3 ms·
It's really too late to manage this. Testing hasn't been made available in time mostly due to total failure to plan and political decisions not to manage any of
by LatteLazy 7y ago
It's really too late to manage this. Testing hasn't been made available in time mostly due to total failure to plan and political decisions not to manage any of this.
All we can do now is turn up and down the level of isolation depending on how many ventilators and ICU beds are available. We will have to do that on a sort of feedback, trial and error basis because we lack capacity and what capacity we do have is being wasted.
The only question is whether anyone will be held accountable for this colossal mess and the preventable deaths its caused, or if we will just accept this happening ever 5 or so years...
- arrrg 7y agoDepends. If active cases can be pushed down to a mange-able level (i.e. a level where contact tracing is a realistic option and outbreaks can be, by and large, contained) a return to relative normalcy could still be possible. So that’s another one, two months of tight lockdown to push down active cases (to, say, 500 in the NY area). Then it becomes feasible to throw massive amounts of people at those 500 cases and to do aggressive contact tracing and quarantining of all contacts. Maybe just by people interviewing the infected, calling around, playing detective (a bit slow), maybe also with the help of contact tracing through mobile phones. Also, you obviously would need to be able to test for the virus (ideally) whenever someone shows the slightest hint of related symptoms (and since those are so unspecific and not exactly rare you would have to expand testing capability). Some measures will obviously stay in place, but many of the most drastic and impactful ones could be reduced since there wouldn’t really be uncontrollable community spread. That, to me, sounds like a realistic plan (unlike a complete lockdown until then or trying to let the wave wash over us) for the time until we have a vaccine and until that vaccine is availible in sufficient quantities. Of course, this depends a lot on whether we can push down active cases so low. South Korea seems to be nearly or already there. Of course we do not know whether China tells the complete truth, but even if they lie quite a bit they are also probably nearly or already there. Outbreaks with exponential growth haven’t happened there at least, of that we can be relatively certain (because that would be hard to hide). So, yeah, it’s probably possible if we can push effective R a bit below zero for a couple of weeks to get into a position where we can regain control. Maybe. Hopefully.
- LatteLazy 7y agoI don't disagree with the plan. It's our only option. But how will we implement it? We have no idea how many active cases their are in the NY area (I assume you mean NYC). And we don't know how many people require hospitalization. So you cannot estimate back from the hospitalized numbers. Plus, that would only tell you how many people we infected a week ago. Except that even that isn't certain because we don't know how long between infection and hospitalization. And all of these numbers depend on what pre-existing conditions (including age) a patient has. So are we over the worst of it or is it just starting? Should we increase or decrease our lock down right now? And before you answer, getting it wrong won't be noticed for at least a week (or more if the 1 week incubation figure is wrong, which it is), and in that time any mistake will kill tens of thousands or burn $100bn dollars. This is what we get for testing senators and NBA stars when we should have been studying populations. China blind sided us with this once by lying about it and covering it up. But we have blind sided ourselves as well by lacking any leadership and ignoring experts. This whole thing as been a huge lesson in how badly western governments are currently running. The slightest hint of a problem and it's every man for himself.
- alkonaut 7y agoTesing is still needed at a high rate for patients and hospital staff. But I agree testing millions when you have uncontrolled spread isn't "managing" the outbreak. It's a charade because people have been screaming "more tests" for weeeks. Test only when you can actually take action with the result, such as giving different treatment, tracing contacts. When the outbreaks in different places are suppressed, you can go back to testing and tracing again.
- eanzenberg 7y agoTests have false positive and false negative rates of ~20%. Start testing millions and not only do you waste tons of money but inadvertently put millions of people in danger.
- LatteLazy 7y agoRespectfully, I think you are exactly wrong. Testing 1 person makes no difference at all to the treatment of that person because like you say it's not accurate enough to be sure and because we have no (edit: Specific) treatment for Covid-19 that isn't just the same as any other similar infection. Whether you're tested positive, negative or not tested we will ventilate you if you need it and send you home otherwise. So why test any individual person? But if we had tested (and regularly re-tested) large groups, we would know: * What the range and controlling factors for gestation period are. This is important because you know when and how many people will start arriving in hospitals in the future. * How many people have the disease. Right now, we have very little idea if lots of people have had it already and not noticed and are quarantining for nothing. These are the asymptomatic. * How many people are asymptomatic but infectious. * Whether people can get it twice * What rate people actually require hospital places at. * What the R0 values are AND what they change to with different levels of social isolation. The lack of accuracy would not really matter because at that scale it just becomes error bars on values and that's fine. We can work with that. Those are the main pieces of information we need to actually "manage" this disease. Without them we are not managing, we are just guessing. Will their be less infections next week than last week? Will more or less people need ventilators? How many of the nurses and doctors in the building today will be available for work next week? Did closing schools actually help? Right now, the answer is no one knows. This could all be over in a week when infections suddenly drop because 80% of people have had it. Or it could be that only 3% of people have had it and we will need to maintain all this for another 20 months. No one knows because no one is testing large groups and making big data sets available for analysis. No one doctor can get 100k tests and use them on 20k people over 5 weeks. But the government could. But they're too busy testing each other and giving speeches and shorting the stock market. Sorry if that's a bit tin foil hat.
- 7y ago