4 ms·
Can people who are not inherently 'gifted', start with an immense interest in math at a mid-point in their life, and still go on to make meaningful and signific
by cperciva 18y ago
Can people who are not inherently 'gifted', start with an immense interest in math at a mid-point in their life, and still go on to make meaningful and significant contributions to the field?
Probably not.
In other words, is precocity a prerequisite to doing good work in Math?
Maybe, depending on whether you by "precocity" you mean "demonstrated precocity".
Intelligence is something you either have or don't have -- and while there's still debate about how much of intelligence is genetic (25%? 50%? 75%?) it's clear that the nurture which is most important is that which takes place before age 5, when the brain is still at its most plastic. Consequently, I would say that anyone who is not gifted when they're 5 years old is unlikely to have a significant mathematical impact.
However, not everybody with intellectual gifts demonstrates them early. Mathematics is a field known for child prodigies, not because it's particularly suited to prodigies, but rather because mathematics prodigies tend to get noticed. Some fields, like mathematics or chess, have little knowledge required before intellect can be applied; others, such as chemistry or biology, require years of prerequisite study. Moreover, just like chess prodigies, the abilities of a mathematics prodigy are obvious and unarguable, while a remarkable writer is still likely to be rejected by his first 19 publishers -- and what 9 year old writer is going to send his manuscript to 20 publishers?
In short: You have to be smart to do make a significant contribution to mathematics, and I don't believe that people can "become smart" past a very early age. However, it's possible for someone to be smart despite not having been recognized as such, depending on which fields his intellect is applied against. Finally, it's definitely possible for someone who is smart but has never done well in mathematics to make a contribution to mathematics -- if he can develop the interest which is necessary for him to apply his intellect appropriately.
Is this a useful answer? I have some other ideas about intelligence and IQ and the Putnam and flashes of insight floating around, but I'm not entirely certain how to explain them -- and given that news.yc stories don't stay on the front page for long, I thought I should post what I could promptly rather than waiting for everything else to crystallize.
- yelsgib 18y agoWhat is "intelligence?" Can we separate it from society's conception of it? Can we state a computational definition rather than a definition in terms of satisfaction of cultural standards? We undervalue a lot of mental attributes - consistency of thought, sensitivity to subtle differences in concepts, patience, self-reflection, the ability to "go meta" etc. which cannot be detected by the rough and rigid abstract problem solving required by low-level Math (e.g. the Math problems which would qualify prodigies). I am highly turned off by the idea that we can't "become smart" after an early age. I feel like I "got smart" after I started playing go, I feel like I "got smart" after I learned category theory. I feel like every year I get smarter - and not smarter in the sense of "having more knowledge" but smarter in the sense of being able to solve larger classes of problems, and more complicated problems. and c.
- billroberts 18y agoI'm not sure that your experience of feeling smarter contradicts cperciva's point about intelligence being determined early in life. I can see that there could be a difference between intelligence as some kind of innate capacity and how that capacity is applied to various tasks. You can certainly learn more stuff and so be able to do more difficult things, but your ability to learn and apply knowledge may not be changing.
- yelsgib 18y agoThis is a good point. I agree that my feeling smarter does not actually mean that I am smarter. I -do- produce a lot more, but this could be due to other factors. I think you're hitting very close to the important issue here which is that all of this is very difficult to define/think about without a really good idea of what sorts of computations our brains perform. My point isn't really so much that I think it can change, even, it's that we should be way more skeptical when it comes to making claims about subtle concepts like these. Usually I find that those who say "we are only really growing intellectually until we're 5" have a very limited and kind of rigid conception of intelligence.
- Prrometheus 18y ago>I am highly turned off by the idea that we can't "become smart" after an early age. I feel like I "got smart" after I started playing go, I feel like I "got smart" after I learned category theory. The percentage of the population that can participate in the two activities you mentioned is probably less than 1%. You probably were smart at an early age.
- yelsgib 18y agoYou're justifying a hypothesis circularly. I was somewhat gifted at an early age, but I consider my intellectual growth over the past 5 years (17-22) to vastly outstrip my growth before that.
- thaumaturgy 18y ago
- gtt 18y ago"not because it's particularly suited to prodigies, but rather because mathematics prodigies tend to get noticed. Some fields, like mathematics or chess, have little knowledge required before intellect can be applied" it is not true. imo modern math requires years of study to reach the border of known. to topic starter: i know pretty good mathematicians who think that geniality exists and who think it does not. i thought about it for a while and come to conclusion that it does not matter. The right question to ask: Am i enjoy (fall in love with) math? p.s. those mathematicians who believe in existance of geniality think that "love math or not" is a good test.
- cperciva 18y agoimo modern math requires years of study to reach the border of known. You're right -- and modern mathematics requires more study than a field like computer science, simply because computer science as a field hasn't had enough time to accumulate very much content. (This is one of the ideas I mentioned as floating around but not fully crystallized earlier.) But this doesn't contradict what I was saying: My point was not about doing original research, but merely about crossing the threshold to being recognized as a prodigy. A 13 year old attending university is certainly noticed -- but that doesn't mean he's doing original research (I didn't until I was 15).
- gtt 18y ago15? wow! may i look at your papers?
- cperciva 18y agoMy publications are at http://www.daemonology.net/papers/ http://www.daemonology.net/papers/, but this doesn't include the work I did when I was 15 -- that was a novel algorithm for computing polynomial GCDs over algebraic number fields, which I never published due to unresolved loose ends involving high-degree fields (professors encouraged me to publish it anyway -- but I didn't want to published something "unfinished"). It turns out that those "loose ends" are rather mixed up with the problem of integer factorization, which might be why I couldn't manage to tie them up. :-)
- gambling8nt 18y agoI don't agree with your choice of cutoff age--certainly it is correct that the historical figures who had made the largest contributions to the field of mathematics have done so while quite young--indeed, the prime ages for developing new mathematics seem historically to be between 17 and 23--but there is nothing to suggest predestination regarding the matter at age 5. Also, given the level of specialization involved with some open problems (and the overwhelmingly large amount of data involved in all of mathematics), it is certainly possible that someone deeply specializing in an aspect of mathematics not "popular" at the time could make a non-negligible contribution to mathematics even if they started late in life, and were less "smart" than their "prodigy" peers. If you start mathematics late in life, you are extraordinarily unlikely to find your name on a list with names like Gauss, Newton, and Archimedes. Nor will you likely reach any sort of par with Euler, Hilbert, or Russell. Indeed, even the levels of Conway, Shannon, and Wiles are probably unattainable. But math is a huge field now, and there are parts of it that most young mathematicians find boring, or simply aren't exposed to. If you find some such part that you like, you can probably make some progress.