3 ms·
I think an important thing to bear in mind is that we don’t have a choice. There seems to be a misconception that if we don’t bother with a lockdown and just ca
by simonh 7y ago
I think an important thing to bear in mind is that we don’t have a choice. There seems to be a misconception that if we don’t bother with a lockdown and just carry on as normal, just with a bit of social distancing, that we can accept higher deaths but save the economy. We can’t. A study of the economic effects of the Spanish Flu shows that cities which locked down hardest and earliest actually suffered less long term economic impact than cities that didn’t[0].
There’s no such thing as an option to “choose the economy”, the Spanish Flu shows us this. Aside from the millions of deaths this could lead to, and completely crushing the health care system, there would also be many tens of millions of people sick and unable to work, plus many tens of millions of people stuck caring for them. A lot of people would choose to stay at home anyway, especially as the carnage reached its peak. There’s just no way for the economy not to take an existentially threatening impact.
This article is shocking, and I believe it’s right, but we need to buckle down and make some really hard choices about how to tackle this thing. However long term I am an optimist. The work force should largely survive and our capital investments still exist. We’ve got used to historically very low inflation, but a dose of inflation over the next 5 to 10 years could actually give use the the flexibility to spread out and absorb the costs across the economy and society. As a fiscal conservative I can’t believe I’m saying this, but there it is.
[0] https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/04/pandemic-economy-lessons-1918-flu/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/04/pandemic-economy-less...
- standardUser 7y agoToday, Denmark, Austria and Czechia are all beginning to ease their lockdowns and allow parts of their economies to re-open. Their approach requires a spectrum of modern technologies and capabilities that were simply not available 100 years ago. The Spanish Flu may not be the most useful analogy for us to keep turning to. The last hundred years were a doozy.
- simonh 7y agoThis is true, as I said Im an optimist longer term. And yes, we shouldn’t need to stay under the harshest restrictions permanently. We need to flatten that curve and spread it out, but can’t expect to eliminate it completely. China shows that with a tight lockdown, you can gradually ease restrictions and get back to work. The behaviours people learn during the lockdown hopefully stick and enable us to resume critical economic activity, applying fresh lockdowns tactically as local outbreaks return.
- drsim 7y agoWhat modern technologies and capabilities here vs. other places? Living in Denmark I see the 'success' as being fairly early with simple social distancing and closing borders.
- Mediterraneo10 7y agoOnce the lockdown is lifted in various countries, regular testing of the population and electronic-assisted contract testing is planned so that the numbers of infected don't begin swelling again. Those kinds of proactive measures did not exist a century ago.
- standardUser 7y agoNot versus other places, but versus 100 years ago. A lot of the capabilities are logistics and communication. Here is an article I found earlier today talking about some of the specifics of reopening schools in Denmark: https://www.thelocal.dk/20200413/schools-and-day-care-centres-gear-up-for-staggered-and-restricted-reopening https://www.thelocal.dk/20200413/schools-and-day-care-centre... The kind of planning and communication necessary to pull that off was not possible 100 years ago, not to mention the scientifically-informed guidelines for preventing transmission.
- simonh 7y agoAbsolutely. The earlier measures are put in place and the better they are observed, the less severe they need to be. However for a small country like Denmark luck definitely plays a part. Looking at the USA there’s no obvious reason why New York has been so severely affected compared to say Los Angeles or Chicago, it just depends how early the virus started getting traction. It seems a small number of very socially mobile people can give the virus a massive kick-start. There doesn’t seem to be any particular reason why what happened in Lombardy couldn’t have happened in Denmark.
- drsim 7y agoIt is curious. I feel that Danes have a strong sense of social, collective responsibility. High education levels, generous social security net. In a pandemic my observation is that these things can play a strong role in stopping the spread (or an authoritarian stance).
- vearwhershuh 7y agoThat's an impossibly certain statement given the evidence you have offered. The linked article does not say that the cities locked down, only that they implemented what they call Non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs). They didn't say that they locked everyone inside. The evidence offered shows that the west wasn't has hard hit as the east. I can think of all sorts of confounding variables in that situation, particularly back then when the east was much more heavily industrialized. It is possible that if we had quarantined the at risk population and focused our efforts on reasonable NPIs such as masks and social distancing, we could have kept the economy open, leading to far less suffering and death in the long run. Hysterical black-and-white choices like we are being given are their own form of gas-lighting.
- jonathankoren 7y agoWhat do you think “non pharmaceutical intervention” are? It’s quarantines. It’s masks. And yes, there were quarantines as dramatic as today’s. Case in point: St Louis. https://www.history.com/news/spanish-flu-pandemic-response-cities https://www.history.com/news/spanish-flu-pandemic-response-c...
- vearwhershuh 7y agoOK. Did LA? Portland? Seattle? Seattle rebounded the fastest, what did they do? (Of course this is a pointless question, it was a completely different time and the data here is impossibly corrupt and old.) Are there other variables involved? Were those different times? Grand Rapids had the lowest mortality rate and, if I'm reading the chart right, had no NPIs. Why? People pushing these hysterical false dichotomies (coupled with a hefty amount virtue signalling) are going to be responsible for a huge amount of human suffering in the coming months and years.
- sbuttgereit 7y agoI think this line of reasoning oversimplifies what those of us that want to see economic impacts addressed (at least some portion of us) really are expecting. I have been cautiously supportive of the lock downs, but I'm greatly concerned that policy makers are simply not playing the long game. I hear far too many speeches in the "think of the children" category of emotional appeals, talk of sacrifice, and very little else other than wait it out. Really? I want to hear the plan about ramping up testing so we can actual get a sense of the real level of danger of the disease. I want to understand how that testing can inform who can go back to work and under what conditions. I want to hear the plans related to scaling up how we deal with the sick. Or, I want a clear expression of why locking down and just waiting it out doesn't lead to civil breakdown. But indefinite lock-downs are not a plan. They aren't insightful nor are the particularly clever, though they are more clever than just ignoring the situation. That we needed to buy time I get. I am increasingly thinking that the time we're buying is being squandered by policy makers that simply aren't up to the task. I found the study you linked interesting, though I wish it discussed more the differences in what they called NPI (non-pharma interventions) between then and now. Also, I'm not sure how far the economic comparisons hold; we have much longer and substantially more integrated supply chains than we did back then. Information flows are also significantly faster now and this allows for much less inventory keeping (think just in time manufacture), so I would expect higher resiliency in some sense to disruptions in the past than we have today. I'm armchair quarterbacking this a bit, I work with companies that make or distribute stuff so I can make some educated guesses, so I'm less convinced how far the previous pandemic can inform our economic actions for the current one.
- Loughla 7y ago>I want to hear the plan about ramping up testing so we can actual get a sense of the real level of danger of the disease. I want to understand how that testing can inform who can go back to work and under what conditions. I want to hear the plans related to scaling up how we deal with the sick. I would throw my support behind literally any candidate that laid out any of these things clearly. Any candidate at any level. Because not one of them, nationally, at the state level, or locally, are even attempting this. It's like they're just hoping a month long lock-down will cure the problem. Poof, magic. > I am increasingly thinking that the time we're buying is being squandered by policy makers that simply aren't up to the task I 100% agree with this. The lock down for my state has been in effect for a while now. And it seems like not one thing has changed, except for the rhetoric is becoming more and more wishful, instead of hopeful. There seems to be zero plan about how to come out of this without another massive spike in cases. No talk of testing. No talk of what services will open with priority. No talk of anything but 'stay home'. That's well and good (and I do love it), but what about next month? What happens when we have done nothing and have another spike in cases because we wished ourselves into doing nothing?