3 ms·
The problem with that approach is you need to scale the surprisingly expensive non-nuclear side of a nuclear plant for the peak load, not the average load. It
by pfdietz 7y ago
The problem with that approach is you need to scale the surprisingly expensive non-nuclear side of a nuclear plant for the peak load, not the average load. It's not just the salt, it's the turbines and generators and cooling towers. It also increases the number of heat exchangers, and also means you are not building a PWR, but rather a higher temperature reactor. These higher temperature reactors are either unproven (molten salt) or have disappointing track records (helium gas cooled).
Moltex claims that interposing a salt store would allow these components to be made to non-nuclear standards, but as far as I know no regulator has agreed with that.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoI feel like you're just arguing in favor of building them. "Unproven" is a synonym for we haven't done it yet, so the only way to prove it is to build them, so building them is the solution to that rather than a problem that should prevent building them. And if the only problem is regulatory but there isn't actually any reason not to allow it, this too has an obvious solution. The justification for treating the cooling system as part of the reactor presumably comes from older designs where the active cooling is necessary for safe operation. For newer passively-safe designs, what happens to the heat once it's removed from the reactor wouldn't matter any more than what happens to the electricity once it's removed from the reactor.
- pfdietz 7y agoUnproven means exactly that. It means customers will not plop down billions to buy them. They will wait until it's demonstrated that the reactors will almost certainly work for their projected lifespans, that all the new parts aren't going to fail early, from all the unknown unknowns that new technology is subject to. And all that means that new reactor technologies are not going to be really available for decades, and will be competing not with renewables and storage now, but the renewables and storage that will be available for purchase decades hence.