone out and purchased overpriced goods. I'm wearing a cloth mask when I go out. In the hypothetical, you have no idea whose life is more at risk. And the central planners who want to implement price fixing, purchasing quotas, etc. do not have much if any more insight than you.
- sk5t 7y agoWatch out of you'll end up in a debate about whether and how HFT and front-running are good for the Main Street investor...
- koheripbal 7y agoI don't think anyone defends front-running. It's illegal in various forms for good reasons. A _manufacturer_ charging more is not _front-running_.
- jcranmer 7y agoThe guy buying up all the masks and reselling them is likely buying them in similar markets to the people who he will be selling them to eventually. His net effect is likely going to be doing diddly squat to the availability.
- Consultant32452 7y agoNone are available to purchase at the old, lower price, because demand at the old price outpaced production. The higher price drives some consumers out of the market, meaning there are still some for sale.
- jbay 7y agoDemand at the old price from people who bought them to resell at the new price?
- tristor 7y agoMostly, because the guy buying them all up to resell at 10x the price is a scumbag just like ticket scalpers, except worse because whether you pay $500 or $200 to get a ticket to a rock concert won't potentially kill you. The availability is primarily negatively impacted because of hoarders and gougers.
- Consultant32452 7y agoDo you believe that, absent price gougers, I would be able to walk into Home Depot, CVS, Walmart, etc. and buy some N95 masks for my personal use? I don't think that's likely, so wherever you were heading with that is irrelevant. I want to be clear I'm intentionally separating two things. The gouger is making product available on the market where otherwise there would be none. The higher price discourages hoarders or others with lower needs. This is clearly a valuable service that some, perhaps many, are willing to pay for. I feel like these are indisputable facts. There is a separate topic of moralizing about the issue, whether or not you think the gouger is a bad actor or whatever. You can keep going on about that, but I won't address it because I don't care about your feelings regarding my personal health.
- downerending 7y agoThis posits a simplistic economy where everyone can predict the future. The real world has risk and unknown effects. If someone stockpiles a lot of masks on the chance that they'll be needed, hoping to thereby profit, they're taking significant risk, and reward for that is not unreasonable. This is essentially how finance, banking, markets, and pretty much our whole economy work. The idea that producers should only be able to charge a modest margin over their "costs" is pernicious nonsense. Furthermore, if you punish this sort of risk-taking intensely enough, producers will just shut down during unusual times (the exact opposite of what is needed).