4 ms·
This is wonderful news for any surveillance state. As the three-page brief on DP-3T [1] says: "A tech-savvy adversary could reidentify identifiers of infected
by FartyMcFarter 7y ago
This is wonderful news for any surveillance state. As the three-page brief on DP-3T [1] says:
"A tech-savvy adversary could reidentify identifiers of infected people that they have
been physically close to in the past by
i) actively modifying the app to record more
specific identifier data and
ii) collecting extra information about identities through
additional means, such as a surveillance camera to record and identify the
individuals. This would generally be illegal, would be spatially limited, and high effort."
If I read this correctly, this means that a government could collect identifier data on a per-location basis and later link this to someone's identity (for example with cameras or by tracking the IP address of uploaded identifiers).
Unfortunately I can think of quite a few entities (e.g. governments) who are not too worried about doing high effort, spatially limited things in order to track people's locations. Saying that this is "illegal" (which is probably not even true in all countries) does not give me confidence it wouldn't happen either.
[1] https://github.com/DP-3T/documents/raw/master/DP3T%20-%20Simplified%20Three%20Page%20Brief.pdf https://github.com/DP-3T/documents/raw/master/DP3T%20-%20Sim...
- dmarchand90 7y agoI was under the impression that the NSA already was tracking most people anyway?
- FartyMcFarter 7y agoGPS / phone network tracking probably has lower precision than short-range bluetooth. Bluetooth receivers can be present even in places without network reception or GPS, and receive signal passively and without a trace.
- dmarchand90 7y agoI guess I'm not clear to that extent the NSA hacks people phones. I would imagine for most users they would have good access to our GPS data, e.g. via Google Maps? Edit: I'm assuming that GPS level precision is sufficient to start the dystopia
- mikarv 7y agoThe alternative approach to contact tracing means that a central server can learn most of or the entire of the social graph. This is a considerable reduction of power in comparison.