4 ms·
Nuclear isn't failing because of safety or waste or political negativity. It's failing because it's too expensive. France is giving up on new nuclear plants b
by pfdietz 7y ago
Nuclear isn't failing because of safety or waste or political negativity. It's failing because it's too expensive. France is giving up on new nuclear plants because the can't build them sufficiently cheaply.
Ultimately, this comes back to the unforgiving complexity of nuclear technology. The plants have to be big to get economies of scale, but then they have so many critical parts that the economies of scale are illusory. A truly scalable technology is made of large numbers of mostly independent pieces that don't have to be so expensively reliable.
- maelito 7y ago> France is giving up on new nuclear plants because the can't build them sufficiently cheaply. No. France aiming at 50% of nuclear electricity (down from 75%) is a purely political move, to please some people that fear nuclear more than they fear climate change.
- pfdietz 7y agoIt's the 50% that's the political statement. It's not realistic, given the state of the French nuclear industry, and their recent experience at building reactors. And I'm pretty sure their politician know this. There are no commitments there, real commitments with real money, to stay nuclear.
- audunw 7y agoI've never seen that anyone has been able to document this claim. Meanwhile it's pretty easy to show that nuclear today is too expensive. LCoE studies shows wind power being cheaper, and attempts at building nuclear reactors in Europe has repeatedly led to economic disasters. You could argue that you could get the cost down if you make a huge push for nuclear. But the last time we did that it was a combined push for nuclear weapons and energy, which made it easier to get support and funding for education and research. Now the only major application is energy. And though you could probably get the cost down to where it was before, the cost of renewables and storage is dropping very rapidly. It seems likely that renewables will reach a price point that nuclear could never catch up to, way before the cost of nuclear will be reasonable again. And since renewables will be so cheap, most countries will want at least 50% of energy to be renewable. And that will make covering the remaining 50% with nuclear more expensive, since you'd need more advanced and expensive load balancing power plants to support the renewables. I also think that the fact that renewables give us an increasing amount of days with overproduction, i.e. extremely cheap electricity, might be a very good thing when we'll want to create more hydrogen and synthetic fuels.
- maelito 7y ago> I've never seen that anyone has been able to document this claim. Are you aware that the French ministry of environment justifies closing Fessenheim because nuclear emits too much greenhouse gases ? And that some heads of EELV, the "green" french party, don't know what a life-cycle analysis is (or purposedly pretends not to know ) and asks for closing nuclear plants to be in line with the Paris 2015 climate deal ? This helps figure out how rational the current moves against nuclear are.
- maelito 7y ago> And though you could probably get the cost down to where it was before, the cost of renewables and storage is dropping very rapidly. It seems likely that renewables will reach a price point that nuclear could never catch up to, way before the cost of nuclear will be reasonable again. And since renewables will be so cheap, most countries will want at least 50% of energy to be renewable. And that will make covering the remaining 50% with nuclear more expensive, since you'd need more advanced and expensive load balancing power plants to support the renewables. Without nuclear, with what life-cycle kgCO2e/kWh result, and when ?
- pfdietz 7y agoIn a post fossil fuel economy, and assuming CO2 from concrete manufacture is captured, CO2 emissions are zero. The question of CO2 emission before then, as fossil fuels are being phased out, is less important. During that process the better question is how much CO2 emission can be avoided per $ invested. By that metric, renewables will be much better than new nuclear.
- Krasnol 7y ago> is a purely political move, to please some people that fear nuclear more than they fear climate change. This is a lie. French people are overly pro-nuclear. It was and remains being about the costs. https://finance-commerce.com/2019/09/frances-nuclear-love-affair-shows-signs-of-souring/ https://finance-commerce.com/2019/09/frances-nuclear-love-af... Not only the costs of setting up new reactors but the costs of maintaining the old ones, maintaining waste and the ridiculously smaller costs of alternatives: https://reneweconomy.com.au/france-solar-auction-success-delivered-at-nuclears-expense-59426/ https://reneweconomy.com.au/france-solar-auction-success-del... It's dead. They don't even continue to throw money onto one of those seemingly "innovative" research programs anymore: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-france-nuclearpower-astrid/france-drops-plans-to-build-sodium-cooled-nuclear-reactor-idUSKCN1VK0MC https://www.reuters.com/article/us-france-nuclearpower-astri... And it's not only France: https://energypost.eu/200-400-nuclear-reactors-to-be-decommissioned-by-2040/ https://energypost.eu/200-400-nuclear-reactors-to-be-decommi...
- maelito 7y ago> This is a lie. French people are overly pro-nuclear. Have you seen that I've used the word "some" in my sentence ? This move was targeting a precise portion of the population. > Not only the costs of setting up new reactors but the costs of maintaining the old ones, maintaining waste and the ridiculously smaller costs of alternatives: https://reneweconomy.com.au/france-solar-auction-success-del.. https://reneweconomy.com.au/france-solar-auction-success-del.... You obviously know that the costs you refer to through this article do not include storage. Nor do not talk about the lifecycle carbon emissions.
- Krasnol 7y ago> Have you seen that I've used the word "some" in my sentence ? You don't make politics for "some" people. You make politics for the majority. Focusing on some minor group interest doesn't give you votes especially if their viewpoints contradict those of the majority. So what's your point there? It does not make any sense. > You obviously know that the costs you refer to through this article do not include storage. Nor do not talk about the lifecycle carbon emissions. Of course they do. This is the way decisions fall if you decide between several energy sources. You take everything in account and in the end you make a decision. The decision is: less nuclear.
- simloo 7y agoNuclear power hasn't become magically more expensive in the last decade or so, it's because it's been hit with taxes and fees in a lot of countries while renewables haven't (or, in some countries, renewables are still even subsidised). Nuclear power is cheaper if politics stay out of it.
- pfdietz 7y agoYou're just making that up, you know. Nuclear has been given such horrible handicaps as 100% loan guarantees. Oh the burden they operate under!
- simloo 7y agoAll large power plant installations are given such loan guarantees, including wind power and solar power farms. It's a pretty good way for the government to make sure they are built. A lot of countries, such as here in Sweden, have a separate nuclear power tax, and a large thermal power tax. Oil and coal, for example, only pay the latter here. These are in addition to the nuclear waste management fees. Nuclear power is the only power source that pays for proper waste disposal (coal, oil and gas just spews it into the atmosphere and wind power installations are simply buried after they expire). So no, I'm not making it up. Nuclear power is heavily taxed which is the largest reason why it's suddenly turned uneconomical in the last decade.
- epistasis 7y agoInteresting, I had never heard of a country that subsidizes solar or wind by providing loan guarantees... Why would Sweden do it that way? It doesn't seem particularly helpful for a tech with such short loan terms and lower risk than nuclear.
- simloo 7y agoThat sounds surprising to me since different kinds of loan guarantees are common for large industrial installations and not unique to any trade. There are no specific ones for renewables that I'm aware of, so perhaps I gave that undue weight. Over here, renewables are most heavily subsidised through elcertifikat[1], which is basically a tax per kWh on electricity brokers, given to producers of renewable energy. This cost is then passed on to the consumer. However, it's not a straight tax and it's a bit complicated, but a renewable source gets on average around 40% extra on top of the sale price[2]. We don't build new hydro power plants, and our climate isn't very suitable for large scale solar, so "building renewable energy" here basically means building a lot of wind power. Nuclear power is then levied additional tax on top of this, which was raised quite substantially a few years ago by the Greens when in government. Note the nuclear waste disposal fee is separate to this tax. Traditionally, our energy mix has been about 50/50 nuclear and hydro power, and some wind and others thrown in. Wind power is now increasing[3]. Nuclear power has historically been very profitable for us and our electricity prices have been very low by international standards, but there's an ongoing phase-out for wind power and the cost of electricity is steadily increasing. That should give you some insight how and why renewables are heavily subsidied here and nuclear power heavily taxed. I'm sorry sources are in Swedish, a lot of the data seems to be unavailable in English. [1] https://www.energimarknadsbyran.se/el/dina-avtal-och-kostnader/elrakningen/elcertifikat-priser-och-kostnader/ https://www.energimarknadsbyran.se/el/dina-avtal-och-kostnad... [2] https://sv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vindkraft_i_Sverige#Elpriser_och_elcertifikat https://sv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vindkraft_i_Sverige#Elpriser_o... [3] https://www.scb.se/hitta-statistik/sverige-i-siffror/miljo/elektricitet-i-sverige/ https://www.scb.se/hitta-statistik/sverige-i-siffror/miljo/e...