23 ms·
No, the safety data is not well controlled in this case. There are lots of ways to administer a vaccine, it doesn't have to be injection. Look up the history o
by Robotbeat 7y ago
No, the safety data is not well controlled in this case. There are lots of ways to administer a vaccine, it doesn't have to be injection.
Look up the history of vaccination. Starting in the late 18th Century, people used to do this exact thing for early vaccinations: they found a naturally occurring, less pathogenic strain (for instance, cowpox[1] in the days of smallpox), and intentionally exposed people. This is exactly the same thing as a vaccine except less controlled and, ultimately, much less safe.
.
[1]The root of "vaccine" is "vacca," i.e. Latin for "cow," for this reason.
- danieltillett 7y agoSafety data can be gained from epidemiology studies. There is more than one way to work out if a treatment is safe and effective.
- Robotbeat 7y agoEpidemiological studies are much poorer than clinical trials. I’d rather have low-N but well controlled clinical trials than nebulous epidemiological studies.
- danieltillett 7y agoOf course, but in this pandemic we shouldn’t let the perfect be the enemy of the good. Waiting for the perfect vaccine to be developed will have a very high cost. There are no easy options here.