5 ms·
> There isn't an alternative. There is an alternative: distribute wealth. On aggregate people tend to behave a lot more rationally than individuals do. So if y
by nicoburns 7y ago
> There isn't an alternative.
There is an alternative: distribute wealth. On aggregate people tend to behave a lot more rationally than individuals do. So if you spread the buying power as widely as possible then you get a more rational market.
- Kaiyou 7y agoNot really, individuals may make mistakes, but it's nothing to the insanity a mass of people is capable of. (Source: Mass Psychology, by Gustave LeBon) Distributing wealth is self-destructive behavior. Generally, you want wealth in capable hands, who can use this wealth to create more wealth. You don't just want to piss it away.
- ceejayoz 7y agoThe idea that wealth inequality is just due to it going to "capable hands" is a hell of an unsupported assertion. "Pissing it away" is also known as buying things, which drives economic growth. The poor spend every penny they make, and this is generally considered good for the economy.
- missedthecue 7y agoInvestment drives growth, not consumption.
- nicoburns 7y agoAnd small investments tend to have better returns.
- ceejayoz 7y agoInvestment requires returns, which mean people have to consume the resulting product, be it goods or services.
- missedthecue 7y agoYes, one can't exist without the other, but economically speaking, it's impossible to consume your way to prosperity. You must increase productivity, and this is done through investment. We tried consuming our way to prosperity during the housing bubble in the early 2000s. That turned out how you might expect.
- Kaiyou 7y agoBuying stuff doesn't facilitate growth. Look at all the toilet paper people buy recently. Where's your growth?
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>On aggregate people tend to behave a lot more rationally than individuals do. Just delegating responsibility for resource allocation to groups of people is not a silver bullet. "Aggregate people" tasked with distributing wealth (or taking wealth and converting it to some resource and distributing that) seems to be highly succeptable to holding onto more and more of that wealth over time for trickle down distribution within it's own organization. Large nonprofits regularly come under fire for using too much of their income on their leadership and luxury fluff for themselves. Governments routinely spend their income paying themselves and paying for pork for their friends and paying for fluff instead of making people's lives good. Religions tend to amass more and more wealth until some sub-group tells them to shove it and historically this results in violence. You could fill libraries with the volume of work written about all the ways organizations become corrupted and self serving and fail to achieve their goal.
- nicoburns 7y agoI don't think you're quite grasping what "distributing the wealth" would look like. I have in mind something like a Universal Basic Income. Reducing the involvement of large organisations (including governments, non-profits and corporations), as well at high-net worth individuals is entirely the point. It's basically democracy for economic power. And you're right, it's not a silver bullet. But I believe it could be a significant improvement on the status quo.