4 ms·
> I would love to see what's wrong with this particular article that's not true. May well be nothing. The gotcha here is not what is being said, but why it is
by baybal2 7y ago
> I would love to see what's wrong with this particular article that's not true.
May well be nothing.
The gotcha here is not what is being said, but why it is there in the first place.
- yorwba 7y agoAlso what is not being said. I do think Sixth Tone's writers are trying to do write informative articles instead of bland propaganda, but some topics are conspicuously absent. E.g. if you search for articles about Uyghurs: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=uyghur+site%3Asixthtone.com https://duckduckgo.com/?q=uyghur+site%3Asixthtone.com There's not much wrong with those articles, except for what's missing. Compare with the South China Morning Post, which is also sometimes accused of being propaganda, but it does cover critical topics: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=uyghur+site%3Ascmp.com https://duckduckgo.com/?q=uyghur+site%3Ascmp.com
- baybal2 7y agoFYI, Jun Mai lives and works out of Beijing, and seems to be doing that with ease. It is near impossible for HK journalists to get journalist visas for mainland China. Second, he does political reporting, in fact, he specialises on it. A foreign person is simply not doing political reporting in a country like China. Absolutely inconceivable, beyond some fully choreographed potemkin village tours. Third, what he puts in his writing, and very overt innuendos he makes from time to time feels very much like somebody doing a "write about this, and that" job. The logical, and thought flow simply doesn't feel like a news report. From the very beginning of his articles, he already has an argument given almost like a statement of a fact, and then he steers the reader towards that with random supporting arguments. In other words, he knows, from the start, reliable facts about current events he writes about. Fourth, where does his info comes from? A lot of things he wrote before could've only come from a first party source. How he gets access to state events to which even internal party press is not allowed? It is 100% clear to me that he is a part of a leaking operation, and very clumsily ran at that.
- ezVoodoo 7y agoWhy it is there? It sounds to me that you think the Chinese people do not have the right to write a blog and post it on the Internet. Then why are you posting here? Is there any particular reason that makes you NOBLE enough to write down your words and show them to people?
- baybal2 7y ago你好同志,你在哪里? Let's have a fruitful conversation
- yorwba 7y ago> It sounds to me that you think the Chinese people do not have the right to write a blog and post it on the Internet. baybal2 can be quite trollish, but he gets accused of pro-China bias much more frequently. This is actually the first time where I've seen the opposite accusation. One time, dang (who moderates the discussion here, in case you're not aware) even commented specifically to defend baybal2 and clarify that he's not a "pro-Chinese agent": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21195898 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21195898 Impressions based on single comment threads can be very misleading about the character of individual participants here.