4 ms·
I do not like the shaming tone of this article. Petabyte server today is a small box that fits anywhere. Meanwhile some people have hundreds of shoes or clothes
by throw32098 7y ago
I do not like the shaming tone of this article. Petabyte server today is a small box that fits anywhere. Meanwhile some people have hundreds of shoes or clothes, but nobody calls them "hoarders".
Anyway, I have offline storage, because my internet connectivity is slow. I do not like waiting, so all my content is downloaded overnight with a few cron scripts.
- mft_ 7y agoPeople with lots of clothing and shoes and other things absolutely might be criticised for their behaviour, and may be called hoarders. (I have direct personal experience of such people.) There is definitely a mindset —at its most extreme, a pathology— associated with hoarding behaviour. Digital hoarding may mostly avoid the negative life consequences of hoarding —as you say, you can store a lot of data in a relatively small physical space— but this doesn’t change the nature of the psychology behind the behaviour. (Although I’d wonder how many digital hoarders really have a small neat modern NAS as you imply, versus a room full of old racks?) Interestingly, the rationalisation given in the headline (“betterment of mankind”) isn’t so very far away (although maybe more grandiose) than the rationalisations that physical hoarders offer to justify their behaviour, around the perceived intrinsic value of their belongings.
- pessimizer 7y ago> this doesn’t change the nature of the psychology behind the behaviour. The "psychology" behind the behavior isn't the problem with hoarders, it's the actual hoarding. The reason we try to change hoarders' thinking is because of the physical consequences of their hoarding - we define this as illness because of its distressful results, if it had no consequences it wouldn't be illness. edit: I think you're accidentally using circular logic to rationalize a bit of magical thinking (person who obsessively collects garbage is ill, therefore person who obsessively collects anything is ill.) It's not the obsession that's the problem, it's the garbage and the distress.
- Mediterraneo10 7y agoI know that some of the members of the organized data-hoarder community are spending huge amounts of money on disks month after month, and it really bothers their spouses. So, even if there is no physical mess being created in their homes, their obsession is still affecting their lives and other people around them.
- mft_ 7y agoYou raise some interesting points. A few thoughts. Generally, psychological conditions can be considered on a spectrum, an analogue scale (i.e. from you have none of this trait or condition, to you display huge amounts). You're absolutely right that the point at which Hoarding Disorder becomes diagnosable (currently, per DSM-5) is determined by the real-world effects on someone's life becoming severe and displaying a number of features. [0] However, I'd argue that for this subject, considering only the DSM-5 diagnostic criteria is too simplistic: a) There are plenty of people whose hoarding behaviour falls short of the formal diagnostic criteria, but which do still cause some level of problem for them in their life, or for other people who are in their life. (For example, you could have someone whose home conditions don't meet the diagnostic criteria, but who no longer receive visits from family or friends because of the state of their house.) b) The diagnostic criteria to a large extent represent a traditional, common-sense, real-world societal view - i.e. it's fine to collect things, until it starts to make you unwell, and unsafe in your physical environment. c) The diagnostic criteria are updated seldom, and slowly. [1] As such, it's not infeasible that DSM-5 might lag behind (potential, arguable) alternate forms of hoarding disorder - such as digital hoarding. Consider someone who spends huge amounts of money on storage media and electricity, to the detriment of their financial well-being and maybe close relationships. Or someone who spends so much of their time downloading and categorising their digital belongings, that they miss sleep and make themselves unwell, or avoid social engagement and have detrimental effects on close relationships. These cases might not be diagnosable within DSM-5, but I'd argue that they would still be representative of psychopathology... and may in time (in DSM-7? :) ) be diagnosable in their own right. [0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK519704/table/ch3.t29/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK519704/table/ch3.t29/ [1] https://www.psychiatry.org/psychiatrists/practice/dsm https://www.psychiatry.org/psychiatrists/practice/dsm
- ad404b8a372f2b9 7y agoHmmm for a petabyte you'll be closer to the size of a desk than of a small box.
- garmaine 7y agoTrue. You can fit 150TB in a 4U rack mounted server fitted into an IKEA coffee table though, using entirely off the shelf consumer parts.
- fragmede 7y agoSupermicro's got a top-loader 90-bay chassis that fits into 4U. Filling it with 16 TB drives will give you 1.44 petabytes (not pebibytes, because hard drive salespeople), minus whatever redundancy you'd like to build in. I wouldn't consider that chassis to be an "off the shelf consumer part" though. Also comes in 45 and 60 bays. :)
- vetinari 7y agoI'm not entirely sure that IKEA coffee table would be able to withstand the weight of 45 or 60 drives plus chassis, either.
- Ao7bei3s 7y agoI don't see why not. 750g/drive * 60drives + 45kg chassis = 90kg. I've stood on top of IKEA Lack side tables, and a) I weigh more, b) with the chassis, the weight is going to be better distributed (lower mounting and no flexing). It might slack a little. Anyway compared to the price of the disks, a cheap small rack (they come in living-room compatible form factors as well. don't ask) wouldn't break the bank. Only inconvenience would be the top-loading aspect. The Lack fits 19" exactly, and besides can't provide the needed counterweight, so you can't have sliding rails. Can't mount lower either, a Lack would only barely fit 4U.
- jfkebwjsbx 7y ago1 Petabyte in a small box? I think the biggest drives are 15 Gigabytes or so? It would take more than 50, that is a loooot of weight!
- zouhair 7y agoYup, a lot of weight, now imagine 3 Petabytes[0] [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EtZXMj_gUjU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EtZXMj_gUjU