6 ms·
Subprime loans already being abused again, this time to push car sales
- functionoid 16y agoBanks have money, thanks to the government. And they will find ways to lend that money till they again dig themselves a hole.
- jurjenh 16y agoWell, with 859,000 sub-prime car loans already handed out, seems like they're well on the way already. Can anyone explain to me how handing out sub-prime loans to anyone is a "sign of health returning to the economy?"
- electromagnetic 16y agoIts like how being diagnosed with cancer is a sign that you're still alive. At least temporarily.
- sethg 16y ago“Sub-prime credit rating” ≠ “guaranteed to default”. If you look at the graph next to the article, the number of sub-prime auto loans being issued is not up to the level it was during 2005–2009. (Unfortunately the graph doesn’t go any farther to the left, so I can’t tell if 2005–2009 was a bubble in the auto-loan market or just business as usual.) And defaulting on a $20K car loan is not nearly as disastrous (for the borrower or the lender) as defaulting on a $200K mortgage.
- ck2 16y agodefaulting on a $20K car loan is not nearly as disastrous Unless of course there are 100 times the number of housing defaults, because the car is not worth the price it was bought at a month later after it's used. Unlike land, cars never increase in value, they only plummet. I've never owned a car newer than 10 years old, I don't know why people have to drive brand new cars, they certainly don't get better gas milage (and apparently many people are using the credit to buy SUVs anyway).
- sethg 16y agoAmong the reasons why the sub-prime mortgage crisis has been Bad For America are: ¶ People who live in depressed areas who are underwater on their mortgages can’t move to someplace with better job prospects unless they abandon hope of recovering the equity in their current house. ¶ In neighborhoods where a significant number of houses have been foreclosed on (or where there is a lot of excess capacity because it was built up right before the bubble burst), all property values suffer, even the value of houses where the owners have good credit and have been making their payments. ¶ It’s a PITA for a bank to sell a foreclosed house, especially in a neighborhood where there have been a lot of other foreclosures (see above). None of these factors apply to car loans.
- damoncali 16y agoThere is nothing wrong with sub prime loans. When sub primes are priced as if they weren't, and then sold around the world with staggering leverage, then you have a problem.
- ck2 16y agoEspecially since no-one from the financial industry has been put in prison for what was done. Zero punishment, even when caught, so zero risk. They are also doing end-runs now around housing regulations, discovering that by requiring 20% down payment, the bank escapes liability for bad loans, regardless of other terms or buyer worthiness.
- hnal943 16y agoZero Punishment? Tell that to Lehman Brothers. You do realize that the banks lose money when mortgages go bad, right? If your complaint is that the federal government through Fannie Mae and Freddy Mac is underwriting the risk of these loans, I would agree that's a problem. But the solution is to no longer underwrite loans, not throw business people in jail.
- damoncali 16y agoYou're confusing fraud with poor business decisions. The economic damage happened because people got irrational about the housing market for various reasons. The result was poorly priced loans that were bought with extreme amounts of leverage (100x was not unusual). When your collateral turns out be worth a fraction of what you thought, your lenders get prickly and want their money back. Except there is no money. Take that and spread it all around the world, and you have a mess. Fraud, although I'm sure there was a bunch of it (as there always is) that really had nothing to do with it. Don't look for conspiracy when incompetence is staring you in the face. This was not a financial industry problem. It was created by unrealistic homeowners, opportunistic bankers, stupid politicians, and a culture that says (for some reason I can't fathom) that home ownership is inherently good. In other words, just about everyone. If you bought or sold a home in the last 10 years, you contributed to the mess in your own tiny way. And yes, it will happen again. Not one thing of substance was done to stop it after the fact. In fact, the government (yes, that's our fault again) has increased the likelihood of future meltdowns by introducing an unprecedented level of moral hazard by bailing out troubled entities.
- mixmax 16y agothe big problem for the US is the American consumer. For the last 20 years the average American has been using $1.10 for every dollar made. This has been possible due to cheap loans and rising real estate prices. The bare truth is that for the last many years America, and to some extent Europe, has been living well beyond its means.
- alecco 16y agoThat's not necessarily bad. As long it's credit for durable goods not experiencing bubbled up prices. There's good and bad leverage. Good leverage is essential to develop a healthy economy.
- mixmax 16y agoI entirely agree that borrowing for durable goods isn't a bad idea if you can afford it. My argument is that for the last many years normal households have been buying stuff they can't afford with money they don't have. And now that the housing prices aren't rising anymore they have serious trouble since they can't take out another mortgage on their house.
- RyanMcGreal 16y agoCars != durable goods.
- trenton 16y agoEcon 101: product with a life span of at least 3 years. http://www.esa.doc.gov/about-economic-indicators http://www.esa.doc.gov/about-economic-indicators http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Durable_good http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Durable_good
- RyanMcGreal 16y agoYes, you're correct by the definition. I was thinking in terms similar to those articulated more clearly in this comment by RyanHolliday: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2284071 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2284071 A car loses 30% of its value as you roll it off the lot, and it continues losing value steadily until the cost of keeping it on the road surpasses the cost of buying a replacement.
- garply 16y agoI found this article interesting, but I think the submission title might be guilty of "gratuitous editorial spin" as outlined in http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- dreish 16y agoThis is a vastly different issue from subprime home loans. The key difference is that depreciation of cars is reasonably predictable; car prices are not typically subject to speculative bubbles.
- asterix 16y agoThe fact is, sub-prime market is where banks make most of their money, not the prime market. These loans have ridiculous fees ($2000 in fee for $3000 car) in addition to high interest rates to bypass state usury laws. Banks don't really care, they get these fees and sell the loans to investors. I am hoping to make some change in this market. I am working on a start up that would help those with limited credit, like Gen Y, get car loans at better than bank rates. More when I have a decent beta page ready, which should be soon :-) But would be interested to learn if those just starting their careers (18-24 yrs) are facing problem getting car loans at reasonable interest rates.