3 ms·
> However any decentralised scheme can be turned into a centralised scheme by forcing the phone to report to the authorities that it was at some point in time c
by epistasis 7y ago
> However any decentralised scheme can be turned into a centralised scheme by forcing the phone to report to the authorities that it was at some point in time close to the phone of an infected person.
If the system was different, it would be bad?
This is a slippery-slope argument that I do not find compelling. The amount of surveillance that this is supposedly guarding against--govt tracking of an individual's location--is already possible with no changes to any system.
It is no more slippery a slope for raw unscrambled BTLE identifiers to be reported to a centralized system. I don't think that the encrypted system makes it any easier in the least.
These devices that we carry everywhere are huge privacy concerns, but I don't think this author is even warning about the right things. Does the author even know the amount of location tracking going on in stores, currently? The amount of data that is sold back and forth with no user knowledge or understanding?
The concerns raised here ignore the much worse reality that already exists!!
- twhitmore 7y agoGenerally I agree that location tracking is already relatively widely done, and the Apple/ Google protocol makes reasonable efforts to preserve privacy. I do share some caution, however -- tracing 'personal contacts' by BTLE is likely much more personally specific, and hence significantly more intrusive, than just location. If such mechanisms became more generally available they would likely become used as part of the machinery of repression in states such as China. Or everywhere (depending on our future). Location is fairly imprecise as to social contact, but I guess the concern would be that this will be accurate enough to track dissenters, find their contacts, and accuse/ imprison you.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- stjohnswarts 7y agoThere are legal/ethical barriers though between google and apple sharing this stuff with the government. This is an effort to soften up the populace on "what a good thing" tracking and activity sharing with the government is and why next it should be permanent rather than just an emergency tactic. "Imagine all the good we could do if we had all the data of things you buy, where you go, who you interact with and provided that to government in a package with a bow on it". Kind of like the sunset clause on the "Patriot Act" which keeps getting renewed and is a travesty.