3 ms·
The argument that we need political solutions originally came from a time when technology people weren't paying attention to politics at all, and of course then
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
The argument that we need political solutions originally came from a time when technology people weren't paying attention to politics at all, and of course then you get this:
https://xkcd.com/538/ https://xkcd.com/538/
But it feels like it has gone the other way now, to the point that people dismiss potentially helpful technical solutions because "what really matters is politics" even though in reality you need both.
If the government bans privacy technologies then it's hard to use them, but if nobody develops or uses them to begin with then you don't have them either.
And for some people the government in question isn't ours, it's a foreign authoritarian government where "policy solutions" are just not going to happen and the only option available is technology. It's a lot easier to develop that technology in less authoritarian countries, which means we have a responsibility to do it, because if they have to do it the cost of a mistake is a lot higher.
- freedomben 7y agoAgree with you completely. If I take my previous statement further to "don't even bother holing up as insurgents because the government will win the battle" then it goes to a place I don't agree with (I think there's plenty of evidence that the "little guy" can win against big governments. Afghanistan is a great example). So I really should re-phrase my position to clarify that I meant in the United States, but also even in the US I do think the technological solutions are important and should be developed. The important point I want to stress is that I don't think we should ever disregard the political war because of technological confidence in our ability to thwart the authoritarians. Both politics and technology are both critical pieces. If we lose on either front, we lose.