8 ms·
An Ode to Driving in America
- woodrowbarlow 7y agoas problematic as cars are in america (for suburban sprawl, environmental reasons, and equal access to opportunities) there is a uniquely enjoyable element of americana to it. the final fantasy 15 game captured this really well.
- kodablah 7y agoTFA mentions "open road" in subtitle, then proceeds with anecdotes of city driving on the coasts sipping chain coffee. That's a very small representation of driving in America.
- Causality1 7y agoThis bears repeating. Driving in major cities is, to me, one of the most miserable experiences to be found on the face of the earth.
- ohples 7y agoNot just that, living (or just being in) a city with cars is also terrible. Its lose lose for everyone.
- sfkdjf9j3j 7y agoWell, it's a win for the suburban dwellers whose weekend visits to the city are subsidized and accommodated by the people who live there full time.
- Causality1 7y agoSubsidized in what way? Cities still have to have roads for buses and delivery trucks and the vast majority of road wear comes from semi-trucks so it isn't the roads themselves. Are you saying the visits are subsidized on the basis of the increased traffic costing the city more money than it receives from the tourist dollars spent by the visitors?
- ohples 7y agoBuses and delivery truck don't need giant parking lots, which can't be used for anything else.
- Causality1 7y agoDo you know a lot of major cities with large amounts of free parking? When city land becomes valuable enough that people in parking lots don't generate more wealth than they would if there wasn't a parking lot, the parking lots get sold and buildings are put there instead.
- ohples 7y agoI wish that were the case but there are minimum parking laws in place in a lot of place that prevents that. And yes most cities I've been to tend not to charge for parking at night or on the weekends.
- Causality1 7y agoSuch a bizarre practice. Demand on the weekends is highest and logically the parking fees should be highest, not zero. I'm not one from whom to take advice on the subject, though. I think roads are for driving and parking on them is perverse and I refuse to live anywhere crowded enough to have a bus system.
- panzagl 7y agoAuthor is from UK, so maybe the Jersey Turnpike seems like the open road. Would love to get his take on driving in Wyoming or Montana though.
- stevenleeg 7y agoWhat about an Ode to the MTA? Or an Ode to Amtrak? Or an Ode to MUNI? An ode to the bike lane! I think the last thing the United States needs is more people glorifying the horrendous car culture that has been built up in this country.
- mdszy 7y agoLet people enjoy things.
- jaywalk 7y agoPeople like you are exactly why this ode is needed.
- helipad 7y agoI suspect 'Ode to Amtrak' is one of the Led Zeppelin songs the author was referring to.
- empath75 7y agoIt’s hard to reform a thing if you don’t understand why people like it.
- infecto 7y agoOde to needles on Bart? But seriously. You cannot ignore the the importance that cars have played in America. Ya ya ya, cars are terrible, Europe is better but also much smaller. I am definitely looking to the future and hope we design smarter cities but we cannot ignore the past. None of the options you listed are part of Americana imo.
- Aloha 7y agoQuite arguably in our mythos, the car effectively replaced the horse.
- danans 7y ago> we cannot ignore the past. None of the options you listed are part of Americana imo. To the contrary, commuter rail transit systems, primarily streetcars, were very much a feature of American cities from Cincinnati to San Francisco in the period from the late 1800s through the mid-century. Ignoring them is, as you yourself say, ignoring the past. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetcars_in_North_America https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetcars_in_North_America
- RajuVarghese 7y agoAh yes. This article does resonate. I've been living in Europe for 40 years but I learned to drive in the US. I loved the wide open of the country and the fact that everything is setup with cars in mind. Classic rock radio: that's the ultimate when on a holiday in a rented car in the US. I can fully understand the sentiment of the author.
- sq_ 7y agoFor all the faults our driving culture has created, there's definitely something calming for me about the whole thing (once you're outside the crush of big-city traffic). Kinda related to what the author says in the article, there's just something about hitting the road, either alone or with a friend, playing some classic rock, and just driving (whether or not there's a destination) that gives me space to think and is soothing. Not sure why or if anyone else has the same experience.
- panzagl 7y agoIt's a 'in the zone' experience.
- ip26 7y agoI'd always heard that, and so growing up I tried the whole "go for a drive" thing many times. I found it felt good in the moment, but when I got home I was just as wrapped around the axle as when I left. I came to think of it as something like trying to drown your problems in ̶a̶l̶c̶o̶h̶o̶l̶ petrol. I've found moderate exercise has a more lasting effect.
- martythemaniak 7y agoDriving anywhere in the world is probably my favourite thing to do while on vacation. Spend a few days in the city, then grab a rental car and start driving. You can take the smaller roads, stop at random villages for coffee, stop by the side of the road next to a fruit tree, an overlook, a plaque or just some scenery you like. There's a dizzying array of things you can see and do which are completely inaccessible to users of mass transit. The vastness of North America certainly has it's own charm and driving the vast distances can put you in a very relaxed, calm, meditative state, which is very different than say, slowly winding your way through the narrow dirt roads Costa Rica's Nicoya Peninsula. But they're both great and a great way to really understand a place.
- core-questions 7y agoThe anti-car crowd has missed this, somehow, in their lust to convert all of us to lemmings that can only get around with mass transport. There's an incredible sense of freedom that comes with a car: you can go where you choose, when you choose, without filing a flight plan or getting a ticket or anything other than fueling the thing up. When you're dealing with something on the scale of North America, it's hard to imagine going without. As a Canadian, there are places here that mass transit can never dream of taking me. Am I to never go to these places?
- naravara 7y agoYou realize you can have a lot more enjoyable driving experiences if you enable all the people who only drive for instrumental reasons to get off the roads right? Nobody is "anti-car." People are anti-city-planning-that-requires-you-to-use-a-car-every-day-in-order-to-be-a-functioning-member-of-society.
- pubstik 7y agoEven "pro-car" people are in favor those who would rather not drive keeping off the roadways. This is a strawman on both sides of the argument. Clearly a functional public And private transport infrastructure are both useful to everyone who also leaves their domicile.
- brickmort 7y agoHere in my car, I feel safest of all. I can lock all my doors It's the only way to live In cars!
- optymizer 7y ago<rant> My biggest complaint with driving on highways in the US is that people generally tend to arrange themselves in a checkerboard pattern, taking up all the lanes, despite all the signs that say that the left lane is for passing. I think it's because everyone wants their own lane, so they can cruise. It's not a case of 'a few bad apples'. Anecdotally, about 1/3 of the cars actually let you pass, the others don't give a rat's ass, slowing down the traffic for no reason. Speaking of cruising, my second complaint is how most don't use cruise control. It's painfully obvious, because the other cars slow down significantly when going up the hill and accelerate downhill. I see the same cars passing me, downhill, then ending up behind me uphill. It's so annoyingly unnecessary. If your car doesn't have adaptive CC, that means you have to turn on/off the CC frequently. The traffic ends up stretching and compressing like a rubber band. It doesn't have to be that bad - just use cruise control. To contrast this experience, I had the pleasure of driving in Portugal (from Porto to Sagres). They have by far the most respectful drivers I've ever seen anywhere (and I drove in Western and Eastern Europe, Middle East and North America). Good job Portugal, the rest of the world's drivers could learn a thing or two from you. </rant>
- timerol 7y agoI agree with you that Americans don't know how to use lanes, but I want to push back on the cruise control comment. Many cars have cruise control set differently, and "keep the speedometer at exactly X" is not the algorithm generally in play. I was once part of a caravan with a sedan, pickup truck, and 15 passenger van where we all yelled at each other for not using cruise control until we realized that we all were using cruise control the whole time, but needed to adjust it to not interfere with each other on hilly roads. If you want the best highway fuel efficiency, programming a cruise control to slow down uphill and go a bit faster downhill is the right way to go. How much faster or slower depends on the engine and current weight of the automobile, which is why the three examples were so wildly different.
- leetcrew 7y agoon very hilly roads, I like to hit the crest of the hill at least 10 mph below my target speed so I don't have to ride the brakes all the way down. imo, this is fine as long as you don't do it in the left lane. my car has a standard transmission so cruise control isn't super useful in this situation anyway, as I tend to change gears a lot.
- jerzyt 7y agoI have a second home in the mountains surrounding LA, and it's such a joy to go out there for a few days. I love driving the curvy mountain roads. It's just exhilarating. Nowadays, with the Covid-19 quarantine, I'm taking circuitous path to go grocery shopping, just to get a little extra "me time" on the road.
- zip1234 7y agoI understand why people like driving. I drive plenty and have two cars and live in the USA. There is no option but to drive in most of the US, so people do and it can even be enjoyable. It really is a tragedy of the commons situation though. Great and horrible at the same time.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 7y agoAnecdote from the old country. I used to live in a relatively small city in the old country ( 50K maybe ). As a kid, I was able to walk just about anywhere. And I did. As most of my friends, I did what I could to get my DL equivalent and as soon as I got it, I drove everywhere I could. I think this is the point that occasionally is forgotten in these conversations. It is not just that the infrastructure forces behavior ( in US, in most areas it does ), but the convenience factor makes it a very hard proposition to just ban cars from cities ( in a way similar to France's ). But it is hard to argue against convenience and established routines. People do not like change.
- akgerber 7y agoThe convenience factor is also engineered. It's not convenient to drive unless there is ample parking at every destination, and policies in the US and many other countries has basically banned building new places without ample parking. Providing this parking requires a large amount of land, which makes walking slow, unpleasant, and dangerous.
- bostonpete 7y agoPolicies dictate required parking? Seems like something developers would naturally do anyways. If you build commercial space without ample parking you're going to have trouble finding tenants...
- tropo 7y agoThis is true for an isolated rural business. In other cases, a business benefits from having customers park at neighboring businesses. If parking is provided, it will be taken by customers of other businesses.
- brailsafe 7y agoI love driving, and thought I'd never give it up until my car died. Now that I've been without one in Vancouver for over a year, it's just not financially sensible to get one for the occasional fun I'd have. Certainly, the sense of freedom is great, but good public transport for $100/month is way better. Renting a car fills the gaps I think so far. It's also super not worth the hassle to maintain and park.