5 ms·
Queue a nasty self fulfilling list "your email idea won't work because" checkbox. Sender pays would do a lot. Not popular.
by ggm 7y ago
Queue a nasty self fulfilling list "your email idea won't work because" checkbox.
Sender pays would do a lot. Not popular.
- dewey 7y agoIt would do a lot against democratization of access and one of the good parts of email. > Ubiquitous. Approximately everyone on the Internet has email, or can get it.
- ddevault 7y agoThe sender doesn't have to pay a lot to make it effective. Remember that the spammer is sending email to a hundred thousand addresses per day, for free. If you charged even $0.01 per email, that'd stop a lot of spam right in its tracks. However, some companies sending spam^wnewsletters would be willing to pay. I think this crap needs to stop, too, so this would be a partial solution at best.
- dewey 7y agoI don't think it's necessarily about the amount you charge but that for charging it you need access to a bank account / credit card or other banking infrastructure. That's not the case for everyone taking part in the internet.
- ddevault 7y agoOr proof-of-work, so long as it can be done without invoking The Blockchain (proof of work can be done without a blockchain, but you need to invest in armed guards to shoot anyone who mentions it).
- brazzy 7y agoBecause it's no better an idea than it was 25 years ago when Spam first became a thing and there was another genius throwing this idea around every other day. First, there are some important use cases it would destroy (especially mailing lists). Second, it's impossible to implement gradually. Protocols and infrastructure would have to change drastically, everywhere at once. Not feasible.
- DennisP 7y agoGradual implementation wouldn't have to be hard. Gmail already sorts your inbox into several buckets. If you have one bucket for "paid/whitelisted" and another for others. You can leave the rest to the user.
- brazzy 7y agoSo basically "pay to bypass the spam filter", is that really what we want? And I don't think it would lead to gradual adoption; as long as people still have to pay attention to the other bucket, there is little incentive to start paying at all.
- genpfault 7y agoA classic![1] [1]: https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt
- ggm 7y agoThat's the one
- hakfoo 7y agoI've never seen a good system to differentiate between legitimate transactional email and spam. Both produce high-volume, templatey mail. So how do we make sure that "Vi@gr@ Pilules from C@nada" pays 15 cents per message, without bankrupting the legitimate invoices, tracking updates, mailing lists, and legitimately requested advertising flyers?