5 ms·
What you are arguing against is a classic smoke and mirrors job where two unrelated things are linked together. If you look outside the US you see similar huge
by Gibbon1 7y ago
What you are arguing against is a classic smoke and mirrors job where two unrelated things are linked together. If you look outside the US you see similar huge gains in life expectancy. Which are 95% due to basic public health measures.
Seriously:
Life expectancy Cuba: 79.18 years.
Life expectancy US: 79.11
- IkmoIkmo 7y agoI don't live in, or look at exclusively at the US. In western europe for example there've been massive increases in healthcare costs, too. These are socialised, citizens don't pay them through their insurance package, but they're paid by society (citizens) through taxes for sure. And these have created large gains. Cuba is a poor example because it prioritises health over everything else. That's not a value judgement, rather that it's just an outlier. If you mandate in a dictatorial government that people should be doctors and work for a humble salary, then of course you'll see good healthcare outcomes for little money.
- vinay427 7y ago> These are socialised, citizens don't pay them through their insurance package, but they're paid by society (citizens) through taxes for sure. This isn't true for much of western Europe which doesn't have a single-payer model. Subsidies and regulations are more abundant than in the US, certainly, but for example everyone where I live in western Europe has to pay out of pocket for insurance premiums and deal with deductibles, etc.
- yostrovs 7y agoOnly those that never lived under communism would believe those numbers. Same as the information on the coronavirus from China. https://www.econlib.org/about-that-cuban-life-expectancy/ https://www.econlib.org/about-that-cuban-life-expectancy/
- Gibbon1 7y agoYou can make a similar argument that Cuba and China's literacy rate is very low because they're communists.
- yostrovs 7y agoYou can argue anything you want. I just don't believe the numbers reported. Not for healthcare in Cuba, not the virus in China. And literacy rates in communist countries were made high so kids will be indoctrinated into Lenin as quickly and thoroughly as possible. That's the only reason.
- arcticbull 7y agoSure if you just pretend, anything's possible! Your article begins with: "Wealth and health are correlated because greater wealth can buy better health care." Wealth is not the only way to obtain good health outcomes, Cuba has a ton of doctors and they don't get paid massive, overwhelming salaries. Just because they don't get paid outsized amounts doesn't mean they're bad at their jobs. Based on all the OECD charts, there's very much a point of diminishing returns re: spending on healthcare and outcomes -- and very much so re: life expectancy. [1] It's pretty clear that spending 8X as much money didn't make people live 8X longer. [1] https://ourworldindata.org/the-link-between-life-expectancy-and-health-spending-us-focus https://ourworldindata.org/the-link-between-life-expectancy-...
- yostrovs 7y agoI lived in the most prosperous communist country and I know for a fact that the numbers reported are lies. You are free to believe whatever you want since you haven't established the need for skepticism in this sphere. But when lied to often enough, folks like me KNOW were being lied to. Cuban healthcare is that perfect lie the ignorant fall for.