2 ms·
Idealistic argumentation in favor of being pedantic: Pedantic is about being correct. There are too many misconceptions and misunderstandings around. * Being p
by hutzlibu 7y ago
Idealistic argumentation in favor of being pedantic:
Pedantic is about being correct. There are too many misconceptions and misunderstandings around. * Being pedantic is an effort to reduce them.
So if people are pedantic out of idealism, I do not mind it. Here on hacker news it comes often in the form of a side comment "nitpick this and this is actually Y"
Which I like.
It is only annoying, if people are pedantic "to win the argument" which never helps the discussion.
* even in our language. like the word atom, for example. It means undividable, but today we clearly know atoms are dividable. And millions of other examples. So a discussion never leads to anything, if all the people involved are overly pedantic ...
- jasode 7y ago>Pedantic is about being correct. [...] Being pedantic is an effort to reduce them. At the risk of my comment being pedantic about "pedantic", the context of how "pedantic" is typically thrown around is to alert readers of a hyper-correction that doesn't matter to the discussion.[0] For example, if I say that some smarthome intelligent light switches sometimes have a 1/2 second lag instead of being "instant on" which is jarring to the user experience, a debater in pedantic mode would then say something like "even a regular dumb light switch isn't truly instant because of General Relativity, it _still_ takes picoseconds to propagate the flick of the switch action to the state change in the light radiation, blah blah blah" That so-called "correction" is _true_ but not material to the actual type of discussion. The discussion was consumer UI and not physics. If the context is UI, it's actually ok to be a little sloppy with what "instant" means. The underlying issue is that each commenter cannot write <billions qualifiers> before each statement. Therefore, the qualifier words we omit lets others pounce on a seemingly glaring hole in the argument (i.e. not reading with charity) and reply with something pedantic. [0] Excerpt from MW dictionary https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/pedantic#faqs https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/pedantic#faqs: >Is pedantic an insult? Pedantic is an insulting word used to describe someone who annoys others by correcting small errors, caring too much about minor details,
- hutzlibu 7y agoOk, so lets be pedantic about pedantic about the argument pedantic ... I know. Thats why I said: " it comes often in the form of a SIDE COMMENT "nitpick this and this is actually Y" Which I like." And "So a discussion never leads to anything, if all the people involved are overly pedantic ..."
- marktangotango 7y agoI see what you did there.
- hutzlibu 7y agoMade an argument, a bit in the form of "devils advocate"?