5 ms·
A speculative theory backed by purely circumstantial evidence gathered online of covid-19's origin is that chinese researchers investigating coronaviruses in ba
by pengaru 7y ago
A speculative theory backed by purely circumstantial evidence gathered online of covid-19's origin is that chinese researchers investigating coronaviruses in bats working near the wet market in Wuhan had an accident and became infected, one who apparently disappeared and has been presumed dead.
I don't know if that's pure conspiracy theory nonsense, but it certainly seems risky to be doing this kind of thing:
> Free-ranging bats were captured, and rectal and oral swabs and guano samples collected for coronaviral screening
Especially considering the potential for asymptomatic spread...
- __s 7y agoHow do you suggest research be done?
- mahesh_rm 7y agoIn whatever fashion you might think of, which does not endanger the lives of millions of people?
- pengaru 7y agoWith great care and from a distance. If we're manually catching and swabbing wild bat rectums, I don't think we're doing a good job of keeping a distance, especially considering how far technology has progressed.
- throwanem 7y agoHumans and bats aren't going to stop interacting, not least because guano is an excellent fertilizer and the easiest way to get it is by giving bats incentives to defecate over your fields. That being so, and given the utter implausibility of bat-butthole-swabbing robots or whatever, would you rather we had people taking the negligible additional risk of doing this kind of research, so that we have a chance of being able to prepare in advance for the arrival of zoonoses like SARS-CoV-2? Or would you rather be taken by surprise? Going by the current state of affairs in the world, I have to say that being taken by surprise seems to have very little to recommend it.
- decebalus1 7y agoWith great care, in isolation and with full transparency. Tthere are protocols for how to deal with lab accidents or outbreaks and prior incidents show that all of these have lower priority than 'saving face' for the Chinese government.
- bb2018 7y agoI feel like it is completely speculative as you said and I am not conspiratorial at all. Because China is so secretive and has already been known to punish people for reporting on this it seems likely that these theories will only increase (I mean, how could you ever prove them wrong given China's actions)
- vkou 7y agoThe US is far more open than China, yet the amount of batshit crazy conspiracy theories that circulate about it is staggering. Only an incredibly slim minority of them actually turn out to be true... Or something resembling true. I don't think the openness of a country has much to do with the number of conspiracy theories that form about it. Conspiracy theories find patterns in incomplete data. There is always incomplete data, and there are always patterns to find. IF you get deep enough into them, then you can even turn around and point at evidence that disproves your theory, with the claim that actually, it proves it! Just the other day, I responded to a post on HN that claimed that there's a vast conspiracy by the Labour Bureau to hide unemployment numbers, by reporting only the U3 numbers, when the U6 numbers are more relevant. When it was pointed out that the bureau reports the U6 numbers, as well as the U3, the claim turned into 'Well, its obviously a conspiracy - what better way to hide the truth than to conceal it in irrelevant gibberish!' No amount of openness is ever going to dissuade that kind of intellectual dishonesty.
- not_exactly__ 7y agoI’d add that in China, the government is especially aggressive at squashing down rumors/conspiracy-theories that involve itself. If the rumors are false, the evidence they provide is usually rock solid. When the evidence they provide is garbage (eg friend of said person swears that they are alive), then you can assume the rumors are true.
- jacobush 7y agoI'd say conspiracy theories thrive in communities where the people are used to being screwed over.
- hubadu 7y agoIt is interesting that a potential accidental leak is now labeled as a "conspiracy theory" by the media outlets, even though China already had two accidentally leaks from their lab in Beijing. Including the SARS leak accident for which Chinese CDC officials were publicly punished in 2004. Same media outlets who keep repeating that masks are useless for civilians, publishing bat soup pictures from Palau Island as Wuhan food, and relaying unfiltered chinese propaganda and stats as "real news".
- baddox 7y agoIt’s a conspiracy theory if there isn’t any good evidence. The fact that labs have accidentally leaked pathogens before is not evidence that all future new pathogens are leaked from labs.
- not_exactly__ 7y agoCMilk did a video a week or two ago on what evidence we have so far. I’d say it’s convincing enough; or rather, that within the context of China, there is enough smoke (disappearing lab members, papers removed...etc), lots of CCP efforts to call those rumors, and not much dispelling being done by the government. In all my years in China, if there’s one thing the government there hates, it’s rumors and they will do anything to squash them if they’re actually false (eg providing proof of life if people claim someone is missing vs just saying “I assure you they is alive.”)
- throwanem 7y agoCan we please cite something a little more substantive than random Youtube videos made by people with no apparent familiarity with the fields of endeavor they're trying to report on? I mean, I don't doubt the guy's good intentions, but this is like if I were trying to make a technical argument about the physics of string theory.
- Wimpzilla 7y agoWell, one can easily dig into the sequences database, to find some useful clues: -A lot of chinese papers have been published through the years on the topic, during multiples waves of sample collection over all the chinese mainland. Showing there was/is a notable interest about this pathogen issue. -One can also easily spot which research center were/are the most active on the topic and its related research teams. Wuhan research center is not excluded from the list as some others main big labs. -Each entry sequence in the database is dated with a location, publishing team and associated paper. It is useful for following the pathogen evolution building phylogeny trees. -Aligning a lot of sequences clearly show that this strain is separated from the rest of the others mains strain. The only related sequences are the one released by the chinese team. -The closest related sequences are 2013 year dated and other from 2015/2017/2019, which per se does not provide a lot of information about the real pathogen evolution. -The different gain of function that this pathogen got compared to its predecessors is quite remarkable and hard to overlook. -The overall AT/GC sequence content have also evolved from its predecessors showing rich AT content that is generally related to higher host habit and expression. So yeah, knowing china is not smiley kind shaped, one can still question the research and lab habit as one would do for any other country. A theory based on excessive and unregulated animal sampling could have exacerbated the real cross-transmission issue is as valid as the one about pathogen leaking from the lab or simply by natural evolution. Anyway one can clearly take a moment to question the overall package, along the safety lab practices deployed around the world when dealing with potential pathogens.
- fspeech 7y agoHere is a study of "Serological Evidence of Bat SARS-Related Coronavirus Infection in Humans, China" done in 2018 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6178078/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6178078/ The corresponding author Zheng-Li Shi is also the lead reasearcher of Wuhan lab. I wish people use peer reviewed articles as supporting evidence when making arguments. These subjects (coronavirus origin and transmission) are well researched and disseminated.
- pengaru 7y agoIs that supposed to be evidence of the covid-19 outbreak originating from the Wuhan lab?
- throwanem 7y agoI wish people who use peer-reviewed articles as supporting evidence when making arguments would do a better job of understanding what those peer-reviewed articles are about. Or, for that matter, of making an argument in the first place. You're not doing that here. You're just noting that a researcher who does research on transmission of coronaviruses from bats to humans, has published research on transmission of coronaviruses from bats to humans. I don't know what conclusion you expect anyone to draw from that.
- fspeech 7y agoPeople can draw their own conclusions. That is what is nice about solid evidence. I will make two notes: 1. Bats can transmit viruses to humans independent of wet markets and research activities and these villagers do travel to cities; 2. This particular research was funded jointly by USA, China and Singapore to monitor possible recurrence of SARS like virus.