5 ms·
> This assumes that people actually behave rationally. There isn't an alternative. If you assume people behave irrationally you may as well send the army in st
by roenxi 7y ago
> This assumes that people actually behave rationally.
There isn't an alternative. If you assume people behave irrationally you may as well send the army in straight away. People are often stupid but rarely irrational given what they can understand. There is pretty solid evidence that people with money are the ones who spend it rationally.
And besides a private buyer's opinion of what is rational is just as valid as anyone else's.
> If I may suggest you and a minority of others would be better served in such a situation and you are trying to construct an argument so as to justify a policy that would benefit yourself.
Yes? I'd like to live in a world where I can go to the store and buy toilet paper. Just like everyone else. This is not an unreasonable demand.
I'd like to see everything go back to normal as fast as possible, thanks. Policies that make it irrational to return to that happy equilibrium are not in my interests. We need producers and companies involved in consumer logistics to change their behaviors. Money is the fastest tool to do that.
Besides, seriously, why do you think people earn money if not to get first dibs on stuff they want? What do you think money is for? It isn't like everyone is going to get what they want, there is a massive shortage. Someone is going to have to do without. If someone has to do without we use money to figure out who. That is how life works in this era, and the eras before dating back to the invention of money. Price controls aren't going to win a war with the economy. It is more likely to take down the government than stop wealthy people getting what they want.
- michaelmrose 7y agoPeople are actually usually irrational. Predicting how people behave always involves building an elaborate mental model of the exact way that their own model diverges wildly from observable reality. The fact that they are rational by their own model doesn't mean they even kind of are objectively. The point is not that you desire to be able to buy TP its that you are willing to sacrifice the general well being for your own convenience. Hoarding of some non emergency items is self limiting and self correcting in a way that doesn't rob the poor of the ability to wipe their asses. It's a problem that doesn't need solving beyond the simple expedient of not allowing one person to buy too much of it to give other buys a chance. Your solution by contrast is actually more likely to shift whose hoarding it and why then solve the problem. If your position was apt then surely you can give one example of such a system working?
- lukas099 7y agoWhen prices of a thing go up, people buy less of that thing. If that were not true, I think somebody would have noticed by now.
- MaxBarraclough 7y ago> If you assume people behave irrationally you may as well send the army in straight away. This is false, as well as being a false dichotomy. We know people act at least somewhat irrationally. That's why we have laws on gambling. It doesn't mean sending in the military.
- altacc 7y agoThere is an alternative to assumming people behave rationally, which is to model behaviors based on large scale evidence, not clean ideals. This is pretty much why Sociology and Anthropology exist and are fairly complicated subjects. Economic modelling often fails because they assume a small number of rational and logic rules. But people are highly variable and rational for one person is irrational for another, depending upon experience and situations. Your claim that people with money spend it rationally is countered by evidence that poor people are often spending money rationally, given their situation, needs and income. Different situations lead to very different definitions of rational and "common sense". (Mental stress & fatigue also becomes a decision making factor at low income levels.)
- roenxi 7y ago> ... poor people are often spending money rationally ... I claimed that most people spent their money rationally. You're not countering me with that point, we're agreeing. If wealthy people make a habit of spending irrationally they go broke.
- me_me_me 7y agoThe whole point of marketing, which often account for over 50% of products' budget, is direct appeal to emotional/irrational aspect of human nature. Average person doesnt buy iphone because they need a new phone, or coke to quench their thirst.
- nicoburns 7y ago> If wealthy people make a habit of spending irrationally they go broke. This just isn't the case. Unless they're spending irrationally AND a large proportion of their wealth then spending irrationally is unlikely to make them go broke. And unfortunately some people have so much wealth that they can spend market-distorting amounts of money that are still a tiny fraction of their overall wealth.
- nicoburns 7y ago> There isn't an alternative. There is an alternative: distribute wealth. On aggregate people tend to behave a lot more rationally than individuals do. So if you spread the buying power as widely as possible then you get a more rational market.
- Kaiyou 7y agoNot really, individuals may make mistakes, but it's nothing to the insanity a mass of people is capable of. (Source: Mass Psychology, by Gustave LeBon) Distributing wealth is self-destructive behavior. Generally, you want wealth in capable hands, who can use this wealth to create more wealth. You don't just want to piss it away.
- ceejayoz 7y agoThe idea that wealth inequality is just due to it going to "capable hands" is a hell of an unsupported assertion. "Pissing it away" is also known as buying things, which drives economic growth. The poor spend every penny they make, and this is generally considered good for the economy.
- missedthecue 7y agoInvestment drives growth, not consumption.
- Nursie 7y ago> There isn't an alternative. Of course there is - look at how people actually behave given various stimuli, rather than presuming enlightened rationality. Enlightened rationality does not govern real actions, we know this, we have ample evidence of this, and making economic forecasts on this basis has been repeatedly exposed as a fools game.