5 ms·
1. It's old people AND people with comorbidities, which is a ton of people. Yep, and they should shelter in place. Nobody else should. 2. Lots of old people,
by arcticbull 7y ago
1. It's old people AND people with comorbidities, which is a ton of people.
Yep, and they should shelter in place. Nobody else should.
2. Lots of old people, which for Covid is about 65, still work full time jobs. Some of them fly every week. These aren't 95+ year olds.
Yep, and they should shelter in place, because they're in a risk category.
3. I'm sure people of all ages think their life is very valuable, and very few people consider themselves candidates for sacrifice. Certainly not for privacy concerns.
That's an unfortunate way of looking at this. The reality is everything we do in life involves risk. There's risk of harm in shutting down the economy, and there's risk of harm in opening the doors. The lifetime risk of death being involved in a car accident is 1%. The lifetime risk of dying of an opioid overdose is 2%. COVID is much lower than both. Locked inside domestic violence is up, alcoholism is up -- liquor stores are considered essential so alcoholics won't come in to hospital due to withdrawal.
What we do know is if we lock things down, then one person flies in from a foreign country with the disease the whole thing starts over. Hiding inside is not a sustainable strategy.
Which is why Sweden remains open for business. And you know what? They're doing just fine [1].
4. 10x deadlier than the flu.
It is not. We do not know how deadly it is, all we know is that of people who go to the hospital (implying that they're showing serious symptoms) between 0% and 9% of people, depending on their age and comorbidities, die.
That's adverse selection sampling bias. Studies show there's huge, huge quantities of people who either show no symptoms at all (which is the thing that makes this disease a challenge) or exhibit mild flu-like symptoms.
The numbers we're seeing are an upper-bound, by an order of magnitude. It's likely in line with the flu, although we should consider in line with the flu is bad -- it kills 650,000 people each and every year we've been alive.
It's also much harder to immunize against the flu (19-60% effective) due to its propensity to mutate and the huge number of strains that show up each season, with different ones being dominant each year.
On the other hand, COVID does not mutate -- or has not yet.
[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesasquith/2020/04/04/no-lockdowns-in-sweden-as-stockholm-remains-open-parks-and-open-air-museums-operating/#77737bef707a https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesasquith/2020/04/04/no-lock...
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoThe ratio of asymptomatic to symptomatic people has been measured, and it's not nearly as high as you're saying. China has been quarantining and testing every single person entering the country, and they find that 2/3rds of cases are asymptomatic. Moreover, Germany has conducted a randomized serological survey of the population of one town where there was a large outbreak, and determined that the true mortality rate was about 0.4%, which is an order of magnitude higher than mortality due to the flu. That's the mortality if there's excellent healthcare and the system isn't overwhelmed. Mortality will also depend on the age structure of the population, rates of obesity and smoking, etc. Because a large fraction of the population is immune to the seasonal flu (both through vaccination and previous infection), far fewer people contract it than would contract CoVID-19 in an uncontrolled epidemic. The combination of a much larger rate of infection than the flu and far higher mortality means that CoVID-19 would kill orders of magnitude more people in one year.
- arcticbull 7y ago> Moreover, Germany has conducted a randomized serological survey of the population of one town where there was a large outbreak... 1. Results showed 0.37% mortality rate, which is an order of magnitude lower than the fatality rates being published, which is what I claimed -- so I re-iterate: "The numbers we're seeing are an upper-bound, by an order of magnitude." [1] 2. 14% of their town has had it already. [1] 3. That 0.37% rate includes all the old and at-risk folks which I was already suggesting we isolate. Since we know the fatality rate for them is 9% in hospital vs 0.1%, I'd suggest that the actual mortality rate of my plan would be incredibly low. [1] We don't know the demographic distribution of the town, and we do know that the disease is incredibly age-dependent so it's hard to project that onto the population. Either way the flu is 0.1% so this isn't 10X worse, it's 3.7X worse. At most. 4. The study shows 15% of them are already immune to COVID. [edit] I found the data [2]. Out of a population of 12,000, 6500 of them are in a risk group (over 45). So 55% of town. This needs to be projected onto the world population factoring into account non-linear risk response. > Because a large fraction of the population is immune to the seasonal flu (both through vaccination and previous infection), far fewer people contract it than would contract CoVID-19 in an uncontrolled epidemic. I don't think they are. The flu mutates regularly, and there's a ton of strains. Vaccinations are only 19-60% effective depending on the year. This is evidenced by the 650,000 worldwide deaths (60,000 US) and the 45,000,000 US cases of the flu each year. [1] https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/04/09/999015/blood-tests-show-15-of-people-are-now-immune-to-covid-19-in-one-town-in-germany/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/04/09/999015/blood-tes... [2] https://www.citypopulation.de/en/germany/nordrheinwestfalen/heinsberg/05370008__gangelt/ https://www.citypopulation.de/en/germany/nordrheinwestfalen/...
- usaar333 7y ago1. A healthy 30 something has an IFR of something like 0.1%. Doesn't justify a lockdown for a year; does for a couple months. 3. Sweden has experienced over 500 covid deaths in a week. That's a 30% excess death rate. Hardly "fine". 4. I see little evidence it is in line with the flu, unless you are talking about historically deadly flus, not seasonal ones. Flu would not have killed 1.5% of the Diamond Princess population that was infected. 0.7% IFR seems about right (Diamond Princess, Iceland, etc. suggest around this) and that's >7x bad seasonal flu years.
- arcticbull 7y ago> A healthy 30 something has an IFR of something like 0.1%. Doesn't justify a lockdown for a year; does for a couple months. It's not 0.1% for a 30-something. The Gangelt survey showed a total population fatality rate of 0.37%, and so far the CFR has ranged from 0% in children to 0.1% for 30-somethings to 15% for 85 year olds. The Gangelt survey showed 0.37% actual vs. a CFR of 2% overall in Germany so we can divide the CFR for each age group likely by 10. It's probably close to 0.01% for a healthy 30-something. > Sweden has experienced over 500 covid deaths in a week. That's a 30% excess death rate. Hardly "fine". It ... is fine, when you take into account that they're never going to get it again, whereas every other country in the world is vulnerable to a single person showing up and re-starting the entire process for everyone. It's not this lockdown I'm worried about it's the next one, when a single person shows up in downtown NYC and we're right back at it again. Hiding inside is not solving the problem because it's an incredibly infectious disease. Unless you can lock down every single person in the entire world for the entire duration, it will fail. > I see little evidence it is in line with the flu, unless you are talking about historically deadly flus, not seasonal ones. Flu would not have killed 1.5% of the Diamond Princess population that was infected. 0.7% IFR seems about right (Diamond Princess, Iceland, etc. suggest around this) and that's >7x bad seasonal flu years. The Gangelt survey showed 0.37% vs the flu at 0.1%. It's worse, I've long maintained it's worse, but it's not massively worse. Certainly not stop-the-world worse. [1] [1] https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/04/09/999015/blood-tests-show-15-of-people-are-now-immune-to-covid-19-in-one-town-in-germany/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/04/09/999015/blood-tes...
- 7y ago
- darkwater 7y agoWell, in the US for seasonal flu the deaths estimation [1] for this season are 24k-60k deaths, for covid19 is 60k-240k, where 60k is applying lockdown, not "everybody work normally". And obviously they are on top of the typical deaths. [1] https://www.statnews.com/2020/04/09/its-difficult-to-grasp-the-projected-deaths-from-covid-19-heres-how-they-compare-to-other-causes-of-death/ https://www.statnews.com/2020/04/09/its-difficult-to-grasp-t...
- arcticbull 7y agoThe German survey showed an actual fatality rate of 0.37% vs the flu at 0.1%. We know herd immunity is in the cards due to the lack of mutation of COVID, and that kicks in at 60-70% of the population. The German study also suggested up to 15% of people may already have it, so we can further reduce this number (an incremental 45-55% of the population getting infected) -- So, if we run some simple arithmetic, we'll see the number of fatalities will be approximately 60-70K. This is in line with the number of fatalities in a difficult flu season. The difference is because COVID does not mutate (or has not yet), this will be a one-off, one-time, one-year issue. The flu kills 60,000 each and every year. The Swedes have it right. We can mitigate this by isolating the vulnerable. So yes, we are, in fact, overreacting. [EDIT] I wonder if this is in fact in excess of deaths we'd see anyways. I'd imagine an 80.5 year old with 3 underlying medical conditions (average in Italy of the dead) isn't just as vulnerable to a bad flu as they are to COVID, so if COVID takes them, the flu won't. [1] https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/04/09/999015/blood-tests-show-15-of-people-are-now-immune-to-covid-19-in-one-town-in-germany/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/04/09/999015/blood-tes...
- camelite 7y agoFirstly, the German study analysed one small particularly hard hit town, so how you are extrapolating this to "people" in general is puzzling. Secondly, there is a very wide range of reported fatality rates, with myriad factors known and unknown, so why you've chosen the lowest one globally (which, by the by, has always been an outlier and in any case is edging up past 1%) as the "actual" rate is, again, puzzling. Finally, you are making a giant but unfortunately common logical error in using these already questionable death counts to make the case for an overreaction without attending to the obvious fact that without this "overreaction" every town, village and city on Earth would be Bergamo, where army lorries are conscripted to transport the dead from overwhelmed mortuaries, or worse. Do better friendo.
- joshuamorton 7y ago> The lifetime risk of death being involved in a car accident is 1%. You're off by a factor of 100. It's .01%. > The lifetime risk of dying of an opioid overdose is 2%. For who? Someone who uses opioids? Maybe, on average, again you're off by a factor of 100 or more. > We do not know how deadly it is, all we know is that of people who go to the hospital No, of people who test positive, which includes people with relatively mild symptoms that don't go to the hospital, but had reason or ability to get tested. South Korea is probably the best current testbed here, they had very widespread testing and they've had very, very slow growth recently so the CFR numbers are probably relatively accurate. They see a 3% CFR. > Which is why Sweden remains open for business. And you know what? They're doing just fine [1]. Normalized by population, Sweden has seen more deaths and more infections than California, by about 50%, and it will likely continue to grow at a similar rate. The problem with exponential growth is that things look like they're doing just fine until suddenly they aren't and there's no way to fix things.
- arcticbull 7y ago> You're off by a factor of 100. It's .01%. > For who? Someone who uses opioids? Maybe, on average, again you're off by a factor of 100 or more. No, lol, it's not. Those are averages across the US population. Your lifetime odds in the US of dying in an automotive accident is 1:103 [1]. I should have said accidental poisoning which is 1:64 [2] but half of that is actually opioids (1:96) so you're still more likely to die of an opioid overdose than being a party to a car accident. Most people don't set out to get hooked on Oxy, they get hurt or undergo surgery, are prescribed them, and that's that. There's 40,000 deaths per year related to car accidents, which if you multiply out by the average lifetime (78.69 years) is right around 3.2 million, or 1%. This is fair to compare against COVID because due to its extremely limited propensity for mutation, the COVID mortality rate does represent what approximates lifetime risk. (i.e. unlike the flu, you won't get it again). > South Korea is probably the best current testbed here... I argue the best testbed is the German study I cited where they actually tested... everyone. CFR is not mortality rate, its about an order of magnitude higher, again, I cited my data. And in my intuitive explanation that you're not factoring out adverse selection risk of only very sick people going to the hospital in the first place. > Normalized by population, Sweden has seen more deaths and more infections than California. Because everyone in California is inside. I'm sure they've seen an order of magnitude more flu deaths too because nothing spreads when you're inside. They're probably seeing infinitely more car accident deaths, too. Life's risky, and you're not comparing honestly. [1] https://www.iii.org/fact-statistic/facts-statistics-mortality-risk https://www.iii.org/fact-statistic/facts-statistics-mortalit...