5 ms·
Interesting that "housing is still overvalued" -- I'm not entirely sure that it's drastically priced out of line with history. The price per square foot of the
by arcticbull 7y ago
Interesting that "housing is still overvalued" -- I'm not entirely sure that it's drastically priced out of line with history. The price per square foot of the average American home, when adjusted for inflation, is almost exactly the same as in 1978 -- right around $130. What's changed is houses have gotten bigger (1600 sqft vs 2400). [1]
Now there are pools where arbitrary supply constraints have created massive price increases above inflation (SF, NY) but those markets are historically the ones least affected by a downturn anyways. With that in mind, it's clear that in SF and NY the price of housing is tied to the economic productivity of the area, and frankly, the chances big tech is going to cut pay is below zero.
The dot-com bubble only took 10% off the average house price in SF. The 2008 mortage crisis took 27% over the entire time period -- which was followed by an 88% increase. [2]
[1] https://www.supermoney.com/inflation-adjusted-home-prices/ https://www.supermoney.com/inflation-adjusted-home-prices/
[2] https://www.bayareamarketreports.com/trend/3-recessions-2-bubbles-and-a-baby https://www.bayareamarketreports.com/trend/3-recessions-2-bu...
- IkmoIkmo 7y agoYeah it's insane these simply facts are completely devoid of any discussion. Inflation as we talk about it colloquially is supposed to measure price changes of the same thing. Like an apple. What actually happens in most discussions is that we measure wildly different things and then say 'look, prices changed'. Not just have homes gotten bigger, the heating and cooling is better, they're safer, they're equipped with more amenities etc. My grandparents didn't have a shower, but went to the communal bathhouse once a week. My parents didn't have central heating in one of their homes. I see the same discussion in healthcare. Life expectancy in many western countries grew by 20-30 years since the second world war, which is a radically improved outcome which proxies health throughout life, yet we are shocked this outcome is much more expensive than before. College is trickier, there's tons of inflation there and you can wonder if education really improved. By some measures, it worsened, by some it's much better. What's clear however is that educational attainment has never been higher. That's not to say there's no inflation in any of these areas. But rather that it's much more nuanced if corrected for some values.
- bradleyjg 7y agoI see the same discussion in healthcare. Life expectancy in many western countries grew by 20-30 years since the second world war, which is a radically improved outcome which proxies health throughout life, yet we are shocked this outcome is much more expensive than before. There’s been more than 300% increase in the last thirty years. How much better off are we health wise than 1990? 1945, sure, but 1990?
- Gibbon1 7y agoWhat you are arguing against is a classic smoke and mirrors job where two unrelated things are linked together. If you look outside the US you see similar huge gains in life expectancy. Which are 95% due to basic public health measures. Seriously: Life expectancy Cuba: 79.18 years. Life expectancy US: 79.11
- IkmoIkmo 7y agoI don't live in, or look at exclusively at the US. In western europe for example there've been massive increases in healthcare costs, too. These are socialised, citizens don't pay them through their insurance package, but they're paid by society (citizens) through taxes for sure. And these have created large gains. Cuba is a poor example because it prioritises health over everything else. That's not a value judgement, rather that it's just an outlier. If you mandate in a dictatorial government that people should be doctors and work for a humble salary, then of course you'll see good healthcare outcomes for little money.
- vinay427 7y ago> These are socialised, citizens don't pay them through their insurance package, but they're paid by society (citizens) through taxes for sure. This isn't true for much of western Europe which doesn't have a single-payer model. Subsidies and regulations are more abundant than in the US, certainly, but for example everyone where I live in western Europe has to pay out of pocket for insurance premiums and deal with deductibles, etc.
- tanilama 7y ago> and frankly, the chances big tech is going to cut pay is below zero. I doubt this. It is not like Google/Facebook are not affected by the market downturn. When recession comes, advertising is the at the frontline to be cancelled.
- arcticbull 7y agoSure, but Apple has $200B in cash, Facebook has $52B and Google has $117B. These are some of the most revenue efficient companies in the history of the world. Why risk jeopardizing that by cutting wages and potentially losing your biggest asset? I don't think they cut any pay in 2008, and Apple didn't even have a single round of layoffs. In fact I recall Apple making a bunch of strategic acquisitions at the bottom of all that.
- waheoo 7y ago"cash"..
- unforeseen9991 7y ago"words"..
- ardy42 7y ago> I'm not entirely sure that it's drastically priced out of line with history. The price per square foot of the average American home, when adjusted for inflation, is almost exactly the same as in 1978 -- right around $130. What's changed is houses have gotten bigger (1600 sqft vs 2400). [1] Unfortunately, a buyer can't get a 33% discount by only buying 66% of the house.
- arcticbull 7y ago> Unfortunately, a buyer can't get a 33% discount by only buying 66% of the house. I think we both know you can :) you can either buy a larger house and portion off an in-law unit, which you can then rent. You could buy a smaller house. You could even build on a fresh plot of land.
- ardy42 7y ago> you can either buy a larger house and portion off an in-law unit Wouldn't that make it even more expensive to buy the larger house? You have to get the larger mortgage and pay to remodel the home on top of that. Plus I'm pretty sure there can be zoning restrictions on turning single family homes into multifamily buildings. > You could buy a smaller house. If what you claimed is correct [1], then that implies that smaller houses are relatively scarcer than they were in 1978, and thus harder to find. Just "buy a smaller house" isn't actionable advice if the houses available to buy are larger. [1] The price per square foot has stayed constant adjusted for inflation, and the price increases are due to houses "getting bigger."