5 ms·
As someone who lives in one of these states, I'm nonplussed at the announcement. It doesn't really seem to say anything concrete that I can tell. "We've agreed
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
As someone who lives in one of these states, I'm nonplussed at the announcement. It doesn't really seem to say anything concrete that I can tell.
"We've agreed that we will use metrics...we are still deciding what these metrics will be."
I thought the Stay Home, Stay Healthy order (in Washington state) wasn't unreasonable and wasn't just political babble, but I don't really know what to make of this piece. Anyone want to try to explain it like I'm five?
- kylemh 7y agoI think you're correct, but the announcement is still welcome. People are gonna be waiting forever for any semblance of federal guidance, so at least these 3 states has decided they'll make calls together.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIn this case, I would be vastly more comfortable if the answer were "No, Doreen, you really are as dumb as you think. Their plan is 1... 2.... 3...." The US governmental system has a long history of injecting bureaucratic nonsense that takes on a life of its own and ends up with outcomes like "teaching to the test" instead of being a net benefit. I would feel differently if this were an announcement of a joint task force for sharing data to help each state make the best decisions possible. But this sounds to me like it will just make it harder for each state to make a decision on their own and that it probably doesn't really add any value. And that concerns me.
- wahern 7y agoYeah, this falls far short of what these states should be saying, something like "We're feverishly working on building out the infrastructure for wide-scale population testing and tracing, but we will not lift shelter-in-place until we're confident the infrastructure is in place in all three states to contain any outbreaks". I have the same beef with Mayor Breed in San Francisco, who has otherwise shown standout leadership. She's publicly worried that people will let their guard done by assuming things are under control. Rather than worry about people's feelings and opinions, she should be setting expectations exactly as I described above.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI was just talking to someone yesterday about impaired vasodilation as a possible explanation for why people are dying at such high rates on ventilators. I'm hopeful that we will soon have some better treatments in place that will make this infection less deadly and thus less of a boogeyman.
- wolco 7y agoIt means these states will together decide when to reopen. A task force would provide that bureaucratic waste. What is the advantage of Oregon having more data to decide to reopen a week before California. The value of them standing together gives poltical shielding against a national government. They speak for the entire west coast. I wonder if other regions will do the same. Mountain states, Northern states, the South as a group wouldn't do this which would group them by subtraction.
- jschwartzi 7y agoIt almost sounds like we three states are preparing for some kind of federal intervention in our politics if we continue social distancing after Trump orders our states to reopen.
- mjcl 7y agoI think this is a polite way of these states saying that they're not going to follow any 'national plan to reopen the economy' put out by the White House.
- lisper 7y agoExactly right. One of the rules of the game is that you're not allowed to say anything negative about Donald Trump even if (perhaps especially if) it is factually correct. If you do, he will retaliate (by, for example, withholding badly needed aid). So the governors have to speak in code. Listen to Newsome's news conference today and the answer he gave to a reporter about his reaction to Trump's announcement that the decision to re-open the economy is his (Trump's) alone. It's a masterpiece.
- rlt 7y ago> If you do, he will retaliate (by, for example, withholding badly needed aid) Has this actually occurred? I know NY asked for way more ventilators than they got, but as I understood it they were giving them out "just in time" rather than up front in case they were needed more elsewhere.
- aboodman 7y agoYes, it was withheld for several days for Michigan: https://www.metrotimes.com/news-hits/archives/2020/03/28/after-demanding-praise-trump-finally-approves-coronavirus-aid-for-michigan https://www.metrotimes.com/news-hits/archives/2020/03/28/aft...
- jschwartzi 7y agoYes. Early in the outbreak, several of the western states including Washington asked for full FEMA aid but received nothing except some disaster counseling aid, while Florida received huge shipments of medical supplies. Trump as much as said he was waiting for Governor Jay Inslee of Washington to say something nice about him before opening up aid to Washington, which is unconscionable. We seem to be doing just fine here without the Federal Government. In fact we've sent 400 ventilators back to the national stockpile and we also returned the Army hospital that was established at Safeco Field back because we didn't need the capacity. Trump did eventually authorize FEMA to pay for the National Guard response here.
- zachkatz 7y agoMy ELI5 interpretation: “Since good leadership is probably not going to come from the President, we’re going to create our own “mini-country” and provide good leadership within it.”
- themodelplumber 7y agoYep, I agree that's a key point. It's easy to confuse big picture language with "nothing concrete" but a lot had to happen behind the scenes before this ever went to press. I'm personally optimistic because of this under-appreciated factor among many others.
- TheNewAndy 7y agoInstead of "mini-country", I would call just call it a group of united states.
- trhway 7y ago>a group of united states. Pardon, English being my 2nd language, would it be a confederation or a union?
- yellowapple 7y agoProbably depends on whether or not there are articles involved.
- szatkus 7y agoOr a commonwealth. https://fallout.fandom.com/wiki/United_States_of_America#Commonwealths https://fallout.fandom.com/wiki/United_States_of_America#Com...
- tathougies 7y agoYou mean a 'mini-alliance' right? Because the 10th amendment has made the states 'mini-countries' since 1787.
- jcranmer 7y agoThe context here is that Trump said earlier today that he was in charge of when to "open up the states." This (along with the NE pact) is probably a big "no, you're not" to Trump.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoAh, thank you. That actually makes some sense and is heartening.
- robocat 7y agoNE pact article: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/13/nyregion/coronavirus-new-york-update.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/13/nyregion/coronavirus-new-... ““” Asked whether the collaboration among the states was a rebuke to the President Trump, who has said the decision about businesses reopening was his to make, Gov. Philip D. Murphy of New Jersey said only that he was focused on making decisions based on facts and science, and he reiterated that an economic recovery was inextricable from a public health recovery. Gov. Tom Wolf of Pennsylvania echoed Mr. Murphy’s comments in responding to a similar question. “The sequence,” Mr. Wolf said, “is you’ve got to get people healthy first, and then you can reopen the economy.” Interviewed later on CNN, Mr. Cuomo was more pointed in his remarks on who bears responsibility for restoring life to something like normal. Trump administration officials, the governor said, could have enacted a nationwide shutdown to stem the spread of the virus. “They didn’t,” he said. “They said we’re going to leave it to the states. Now all of a sudden when it comes time to open the economy, now it’s back to the federal government’s responsibility?” “””
- lidHanteyk 7y agoThree concrete takeaways that are new to me, as an Oregonian: * Nursing homes, long-term care facilities, etc. will get some priority and focus. * Socioeconomically-disadvantaged communities are taking indirect impacts from mitigation measures, and they will also get some priority and focus. * We will not return to anything resembling normal until we have a way to efficiently test, track, and isolate at scale.
- JPKab 7y agoMy brother lives in Oregon. He was complaining to me the other day that Oregon's requirement that you are not allowed to pump your own gas is an obvious COVID transmission vector. To get gas in Oregon, he follows these steps: 1.) pull up to gas station 2.) Roll down window to hand attendant (who isn't wearing a mask, nor is required to) his debit card. 3.) Get card back from attendant. 4.) Sanitize the debit card 5.) Sanitize his hands 6.) Hope that the attendant is washing his hands, and that he didn't breathe COVID onto him through the open window. Not saying this isn't a great, noble effort. Just saying that, in some aspects, these states aren't doing a good job on obvious things within their own borders. Why the hell is Oregon still doing this, and not requiring masks from gas attendants anyway? Maybe it is required, but my brother told me he has yet to have an attendant wearing a mask, so possibly not enforced???
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI'm curious: Was that the law before the pandemic? If so, couldn't the pandemic be a good reason to campaign to change the law so Oregonians can pump their own gas?
- dahdum 7y agoThat law hasn't changed because it's essentially a jobs program. They did retcon equal access for the disabled / elderly in there, but the ADA covers it well enough for every other state.
- jmckib 7y agoIt's also part of the reason you can't buy liquor at a grocery store in Oregon. If we really need more pointless jobs, I'd rather the state just hire some people to dig holes and fill them back up. At least everybody else wouldn't be inconvenienced that way.
- jonas21 7y agoWhen pumping your own gas, you touch a pump handle and card reader that have been handled by hundreds of other people in the last few hours. Is that any better?
- xapata 7y ago> nonplussed It seems nonplussed has two, almost contradictory definitions: 1. (of a person) surprised and confused so much that they are unsure how to react. 2. (of a person) not disconcerted; unperturbed. The latter is an "informal" definition. This seems to be the process by which the word awful switched from meaning awe-inspiring to the opposite.
- DoreenMichele 7y agohttps://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/nonplussed https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/nonplussed unsure about what to say, think, or do : perplexed chiefly US : not bothered, surprised, or impressed by something I'm an American. "Not impressed" is the closest thing I am seeing to what I was trying to convey. Unmoved might be a good substitute word in this case.
- xapata 7y agoI'm an American, too. It's funny that those Merriam-Webster definitions are so mild. I've always "known" nonplussed to indicate a fairly extreme state, like gobsmacked. I quoted definitions from Google's search snippet.
- jschwartzi 7y agoIt's essentially saying that the governors of these three states aren't going to follow what Trump orders them to do unless the medical professionals and the state emergency management teams give the go-ahead. Trump has been downplaying the seriousness of the disaster since January. He contradicts the statements of his own staff in the same press conference as the staff speaks. He exuberantly proclaims the effectiveness of "treatments" that haven't been studied in any serious way. All this is to say that we can't trust any decision he makes. Contrast this with the way the Western governors have handled this. Inslee was one of the first governors to announce any kind of Social Distancing rules. And he followed Illinois in issuing a statewide Stay Home order that is probably the most restrictive such order in the states. There's a lot of evidence on the Washington DOH website that this is working and the spread of the disease is under control. The fact is that Trump's response is mostly to bury the problem and apply wishful thinking when he can't bury the problem. The governors in this union are taking a facts-based approach to solving the problem that has largely been successful. And so it's a really bad idea to do anything that Trump advises the country to do because he has a track record of making really bad decisions throughout this crisis.
- elihu 7y agoI guess it's significant that the three states have agreed in principle that they'll act together rather than each do their own thing. Maybe they can also be more ambitious in terms of testing and contact tracing by collaborating. They might also be able to collaborate in buying PPE and ventilators and so on rather than bidding against each other.