4 ms·
A “software engineer” should be required to be licensed
- RoyTyrell 7y agoWhile I think having the equivalent of the Professional Engineer (in the US) for software or hardware/electrical is probably a good idea for very critical products (self-driving cars, medical devices, planes, etc) distributed to the public, a blanket requirement would significantly impair a lot of the economy.
- Apocryphon 7y agoThe thread is a mess, but he clarifies that he's referring to those who develop software for "critical infrastructure."
- heldrida 7y ago"React Engineer". Cringe!
- uberman 7y agoIn many engineering disciplines one needs to be a "Professional Engineer" to well actually do engineering stuff (I'm looking at you Structural Engineering). In some places (Canada for example) the title is reserved exclusively (and by law) for those who got an accredited engineering degree and go on to apprentice under what would be a thought of as a PE in the USA. I personally don't have a problem with the title "engineer" being reserved for what would amount to a US "professional engineer". I'll note that PE don't require either an advanced degree nor a million dollar liability policy, so I'm not sure why such would be required from a "software engineer". Really in the end, I don't think programmers should be calling themselves architects or engineers. I feel like we do so because we covet the prestige associated with these professions, but work in one that is not old enough for our own secret societies or iron rings or titles. For what it is worth, internally in my company I have co-opted and use the title "Jedi Master". It is just as valid/invalid in my opinion as software engineer or architect and is way cooler.
- ThrowawayR2 7y ago> "I'll note that PE don't require either an advanced degree nor a million dollar liability policy, so I'm not sure why such would be required from a 'software engineer'." Leaking customer data for a medium sized business would probably easily exceed $1 million in emergency software fixes, PR, and goodwill (and that's leaving aside the cost to the customer), yet that happens constantly because of bad developers continuing to implement known bad practices.