2 ms·
So this is supposed to be an example of good management? Looks more like an example of why Microsoft succeeded in spite of its management. I guess when you're
by edw519 18y ago
So this is supposed to be an example of good management?
Looks more like an example of why Microsoft succeeded in spite of its management. I guess when you're milking a monopolistic cash cow with crappy products, you really don't need good management.
Think about it. The CEO comes into a meeting with 6 levels of management and proceeds to treat his people like children by acting like a child himself and "teaching them a lesson".
I wonder what Mike Conte, Chris Graham, Pete Higgins, and Mike Maples were thinking during this charade.
With 6 levels of management, you'd think that the CEO would focus of the big picture, set the course, and trust his people to do their jobs.
Perhaps the best evidence that Bill Gates was too busy bullying and micromanaging was the book he wrote 3 years after this meeting, "The Road Ahead," which never even mentioned the word "internet". Imagine, the CEO of a multi-billion dollar technology company who didn't see the internet in 1994.
There are stories of him being upset with having to write that book because it made him take his eye off the ball. I always wondered what ball he was talking about. Thanks to Joel, now we know.
- chrisl99 18y agoI have a copy of the first edition of The Road Ahead. Here is the index entry for Internet: Internet, 3-4, 91-100, 91 activities on, 93-97 addresses on, 94 cost of use of, 97-99, 125 e-mail on, 96-97, 124-25 expectations for, 125 foundation of, 97 growth and evolution of, 91, 95-96 and information highway, 3-4, 89, 95, 100, 230, 246 and publication, 95, 123-25 real-time content on, 99 regulation of, 161-63, 204 revenue from, 125 and security, 95, 96, 145 software on, 100 and standards, 96 and telephone system, 99 and Windows, 64 and WWW, 94, 95, 193, 201
- edw519 18y agoWhat was I thinking? I obviously read something that was wrong. Looking for my source... [EDIT: I give up. I'm not looking anymore. I thought it may have been "Hard Drive" but it's not. So I either read something that was wrong or (more likely) I misinterpreted it. But I stand by my claim that Joel's meeting is an excellent example of mismanagement. If Bill Gates wasn't so busy maintaining an atmosphere of bullying and "see how smart I am" and instead was a real visionary, would there even be a Yahoo or Google today?]
- chrisl99 18y agoOne thing I should point out, is that although the 1st edition does have a fair bit of talk about the Internet, (even predicting things like VoIP), Gates uses the phrase "information highway" because he thought the Internet would be supplanted by something better: "...we stand at the brink of another revolution. This one will involve unprecedentedly inexpensive communication; all the computers will join together to communicate with us and for us. Interconnected globally, they will form a network, which is being called the information highway. A direct precursor is the present Internet..."
- hernan7 18y agoMaybe you could submit that to Snopes. I was another believer in the "no Internet in The Road Ahead" urban legend.
- neilc 18y agoPer Wikipedia: After the book was written, but before it hit bookstores, Gates recognized that the Internet was gaining the critical mass needed to drive it to dominance, and on December 7, 1995 — just weeks after the release of the book — he redirected Microsoft to become an Internet-focused company. Then he and coauthor Rinearson spent several months revising the book, making it 20,000 words longer and focused on the Internet. The revised edition was published in October 1996 as a trade paperback. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Road_Ahead http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Road_Ahead
- edw519 18y agoThank you! For a minute there, I thought I was losing what's left of my mind.
- bgutierrez 18y agoIt's an example of management that knows their business and takes knowing it seriously. In Joel's mind, this is good.
- akd 18y agoSteve Jobs is notorious for inspecting product prototypes and sending products back to the drawing board because a certain gap is half a millimeter too big. This is pretty much the same behavior as Gates exhibits in the story. This is bad management?
- edw519 18y agoThis is bad management? If you're doing the job of a subordinate and not your own job, then yes. Remember, there were 4 levels of manager in the room. What did they do? Did anyone trust them? The internet practically passed by the largest software company in the world while 6 levels of micromanagement were showing each other how smart they were. Yes, I'd call that bad management.