3 ms·
Obligatory: https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt > Every email user has one or more identities, represented by cryp
by kazinator 7y ago
Obligatory:
https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt
> Every email user has one or more identities, represented by cryptographic keys.
Administered by whom?
> No email is delivered unless it carries a digital stamp issued by the recipient
The central premise of e-mail is that you can contact anyone if you know their e-mail address, without any pre-arranged permission.
If a recipient has to issue something to me before I can contact them by e-mail, that is too broken to be usable.
An intelligently designed micropayment system doesn't require anything from the recipient. Simply knowing someone's endpoint address, you an create a payment without their knowledge or consent, and attach it to the message.
> In this approach, each email user can have as many email identities as they want [ ... ] This means misrepresenting the sender becomes much harder, reducing the possibility for scam.
I.e. people can create arbitrary cryptographic identities, as many as they want (spammers can create millions of of these identities), yet somehow misrepresentation is not possible. Right.
If you get a cryptographic message from Joe Blow offering you fake R0lex watches, you know that must be the real Joe Blow, because, like, it is cryptographic! Someone running a key generator would never lie about who they are.
- tomjen3 7y agoI remember how often it was posted on /. back in the day, and how it effectively shut down any discussion about fixing the real issues with email in any kind of open source fashion. The problem was eventually solved, but it was solved by Google and Yahoo and Microsoft in monopolizing email, because they were focused on the user and us nerds were focused on shutting down (im)-perfect open source solutions instead of working to improve them. The document is not obligatory, it is one of the most destructive ever published on the subject; it represents the worst of nerd-dom and should not be used.
- kazinator 7y agoThere is no debate-silencing coercion involved in posting a link to a humor piece. The debate stops spontaneously, because the participants are too stumped to respond to the ways that the form managed to anticipate serious flaws in their ideas. If you can't defend your ideas in the face of some piece of net humor written years earlier, what good are those ideas? That piece is in fact the encoding of a requirements specification; it shuts down the debate because it intrudes into it with some real world requirements that e-mail has to satisfy, and continue to satisfy while it transitions to something new. (Some of it is plain wacky, too, but not all). A lot of programmers are very good at pretending requirements don't exist; they think that design means inventing your own requirements and making everyone else follow them. But a world-wide electronic mail communication system isn't an editor, video game or toy compiler.