4 ms·
There's a few issue with this though. 1) There's no equivalence between a bomb and nuclear waste. 2) The waste is actually REALLY REALLY small. We're talking
by godelski 7y ago
There's a few issue with this though.
1) There's no equivalence between a bomb and nuclear waste.
2) The waste is actually REALLY REALLY small. We're talking about a coke can per person per year. That's total waste, which only 3% of that is high level waste and needs to be buried. There's a deep misconception about the amount of waste we're talking about here. And this is before we talk about recycling, like France does (see above comment), or using waste in medicine.
3) The cost for nuclear is more similar to why the postal service costs so much/isn't profitable. This cost is manufactured.
4) No pro nuclear person is saying "nuclear vs renewables". They may say "nuclear vs fossil fuels" or "let's not remove it from the options because there's places where nuclear is a better alternative". (e.g. renewables work great in southern california and the southwest. Not always in areas where it is cloudy like the northern coasts). All pro nuclear people want is nuclear to not be removed from the portfolio of technologies.
No one is denying renewables are the way to go. The argument is "are renewables enough to kill coal and gas?" There's significant evidence to suggest no. Even if you don't believe that, that's not a good reason to remove nuclear from the table (mind you, just being on the table doesn't mean you have to use it). I'll even note that a significant number of climate researchers advocate for expansion of nuclear, including the IPCC.
- Krasnol 7y ago1) Yeah, the bomb is the reactor. Waste is waste. 2) https://www.faz.net/aktuell/politik/inland/probleme-bei-bergung-atommuell-muss-womoeglich-in-der-asse-bleiben-13595392/drunter-und-drueber-geht-es-in-13595409.html https://www.faz.net/aktuell/politik/inland/probleme-bei-berg... This is what Germany is dealing with. It's just one room. Tons and tons are stored above ground near the reactors (15.075,6 t just fuel in Germany) https://www.atommuellreport.de/themen/atommuell/einzelansicht/radioaktive-abfaelle-mengenuebersicht.html https://www.atommuellreport.de/themen/atommuell/einzelansich... 3) Costs are IMMENSE. Here somebody took their time to write it up: https://www.reddit.com/r/de/comments/emc2ne/quelle_surprise_frankreich_verzichtet_vorerst/fdoxtt3/ https://www.reddit.com/r/de/comments/emc2ne/quelle_surprise_... (fixed link to english version) 4) No anti-nuclear person is saying "nuclear vs. coal" it's still such a prominent argument. Weird eh? And it's not even real. It's a huge straw man set up by the lobbyists of a dead technology picked up by some misguided fans. Here is a read up for the baseload theory that comes up at this moment in a discussion so you can save yourself a few useless lines: https://skepticalscience.com/print.php?r=374 https://skepticalscience.com/print.php?r=374
- godelski 7y ago> 1) Yeah, the bomb is the reactor. Waste is waste. Citation needed. Reactors don't explode. Chernobyl is an exception to the rule. The USSR is the only country to build positive void reactors. > 2) Posts in German Unfortunately I don't read German. But I'll mention that again, high level waste and low level waste is treated differently. > 3) Another post in German Again, I don't read German. I'll just link you to this https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22852228 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22852228 and encourage you to read more of AcidBurn's posts, as he is a reactor scientist. > 4) No anti-nuclear person is saying "nuclear vs. coal" it's still such a prominent argument. I'm claiming anti-nuclear people are saying "nuclear vs renewables" In fact, it is the first sentence of this item. But who wants to listen to scientists anyways... Not when we have our feelgood politics on our side! https://i.imgflip.com/1pk2po.jpg https://i.imgflip.com/1pk2po.jpg
- Krasnol 7y ago1) Yeah they do not "explode" which doesn't make any difference at all for the disaster and playing the word game won't change a single thing about the problem itself. 2/3) I changed the link to english but besides that: you are here on a board for technically capable people and you can't paste that into google translate? You got the picture at least? 4) No you didn't say that, but you implied it. Just like OP and oh look it's a funny picture from The Simpsons. Guess you reached the end of your arguments. Good bye.