4 ms·
> People don't want a potential bomb in their neighbourhood in the same way they don't want a nuclear waste dump in their neighbourhood. No sane person would bl
by roenxi 7y ago
> People don't want a potential bomb in their neighbourhood in the same way they don't want a nuclear waste dump in their neighbourhood. No sane person would blame them and that's the whole story.
The stubbornness of people like that has cost thousands if not tens of thousands of lives to air pollution, caused the destruction due to coal mining of big swathes of land and increases the risk of a resource war or other difficult geopolitical situation arising.
They are also causing tens of thousands of people to waste their lives working unproductively in energy-producing industries when they could have been doing something useful instead.
Sane or otherwise, they are just people who don't understand statistics or how energy works. They are symptoms of the general problem that society has with implementing evidence-based policies.
- godelski 7y ago> The stubbornness of people like that has cost thousands if not tens of thousands of lives to air pollution Considering that the research suggests 7,500 and 52,000 people in the US each year[0], I think you could safely say "hundreds of thousands of lives have been lost due to this argument" (considering that less than 30k lives have been lost to nuclear, including future deaths from disasters). I want to make this abundantly clear. We're pro-nuclear because we want to save lives. Because we want to save the environment. And because we are listening to the scientists. No one is saying "nuclear vs renewables", but rather "keep nuclear on the table". We're on the same team as those that advocate for renewables (I myself strongly advocate for renewables!). [0] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-other-reason-to-shift-away-from-coal-air-pollution-that-kills-thousands-every-year/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-other-reason-...
- Krasnol 7y agoYeah statistics look so great...on paper. In reality A SINGLE overdue French reactor could wipe out a whole country (Luxembourg) leaving us with a nuclear wasteland right in the middle of Europe. A beautiful picture you can't draw with numbers. To make my point even clearer and because I have the feeling like I'm talking to Americans who have never even took a look at an European map. This is it: https://i.imgur.com/SVom3rl.jpg https://i.imgur.com/SVom3rl.jpg Yes, there are people all over the place. This stuff is being kept alive for political reasons (hey here is your favourite reason for nuclear "mistakes": human error again) while it rots from within. So how it may be surprising that people do not trust the energy and those who are responsible for it politically and technically, is beyond me. All that money wasted for this technology could have been invested into renewables which would have brought us much farther than we are today but it didn't happen because: hey nuclear lobby. Throwing even more money on it now is beyond stupid (https://www.reddit.com/r/de/comments/emc2ne/quelle_surprise_frankreich_verzichtet_vorerst/fdoxtt3/ https://www.reddit.com/r/de/comments/emc2ne/quelle_surprise_...) and I really hope the lobby money for this artificially kept alive propaganda train finally runs out just like the technology did.
- roenxi 7y agoThe only INES 7 disaster in the last 30 years involved Fukushima being hit by an earthquake that was out of design spec and then a literal 14 meter high tsunami. I think it was something like a 1 in 600 year event. Even then they had to be negligent on their safety standards for it to cause a bad meltdown. That was what it took to fail a 1970s designed (pre-Chernobyl, pre-computer-aided-design) nuclear reactor with upgrades. Standards haven't gotten lower since then. Luxembourg will be fine. Don't panic. Unless they migrate to the coast with global warming. Which can be mitigated by more nuclear use!
- varjag 7y agoIt was hit by tsunami because it was built in a tsunami-prone, seismically vulnerable area. A "1 in 1000 year" tsunami hitting it in first 40 years of operation sounds like a planning and engineering failure, and is why people tend to be super sceptical about safe nuclear.
- roenxi 7y agoHow many nuclear plants are there in the world? About 500 [0]. Years between Chernobyl and Fukushima? ~30. I expect a 1 in 1500 year event to have happened to a nuclear reactor somewhere in the world in that time. People are skeptical because they don't have a very good grasp of statistics. I may have mentioned something about that a few posts up. Somewhere in the world something is going horribly wrong. The world is a big place. That being said; I think there were design decisions made around Fukushima. The engineers in the 70s didn't have the capabilities we enjoy now. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_reactors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_reactors
- varjag 7y agoNuclear power today is about 10% of overall power generation. Were it 100%, INES 7 catastrophes would be happening every 3 years. That's before you account for wars and low safety culture plaguing significant part of the world which does not operate nuclear currently. Engineering in 1970s was overall solid and not that much behind on material science and control systems theory than today: they could get people to the Moon and back after all. Dismissing the catastrophes to that is a dangerous hubris.
- adrianN 7y agoIn many situations people prefer choices with worse expected value when they also have a lower variance. That's the whole point of insurances for example. Choosing more expected deaths from air pollution over lower expected deaths from nuclear accidents (but with a very large variance compared to pollution) can be rational. It just depends on your valuation function.
- roenxi 7y agoIt can be rational. However, in this context, it is not. It is pretty clearly people who just don't understand what 6 orders of magnitude improvement of fuel density implies for pollution and efficiency. Or how rare a 1 in 30 disaster is on a global scale. COVID-19 just dropped on us one day and everything shut down. That is a pretty good example of how scary the world is. The tiny odds of a nuclear disaster (that can still be walked away from!) is nothing compared to the baseline risks of being alive. We'd be a lot better off right now if the anti-nuclear protests in the 80s had been anti-aeroplane-travel instead; because disease from having fast transport links has done a lot more damage than nuclear power could. Nuclear weapons notwithstanding.
- Krasnol 7y agoYeah it's funny how it goes with those "tiny odds" eh? Today nuclear technicians need to sleep and life in their plants because of one of these tiny odds actually happening. I don't see any solar panel technicians having to sleep at their solar panel fields. And how about those odds of a salt mine that was perfectly good a few decades ago to store the tons of waste suddenly getting a nasty groundwater inflow and becoming a risk for groundwater? It's happening right now in Germany and has been for a few years now. All that money wasted for pumping out and clearing out this mine could be invested into REALLY clean energy but it's not. It's dumped into radioactive waste "management". Funny how those odds go eh?