3 ms·
> Sometimes you have to have the self-awareness to ask yourself, here I am, a country-simple and inexperienced elected official No one thinks of themselves as
by smt88 7y ago
> Sometimes you have to have the self-awareness to ask yourself, here I am, a country-simple and inexperienced elected official
No one thinks of themselves as "country-simple". They certainly don't throw hope for their community out the window because they're too "country-simple" to understand that it's a lie.
Sometimes you have to have the self-awareness to ask yourself, here I am, an educated tech enthusiast, who's being presented with a decision and self-delusion I can't empathize with. Is it likely that my narrow experience can be applied in judgment of all other people? Or maybe I have never known the desperation of living in a dying region?
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> No one thinks of themselves as "country-simple" Of course not. But this is a story of a small town government negotiating with a multibillion-dollar company. They kept negotiations secret. They didn’t seem to hire best-in-class bankers nor lawyers. I understand the desperation. But stupid doesn’t become less stupid because it was dumb for the right reasons. Best case, they deluded themselves into believing they found a golden goose. That’s incompetent.
- smt88 7y ago> But stupid doesn’t become less stupid because it was dumb for the right reasons. I think you misunderstood my post. I wasn't saying that what they did wasn't stupid. It was. The post I was replying to implied the following in a condescending way: 1) the poster is not "simple" enough to be conned by a massive corporation 2) all people living in rural areas are "simple" 3) all people living in rural areas should know that they are simple and never aspire to anything that we big-city people do because it is beyond their cognitive abilities 4) doing something that will probably fail (trusting Foxconn, in this case) is never a rational decision Regarding #4, it's easy to say that Foxconn is 100% untrustworthy, but we all know that mostly in hindsight. Even if they had a 1% chance of coming through, a region with a dying economy might actually be rational to throw away an enormous amount of money. If it's their only hope, it would be rational to throw away all of their money.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> people living in rural areas should know that they are simple Countermeasures to this stereotype can be equally damaging. It may have played into Foxconn’s advantage here. “We don’t need an expensive coastal banker telling us what to do” is reasonable if everyone is out to screw small timers. > a region with a dying economy might actually be rational to throw away an enormous amount of money This wasn’t money they had. It was taxpayers’ future money. Money that could have financed education or infrastructure or a move to another city. This mindset is only rational if staying in place has infinite utility, not only for the region’s present residents, but its future ones too.
- jlaurend 7y agoJust to jump in here to add some additional comments: * Mount Pleasant WI is not rural (city-data.com says 95% urban). It lies on I94 just 1hr 15min from Chicago and 30min from Milwaukee. * I doubt Mount Pleasant WI is dying. If I remember, the deal was pretty opaque and many details were murky. I find it more likely the local officials were incentivized somehow as opposed to sheer incompetence. Additionally, it should be noted that the WI governor (Scott Walker) who orchestrated this deal lost his re-election bid shortly after this. While there was always uncertainty about Foxconn actually following through, the lack of Walker (and thus probably Trump) basically sealed the deal.
- smt88 7y ago> Mount Pleasant WI is not rural I think you're right. I was responding to someone saying they are "country" people. > I doubt Mount Pleasant WI is dying. Milwaukee's metro area (which includes Mount Pleasant and Racine, the places most closely tied to Foxconn's scam) has seen a massive decline in manufacturing: > "The Great Recession hit Milwaukee’s manufacturing industry especially hard, and the city continues to have discomfiting employment statistics..."[1]. Broad economic numbers aren't great for Racine County as far as I can tell. They're worse than the US overall. Even if they were great, we know from examples across the US that declining blue-collar jobs may be especially painful for the non-urban electorate -- people who influence the local officials who believe the wishful nonsense Foxconn peddles. > "'This area desperately needs the investment. There's nothing here anymore,' said Tom Johnston, a 54-year-old veteran of [Racine's] once-vaunted manufacturing sector."[2] 1. https://www.badgerinstitute.org/Reports/2013/A-Fresh-Take-on-an-Old-Reliable-Milwaukee-and-Manufacturing-.htm https://www.badgerinstitute.org/Reports/2013/A-Fresh-Take-on... 2. https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/as-the-economy-teeters-trumps-eighth-wonder-of-the-world-wobbles-with-it/2019/09/28/478baca2-da59-11e9-a688-303693fb4b0b_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/as-the-economy-teete...
- analog31 7y agoThe state government was a player in this as well. Foxconn was not the only people promising a golden goose.
- defterGoose 7y ago> They didn’t seem to hire best-in-class bankers nor lawyers. Even if they had, is it likely that those people would have told them it wasn't a good deal? My sense is that everyone on the inside thought this was a sweetheart of a deal and were already counting their eggs. And if recent history is any guide, that group of people might very well be the least concerned about whether truth was being conveyed, or care to look deeper into the matter than their own pocketbooks.
- cosmodisk 7y agoThat's not that uncommon. We've had so many examples in Lithuania,which has less people than suburbs in New York,where some local functionaries thought that large US companies are nice and easy to deal with just to end up with the crappiest deals ever.Some were literally salivating from the fact that a few hot shots from the US will visit their god's forgotten town. One can build any experience, including dealing with multinationals, however it usually comes with very expensive lessons.
- askYoSelf 7y ago> Sometimes you have to have he self-awareness to ask yourself, here I am, an educated tech enthusiast, who's being presented with a decision and self-delusion I can't empathize with. ️I love this kind of nonsense dig. Something that is too good to be true, that has to be done on secret should set off warning bells for EVERYONE. But, yup, it must be the narrow experience of the commenter that causes them to be unable to empathize. One can empathize while still calling out ridiculousness of the people and situation. Jesus Christ. Maybe you should check yourself.
- deanCommie 7y ago> Or maybe I have never known the desperation of living in a dying region? I'll bite. The first thing I would do in a desperate situation in a position of power in a dying region is be radically open to feedback and transparent with my own ideas. A desperate situation is no room for ego or selfishness. You involve the community, and you try to listen to everyone, and if an opportunity presents itself that is above your paygrade you try to hope that the COLLECTIVE wisdom of multiple people with different strengths might somehow help offset your power imbalance. Now, listen to the podcast that interviews this inexperienced elected official and ask yourself if he did anything of the sort, or if he just saw an opportunity to enrich and embiggen himself: https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/wbhjwd https://gimletmedia.com/shows/reply-all/wbhjwd
- smt88 7y ago> The first thing I would do in a desperate situation in a position of power in a dying region is be radically open to feedback and transparent with my own ideas. I'm glad that people like you exist, but it is extremely rare that they are elected or stay in office. It's common for intellectual humility to be perceived as incompetence or weak leadership. "I don't know what to do, but I'm open to hearing your ideas!" is not confidence-inspiring. Admitting to mistakes can be the same. > You involve the community, and you try to listen to everyone Similar to the above, this can be seen as weakness. Look at the criticism of Jack Dorsey and Twitter. People mock him for this behavior instead of making unilateral decisions with incomplete evidence. > if an opportunity presents itself that is above your paygrade Again, not something a normal human in a leadership position often thinks. You don't think to yourself, "Wow, I'm just not smart enough to understand a large company promising something." Especially in the US, where people trust the legal system to force the other party to make good on its promises. > he just saw an opportunity to enrich and embiggen himself I agree that he did this. He wasn't the only person who saw this opportunity. It's also how democracy is supposed to work: someone wins a popularity contest and then wants to win it again. The incentives this creates are sometimes perverse. You do stupid things that sound good just because they sound good. Can you imagine being an official brave enough to say they don't think Foxconn would follow through? No one would want to vote for you. We've seen this repeatedly with Trump: he promises impossible things like the return of the coal industry and manufacturing jobs. Some of his rivals in the Republican Party did not promise this, and they were nowhere near as popular as him.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoWhat were they going to build with these displays? None of the PR identified what the actual business case was. The automotive industry is the only large domestic consumer of these parts. Otherwise they'd have to ship them back to SZ.
- huffmsa 7y agoWisconsin is hardly a dying region. It's a very quiet biotech (UW is/ was the largest patent holder in the world mostly in bio, pharma and tech), software (Epic, redox, SwanLeap) and manufacturing (Trek, Kohler, Georgia Pacific, Stryker medical, Mercury Marine) powerhouse. Though the smaller towns in the state are more dependant on lower yield industries.