3 ms·
The best theory I've seen for crash cycles is: 1. The establishment encourages making credit widely available in order to pacify the less well off who would ot
by nicoburns 7y ago
The best theory I've seen for crash cycles is:
1. The establishment encourages making credit widely available in order to pacify the less well off who would otherwise demand a better deal out of the social contract.
2. This leads to unsustainable debt, as people are forced into borrowing to meet basic needs with no means to pay it back.
3. Eventually this comes to a head as people begin to default, causes a cascading chain through the economy as people are unable to meet their obligations, leading to crash.
4. At which point, governments step in and debt is forgiven, correcting the imbalance created in step 1.
Seemed to make a lot of sense to me. And the interesting thing is that it suggests a solution: replace widely available credit with direct wealth redistribution and you end up with the same net effect (as the debts are being forgiven in the end anyway), but without the destructive boom-bust cycles.
- Scea91 7y ago> 2. This leads to unsustainable debt, as people are forced into borrowing to meet basic needs with no means to pay it back. People borrow for much more than basic needs and they do so voluntarily without anyone forcing them. This does not substantially affect your logic, but I think lots of the blame for mismanaging debt lies at the people in debt themselves.
- nicoburns 7y agoHmm... they do, but this is actively incentivised with low interest rates, which directly inventivise borrowing, and also have secondary effects, such as easily available mortgages leading to increased house prices, which leads to further borrowing. You can also see this in student loans. Sure, people volutarily choose to take them out. But this is because they live in a society where access to a lot of jobs is gated on having a degree, and degrees are so expensive that a loan is the only option more often than not.
- ianleeclark 7y ago> People borrow for much more than basic needs and they do so voluntarily without anyone forcing them. People can be forced without there being an "anyone" to do the forcing. Being underemployed in some expensive city, unable to make your next car payment that you need to get to your job doesn't require an "anyone" to force that person into a loan at gunpoint. They're still being coerced into that decision, even if there isn't an "anyone."
- smnplk 7y agoThe way I see it, it's the cheap money problem. Big businesses with lots of capital are incentivized to borrow cheap money and make stupid investments with that borrowed money.
- oDot 7y agoThe establishment you describe in step 1 is the government. Wall street could not do what they do now without government involvement. They will run out of money, and have to suffer the losses of the bad loans they make, instead of relying on the Fed to save them by depreciating the money of regular working people.
- nicoburns 7y agoAgreed. Although one might note that those involved in wall-street are highly likely to be amongst those voting for conservative governments that are enacting these policies.
- oDot 7y agoBoth aisles, conservatives and leftists, support Cronyism with their actions. It was the Bush adminstration that came up with the plan the save Wall Street, and it was Obama's that passed that plan, in one form or another.
- nicoburns 7y agoAgreed that cronyism is a problem across the political spectrum. Supporting cheap debt, and its use as a tool to prop up political support for otherwise uneven wealth distribution is something else though. Letting organisations like Wall Street pay for their stupid risks is one way of dealing with the problem. But IMO not particularly workable one due to all of the colateral damage it would inflict on ordinary people. We need to prevent this behaviour before it happens. That means making our economy less reliant on finance. I would argue that there has been no truly left government in either the US or the UK (where I live) since Reagan/Thatcher introduced this style of economics in the 80s.
- eru 7y agoHow does step 2 work? Are the creditors fools?