4 ms·
Mr. Mouse has a good take on this but there is a second perspective that is worth considering: If we set up a dog-eat-dog world where only money matters, why w
by roenxi 7y ago
Mr. Mouse has a good take on this but there is a second perspective that is worth considering:
If we set up a dog-eat-dog world where only money matters, why would a billionaire hoard unneeded masks? They know that they can just buy what they need when the need it. The only people with incentive to hoard are poor and vulnerable people because they know they won't be able to afford masks when they run out. Entrepreneurial types looking for arbitrage will probably cause weird things to happen in the short term, but after a month or two things will rebound sharply to whatever the new normal is going to look like.
If this crisis has taught me anything, it was a mistake not to hoard. I assumed I would be able to buy what I needed at outrageous prices, instead I ran the risk of running out of toilet paper because prices stayed unreasonably low.
If bankrupting hoarders with high prices is going to be unacceptable, I'm going to become a hoarder out of necessity next time I see a crisis inbound. I'll stock up on much more toilet paper than I need because I can't predict when governments/major supermarkets/public at large will let me buy the stuff at market price; which is clearly a bit higher than what the supermarkets are charging.
- notauser 7y agoGiven that poor people can't afford to hoard because of the cost of storage (especially in cities) and financing, isn't it better that rich people are encouraged to hoard when supply is plentiful? The problem arises when rich people start hoarding at times when supply is constrained, because they can do it so much more rapidly and create a much greater shock to the system. It was notable in London that severe shortages only really existed at stores you can drive to. Stores that you can only walk to have been much better stocked.
- roenxi 7y ago> isn't it better that rich people are encouraged to hoard when supply is plentiful? The market signal that would make rich people hoard masks in the good times would be ... an expectation that if an unexpected crisis arose then prices would rise to extreme values. Nothing else is going to make that happen. Not even most governments manage to resist economising and running down their medical supplies after the last health scare they faced. I'm not going to hoard in good times because I'm not crazy; I know I can't be ready for everything. I'm just going to try and preempt everyone else at the start of a crisis. It won't work every time but that is the strategy that makes sense if the crisis response is includes 'stopping price-gouging'. If we allowed price gouging, I might seriously keep a few extra boxes of masks ready for selling to others the next time this happened. I like money. I have some shelf space. The only question is will prices go high enough to justify using it.
- croon 7y ago> I'm not going to hoard in good times because I'm not crazy; I know I can't be ready for everything. We don't want anyone hoarding (or gouging). However keeping TP enough for 2 weeks when supply was ample, whould have prevented this ever being an issue, and no gouging needed. TP production has never been an issue, the system shock of people panic buying (too much) all at once was. People aren't shitting more than before. I have about a month's supply of TP at home, and have only bought 10 rolls since this whole thing began. I am not a prepper nor a hoarder. I just like having a buffer of things I like not being without. There's a miniscule opportunity loss of storage and sunken cost, but I'm not spending any more than I would with just-in-time purchasing. > If we allowed price gouging, I might seriously keep a few extra boxes of masks ready for selling to others the next time this happened. I like money. I have some shelf space. The only question is will prices go high enough to justify using it. Great argument for not allowing price gouging then.
- code_duck 7y ago>People aren't shitting more than before. Like bananas, this is an issue of commercial and residential supply chains. Most commercial bathrooms have totally different toilet paper than home paper - thin, and on a huge roll. People are using the bathroom at home far more than before, since they’re not using it at restaurants, work or other public areas.
- lukas099 7y agoPlenty of poor people are hoarding, at least here in the US. They make room.
- WalterBright 7y agoAnti-gouging laws cause sensible people to hoard at the first sign of trouble.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoThey also arguably make people hoard less. If you can't resell for a large profit, there's no point in buying more than what you feel hedges your risk. So you'll buy 200 masks instead of 20 000. Disposable PPE is also funny in a way that it makes no sense to buy it unless you buy in bulk. If you can get 200 N95 masks for $20, it's OK. If you can buy 2 masks for $20, then you'd better spend $1000 or don't buy at all. A lot of people buying few masks each just wastes a whole supply of masks that could all go to one place (e.g. a hospital) where they would make a difference because there would be enough of them to be used properly.
- WalterBright 7y ago> They also arguably make people hoard less. There's no need to theorize or argue, the historical evidence is that price fixing (anti-gouging) leads to shortages (or gluts). https://www.amazon.com/Forty-Centuries-Wage-Price-Controls-ebook/dp/B004VHIIUC/ https://www.amazon.com/Forty-Centuries-Wage-Price-Controls-e...
- Firadeoclus 7y agoFear of gouging causes (some, whether sensible or not) people to hoard at the first sign of trouble.
- WalterBright 7y agoThe 1970s gas lines stopped immediately after Reagan, as his first act as President, signed an Executive Order eliminating oil & gas price controls. Literally overnight. And they never returned since.
- michaelmrose 7y agoThis assumes that people actually behave rationally. Do we have actual numbers on rich people buying TP during the present crisis? If most people including the rich are going to hoard anyway a rising price just transfers more money to sellers when many need it most. Worse it incentivizes people to buy for resale if the price is trending upward. TP selling for 200% that is headed to 400% shortly is a smarter buy than most stocks. Since people can't actually store infinite TP wouldn't all hoarders end up with the max TP they are willing to hold in a reasonable time frame after which more supply becomes available for everyone else. In the mean time most buyers haven't been wiping with leaves they expected more effort to visit more stores and ultimately settled on buying some inferior TP. It's not even clear that your suggestion would bring equilibrium faster. If I may suggest you and a minority of others would be better served in such a situation and you are trying to construct an argument so as to justify a policy that would benefit yourself.
- roenxi 7y ago> This assumes that people actually behave rationally. There isn't an alternative. If you assume people behave irrationally you may as well send the army in straight away. People are often stupid but rarely irrational given what they can understand. There is pretty solid evidence that people with money are the ones who spend it rationally. And besides a private buyer's opinion of what is rational is just as valid as anyone else's. > If I may suggest you and a minority of others would be better served in such a situation and you are trying to construct an argument so as to justify a policy that would benefit yourself. Yes? I'd like to live in a world where I can go to the store and buy toilet paper. Just like everyone else. This is not an unreasonable demand. I'd like to see everything go back to normal as fast as possible, thanks. Policies that make it irrational to return to that happy equilibrium are not in my interests. We need producers and companies involved in consumer logistics to change their behaviors. Money is the fastest tool to do that. Besides, seriously, why do you think people earn money if not to get first dibs on stuff they want? What do you think money is for? It isn't like everyone is going to get what they want, there is a massive shortage. Someone is going to have to do without. If someone has to do without we use money to figure out who. That is how life works in this era, and the eras before dating back to the invention of money. Price controls aren't going to win a war with the economy. It is more likely to take down the government than stop wealthy people getting what they want.