5 ms·
> Every nuclear disaster so far has exposed incompetence, negligence, corruption, or unsafe practices at some level, and has usually been accompanied by delays,
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> Every nuclear disaster so far has exposed incompetence, negligence, corruption, or unsafe practices at some level, and has usually been accompanied by delays, denials, and attempts to bury the evidence.
Humans are lazy and greedy and stupid. But that applies to everything, and nuclear is responsible for fewer deaths per TWh of power generated than anything you're proposing as a "dirty" alternative.
> When dealing with potentially "forever" contaminants, this is simply unacceptable.
This is factually not what we are dealing with. The radioactivity of a substance is inversely proportional to its half life. In other words, the more radioactive something is, the faster it disappears.
The most problematic nuclear contaminants are therefore the ones with medium half lives (i.e. decades), because they're radioactive enough to be harmful but long-lived enough to still be there a week later.
This is nasty stuff, but not in any way "forever" and not particularly any nastier than a lot of the chemical substances industries deal with on a large scale all over the place, which are chemically rather than radiologically hazardous and therefore don't even have a half life, i.e. they really are there forever. How is a nuclear reactor worse than a chemical plant?
> Ans since human nature and psychology is not going to magically evolve over the next couple of centuries, and since there's no such thing as a foolproof design, reducing nuclear power is a pragmatic approach, even if it causes a temporary increase in dirtier energy production (up to a point, of course).
Considering that coal is responsible for more radioactive emissions than nuclear per TWh produced including Chernobyl and Fukushima, that is a totally irresponsible and dangerous course of action.
- kstenerud 7y agoIt's estimated that the zone around the Chernobyl nuclear plant will be uninhabitable for 20,000 years. The Fukushima area (especially the sea surrounding it) suffers a similar fate. Once the Bikini Atoll containment fails within the next decade or so due to neglect, it will be uninhabitable for thousands of years as well. The world is awash in secret-but-not-really nuclear dumps with failing containment systems built too close to groundwater sources, which cannot be fixed due to the radiation hazard from the failed (due to neglect, improper design, and seismic activity) containment.
- scandox 7y ago> Considering that coal is responsible for more radioactive emissions than nuclear per TWh produced including Chernobyl and Fukushima, that is a totally irresponsible and dangerous course of action. Don't concentration and distribution matter? I mean in Serhii Plokhii's book on Chernobyl he several times repeats the claim that a significant leak into the river/sea would have rendered large parts of Europe uninhabitable. Now either that's a gross lie or your point is ignoring a hugely significant difference between coal production and nuclear. Which is it?
- lmm 7y ago> I mean in Serhii Plokhii's book on Chernobyl he several times repeats the claim that a significant leak into the river/sea would have rendered large parts of Europe uninhabitable. The grandparent's claim is about what did happen, not what might have happened in some hypothetical, but the claim you're quoting sounds utterly implausible to me; there simply isn't enough nuclear material anywhere to render a significant area uninhabitable for any significant length of time.
- makomk 7y agoConcentration absolutely matters, and based on the figures I've seen coal fly ash - which is what the claims about radiation released from coal power plants are based on - is about as radioactive, kg for kg, as granite is. Which isn't nothing, but it's also not exactly nuclear waste. (Speaking of nuclear waste, the comparisons with coal often also get their numbers by ignoring it and only counting radiation intentionally released to the environment from a properly-working plant. Which is basically just a way of saying that if we could solve the nuclear waste disposal problem and the humans are too incompetent to build and run nuclear power plants problem it'd be a really clean form of power. That's probsbly true, but not realistic. Also, the comparison is generally based on really old and polluting coal power plants that mostly don't exist anymore.)
- sarbaz 7y agoNuclear waste can basically be safely solved by dumping sealed containers into the sea. We're talking about extremely small amounts of waste. A swimming pool can contain a year's supply of waste, and 20 ft of water is extremely effective radiation shielding. The ocean is so large that this would be totally negligible even if the worst happened.
- cletus 7y ago> nuclear is responsible for fewer deaths per TWh of power generated than anything you're proposing as a "dirty" alternative. Irrelevant. The issue here isn't the expected value but the magnitude of the failure modes. Hundreds of thousands of people die every year in or because of automobiles, way more than in commercial airplanes, By any measure you can planes are safer. Yet, you will find more prevalence of the fear of flying than driving. Why? Because incidents are catastrophic often killing hundreds of people at once. There's only so much damage a single car can do even though cars collectively do way more damage than planes. Caol has obvious issues but the failure modes aren't catastrophic. Nuclear failure modes are. Nuclear has the power to make thousands of square miles uninhabitable for centuries (the last time I mentioned this I was accused at exaggerating so I'll preempt that by pointing out the absolute Chernobyl Exclusion Zone is, currently, 1000 square miles). > The most problematic nuclear contaminants are therefore the ones with medium half lives Yeah, no sale. There are two factors you're ignoring here: 1. Not just the strength but the type of radioactive decay. For example, a piece of paper will stop alpha emissions but alpha emissions are highly energetic and this is what makes Polonium-210 (as an extreme example) so deadly; 2. The chemical toxicity of the byproducts. Even U-238 (with a 4.5B year half life) is quite toxic; and 3. What an element decays into and the properties it (and all subsequent elements) has. > How is a nuclear reactor worse than a chemical plant? And what "chemical substances" are you referring to in particular here? I'll reverse your own argument here and say that any process is capable of producing toxic byproducts, nuclear waste has the additional property of being radioactive too. How is that better?
- roenxi 7y ago> Why? Because incidents are catastrophic often killing hundreds of people at once. You're rationalising something that isn't a rational or reasonable response. Exactly the same argument could be applied to trains; but I havn't met anyone who is scared of traveling by train. People are scared of heights and having no plausible escape routes if something goes wrong is also pretty scary. The statistics are overwhelming that this instinctive response is wrong.
- ivanhoe 7y ago
- Tade0 7y ago> Humans are lazy and greedy and stupid. But that applies to everything, and nuclear is responsible for fewer deaths per TWh of power generated than anything you're proposing as a "dirty" alternative. There may be fewer deaths, but it's the only energy source to create effectively permanent no-go zones.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoIn areas with heavy coal mining activity the water and the soil is poisoned from erosion and runoff and people that live in these places come in enough contact with the toxins (mostly heavy metals) that they develop medical problems later in life. In practice the effect is about the same that you'd get if you lived in a radioactive area.
- cycomanic 7y agoThis is a non argument. Nobody is seriously proposing coal as an alternative to nuclear. Sure in some countries (e.g. Germany) they phased out nuclear before coal, but there are very different reasons for this, for example they are favoring brown over black coal. That is for different reasons though, largely the political lobby and associated jobs in economically weak regions (note I'm not saying this is right). However, nobody is proposing coal as a long term solution. Yes one might make the argument that nuclear is safer than coal (however that argument is by no means as clear cut as you make it out too be), but the competition are renewables and neither nuclear or coal come close.
- simloo 7y agoNot the parent, but if you look at what's currently replacing nuclear power world-wide it seems to be gas. Gas extraction is also not very environmentally friendly and releases a lot of nasty toxins into the air and surrounding areas, just not as much as coal mining does. I think the point still stands.
- asjw 7y agoNot the only one People are also highly irrational, they'll live where water is contaminated but fear 5G wireless https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhopal_disaster https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhopal_disaster
- zaarn 7y ago>Humans are lazy and greedy and stupid. But that applies to everything, and nuclear is responsible for fewer deaths per TWh of power generated than anything you're proposing as a "dirty" alternative. Such an argument still undermines the pain and suffering such an accident can create, especially because nuclear can create suffering that doesn't necessarily end in a death caused by it. >This is factually not what we are dealing with. The radioactivity of a substance is inversely proportional to its half life. In other words, the more radioactive something is, the faster it disappears. Long-lived Radioactive materials have other problems if they are farther up in the atomic charts. Uranium and Plutonium are simply toxic to life (with few exceptions), other materials produced in a nuclear reactor behave similarly. Large amounts of uranium can still produce lethal amounts of radiation if they're on a long halflife. If it leaks into the ground water, you have much bigger problems because radioactivity from inside the body is even more troublesome. And it doesn't detract from the fact that the short and medium lived isotopes still need to be isolated for quite some time.