4 ms·
The US is 72.4% white. You would then expect there to be 27.6% non-white students at any particular institution, assuming no racial discrimination, etc. So then
by fastball 7y ago
The US is 72.4% white. You would then expect there to be 27.6% non-white students at any particular institution, assuming no racial discrimination, etc. So then why is 40% non-white a desirable outcome? I thought the point was to compensate for exclusion / marginalization / discrimination, in which case the target should be that aforementioned 27.6%.
EDIT: since many people are replying to me saying that using the national demographic stats is a bad thing to do, I will use the stats for GP's state, which appears to be Virginia. Using these stats (94.2% white), you would expect the school to have only 5.8% non-white students, assuming a complete lack of racial discrimination compared to the state population.
I personally still think using the national stats is a better idea, as the goal of a college / university should not be to only educate people from the state it is located in.
- mikeatgl 7y ago"The White, non-Hispanic or Latino population make up 61.3% of the nation's total, with the total White population (including White Hispanics and Latinos) being 76.9%." - Wikipedia "White alone, not Hispanic or Latino, percent: 60.4%" - census.gov
- fastball 7y agoWhat is your point? Hispanics/latinos can be identified as white. The percent of people in the US that are white by the 2010 census definition is 72.4%.
- DeathArrow 7y agoBut asians are in same boat as whites, lumped together in by the diversity promoters.
- battery_cowboy 7y agoMan, you twisted this comment so much to extract that message. The commenter is likely saying it's good that the campus is more representative, not that they're for the elimination of whites or some shit. Also, you don't know where they live. Where I come from, it's about 80 percent nonwhite. Before you comment, consider that the story you make up in your head isn't always the most likely. Edit: Hawaii has 25 percent whites, so my estimate was correct.
- fastball 7y agoI am using national statistics given a lack of information by the GP. If the GP wants to update with a more accurate location, they are free to, and we can have this discussion with better accuracy. Without that, the "story in my head" is, in fact, the most likely.
- battery_cowboy 7y agoAlso: It doesn't even matter what statistics are correct, your assumption that the original commenter was celebrating antiwhite sentiment is absurd by itself. Original: You're using statistics for the whole USA. There are half a million people here, you're just regressing to the mean, some states have a larger percent nonwhite people. Hawaii has 25 percent whites, so my estimate was correct. Edit: also, your stats are wrong, see the other comment and get some perspective.
- fastball 7y agoI'm confused, why are you going on about Hawaii? From looking at the GP's account info, they seem to teach at a school in Virginia, which is 94.2% white.
- battery_cowboy 7y agoClearly you're not arguing in good faith, since you also didn't know at that time where the commenter was from, so have a good night and continue to fear that your race is being threatened or something like that.
- fastball 7y agoI'm not arguing in good faith? Your point was that using national stats was inaccurate as GP could've been in a state with a lower proportion of whites. However, due to how averages work, it was just as likely that GP was located in a state with a higher proportion of whites than the national average. Then, when I actually bothered to check GP's profile and found out that apparently GP works at a college in Virginia and communicated that fact to you, you started throwing around accusations of "bad faith" and checked yourself out of the conversation. You then added to that with an accusation that I am somehow (despite saying nothing even remotely like this) worried about whites being replaced or similar nonsense. This was compounded by your assumption that I am even white to begin with, or that I even live in the United States. I think some self-reflection might be worthwhile. Projecting your own failings onto others is never a good way to have a conversation.
- ArnoVW 7y agoThose averages are across the country. The distribution will be hugely different depending on whether you are in Iowa or Florida. Moreover, the distribution is not equal across ages. And since only young people go to universities, this has a huge effect.
- fastball 7y agoAre colleges only supposed to attract people from the local area and therefore reflect local demographics? That seems a bit backwards to me. Regardless, GP seems to teach at a school in Virginia, which is 94.2% white. That is a good point about how racial demographics can change between age groups though. Do you have more accurate numbers that we can use in this regard?
- ArnoVW 7y agoYou're lucky I was waiting for a render to finish =) A google of "race distribution over age us" got me this: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/07/30/most-common-age-among-us-racial-ethnic-groups/
- ArnoVW 7y agoBTW,19% of Virginia is black. https://worldpopulationreview.com/states/states-by-race/ https://worldpopulationreview.com/states/states-by-race/
- jimhefferon 7y agoI believe that you are mistaken. My reading of this table from the Census Bureau is that white is 60%: https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/US/PST045219 https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/US/PST045219. Further, college age students are barely majority-white, https://nces.ed.gov/programs/raceindicators/images/figures/figure-raa-4.png https://nces.ed.gov/programs/raceindicators/images/figures/f.... Those are the national stats. I happen to not be from VA. I happen to be from VT (as a google of my user name or email would show). FWIW, I teach at a Catholic school so many of the nonwhite students we see are a variety of Hispanic. But there are also plenty of others, including African Americans. We draw from New England in general, and to a lesser extent the entire Northeast. But if I understand your comment correctly, you are not mistaken in that I am a person who thinks that it is right for educational institutions to make strong efforts about redressing our country's heritage of making life harder for some people than others. In my note I meant to express that there are anecdotal signs of progress. Too few, for sure, and I cannot say how much is due to the diversity officers, but wanted to suggest that the article's contempt for work in this area is not wholly justified.