7 ms·
Some shirts hide you from cameras, but will anyone wear them?
- ph0rque 7y ago"Is that you hiding from the cameras, or are you just wearing an ugly shirt?"
- heeen2 7y ago“What’s that?” she asked. “The ugliest T-shirt in the world,” he said, and kissed her cheek. “The Bollards will be disappointed,” she said, coming in and closing the door. “I thought they’d had me sleeping in that.” “So ugly that digital cameras forget they’ve seen it.” “Cameras can see it. The surveillance cameras can all see it, but then they forget they’ve seen it.” “Why?” “Because their architecture tells them to forget it, and anyone who’s wearing it as well. They forget the figure wearing the ugly T-shirt. Forget the head atop it, the legs below, feet, arms, hands. It compels erasure. That which the camera sees, bearing the sigil, it deletes from the recalled image. Though only if you ask it to show you the image. So there’s no suspicious busy-ness to be noticed. If you ask for June 7, camera 53, it retrieves what it saw. In the act of retrieval, the sigil, and the human form bearing it, cease to be represented. By virtue of deep architecture. Gentlemen’s agreement." William Gibson, Zero History (2010)
- jmaa 7y agoThat sounds more realistic than one might expect. Most printers will apparently reject printing of patterns containing the EURion pattern [1], commonly found on paper cash. Not a far stretch that some facial recognition tech might contain deliberate hidden patterns in the future. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EURion_constellation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EURion_constellation
- anigbrowl 7y agoI like the license plate dress featured in the article. A simpler point to bear in mind that even after the immediate pandemic emergency is over many people will need to continue to wear a mask in public. Doing errands/outdoor exercise/volunteer work in public while masked is an enjoyable increase of freedom and privacy.
- consultutah 7y agoThe thing is, they won’t work forever or even for very long. Even makeup will eventually be thwarted.
- quickthrowman 7y agoI remember seeing an article about how ICP “juggalo” makeup fools some facial recognition software, I wonder if that has been solved yet?
- Igelau 7y agoThe juggalos are evolving. They have superior technology. We thought we'd finally cracked the code, but it was too late: the enemy was already within the gates. Our hopes were doused in a shower of Faygo, and the machine lay sizzling its last breath in the putrid foam.
- falcolas 7y agoCV dazzle has been around for at least 7 years; an eternity in this era of CV growth. It still works. What makes you believe it will be thwarted?
- ceejayoz 7y agoAs with ad blocking, no one really cares until it becomes widespread. CV doesn't account for dazzle because no one's really using it; there are more immediate problems to solve of higher utility. There's also the non-technical approaches, like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-mask_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-mask_law.
- freedomben 7y agoI'm certainly no expert in CV, but having worked in government/law enforcement tech previously (pre-Snowden days) I have full confidence that if people started actually using CV Dazzle to evade detection, they would work on breaking through it. Generally speaking those systems only receive features that are actually problems the users are facing. Once they identify the problem they can throw nearly unlimited amounts of money at it, and they will win. This is why I'm focusing my efforts on political solutions to protect our privacy, rather than technical solutions. That's not to say I don't think technical solutions are important, because they absolutely are, but even things like encryption could be made illegal politically if they want to. Thus politics is the most important arena for privacy advocates IMHO.
- mattkevan 7y agoGetting strong William Gibson/Zero History vibes from that article. If you haven’t read the book (written over a decade ago), a major plot point revolves around a T-shirt that renders the wearer invisible to CCTV cameras.
- bawolff 7y agoThat was the first thing i thought of too
- yandrypozo 7y agoSorry I couldn't read the article, could someone post where to buy those shirts, I'll use them for sure.
- yumraj 7y agoThe license plate dress has the added benefit that buggy self driving cars may actually notice the pedestrian wearing it.
- LeifCarrotson 7y agoYou might be able to take your car out for a walk if the adaptive cruise will latch onto and follow your shirt plate! It could be like having a leash-trained 3500 lbs steel dog - just hope it doesn't see any squirrels. Heel, Tesla!
- BelleOfTheBall 7y agoHonestly, I'd wear that dress easily, even for regular outings, not just for hiding from cameras. Those hoodies, though, maybe I'm an old fart but they're a bit too "abstract". Sadly, those seem like the most effective option right now. I read the Adversarial Patch article [0] and it pretty much demonstrated similar patterns. Trouble is, if these get widespread enough - they won't look out of place but the moment they become widespread is the moment updates get pushed to make them obsolete. It's an unescapable situation. [0]: https://arxiv.org/abs/1712.09665 https://arxiv.org/abs/1712.09665
- ph0rque 7y ago> Trouble is, if these get widespread enough - they won't look out of place but the moment they become widespread is the moment updates get pushed to make them obsolete. It's an unescapable situation. Did you just say recurring revenue (for the clothing makers)?
- itronitron 7y agoFinally I have an excuse to wear my ugly Christmas sweaters all year long
- emptybits 7y agoRelated thought, on hiding from cameras and overzealous public identification systems... Most western nations are now, temporarily, accepting face coverings as daily attire in the age of COVID-19. Plenty of asian and muslim nations did previously, for cultural and health reasons. Culturally acceptable anonymity, courtesy of the pandemic. Maybe this isn't temporary if the fear of future viral spreads takes root in culture.
- NikolaNovak 7y agoneat if it worked, but article specifically calls out that Chinese (and other) systems have been trained on medical-masked datasets :-/
- emptybits 7y agoYes, several Chinese companies claim to do reliable identification of masked faces.[1] I find that pretty amazing but time will tell. [1] https://thenextweb.com/neural/2020/03/10/masks-wont-make-you-safe-from-facial-recognition/ https://thenextweb.com/neural/2020/03/10/masks-wont-make-you...
- JauntTrooper 7y agoI wonder how accurate gait recognition technology will become.
- prophesi 7y agoI ordered this specific anti-human recognition hoddie, and it actually looks pretty awesome. It really only goes well with black/grey pants, though. https://www.rageon.com/products/ensemble-7 https://www.rageon.com/products/ensemble-7 And Adversarial Fashion's anti-ALPR backpacks are cool looking as well. https://adversarialfashion.com/collections/bags/products/state-plate-alpr-backpack https://adversarialfashion.com/collections/bags/products/sta... Sadly, it's definitely much easier to push out a software update than it is to replace your clothing. But that game of cat and mouse won't start until the clothing becomes more commonplace, which is very doubtful.
- the8472 7y agoThe mostly black backpack makes me wonder if a vantablack-covered tarp poncho would work. Since you should just be a black, featureless blob to a camera there's not much for the NN to latch onto other than outline.
- close04 7y agoThe backpack works because it's not just black and it actually includes some adversarial input ("fake" license plates). A Vantablack poncho wouldn't protect you more than a regular poncho with no distinguishing patterns. The image recognition wouldn't really latch on to creases in your clothes to perform recognition. Your face would still be visible and there's nothing about solid black that further confuses the AI behind the system, there are far better adversarial examples for that.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoAnti-ALPR patterns really should be using diplomatic plates from the axis of evil countries for extra fun.
- prophesi 7y agoWelp, I know what my project will be during the self-quarantine. https://adversarialfashion.com/pages/diy-resources https://adversarialfashion.com/pages/diy-resources
- yellow_lead 7y agoWill anyone wear it while crossing the street with Tesla's on the road?
- noodlesUK 7y agoWhat about an incredibly bright set of IR lights? Surely that would cause most cameras (at least IR ones) to massively overexpose. It might only work at night though.
- dylan604 7y agoTo me, this is the best way to go. I've seen the hats with the UV LEDS embedded in the brim, but why not around the collar of a shirt?. The only side effect I see is UV light directly in the face. Not sure if the UV wavelengths/intensity can be low enough to blind a camera to not cause odd tan lines or worse?
- blincoln 7y agoUV LEDs probably won't do much against cameras. You want NIR, around 700-800nm. Security cameras are generally sensitive to it, unlike UV.
- dylan604 7y agoThat's even better. IR won't cause skin cancer. Either way, blinding the camera with lights that are invisible to other people unlike these outfits would be much more effective. You can still be subversive without advertising it to anyone. If you're recruiting, then sure, where these outfits. If you actually want to not be seen by the cameras, make the cameras unable to see.
- Igelau 7y agoThe cameras won't recognize you when you literally catch on fire.
- starky 7y agoYou are correct that it would only work at night since a majority of cameras out there have IR Cut Filters for daylight colour accuracy. Not to mention the safety risks of strapping IR LEDs that are that bright at other people's eye level.
- jerrysievert 7y agoamusingly I've seen a couple of people out recently wearing anti-cv masks. I guess you wear what you've already purchased, but it's most interesting that I've seen more than one.
- davidw 7y agoI could see this being a sub plot in a modern day Seinfeld. Kramer buys one - or sells them? Things go sideways.
- notJim 7y agoI seriously hope this begins to become a fashion trend in the near future. I don't see why one of the more out-there fashion designers wouldn't pick it up.
- chipperyman573 7y agoAs soon as it becomes mainstream models will be trained for it.
- turblety 7y agoNa, just make it illegal. Governments are increasingly eroding people's freedoms. Let's remove another one, and force everyone to wear approved and regulated clothing. You know, for your own safety.
- dylan604 7y agoThe second image in the article looks like the result of some machine learning output. Something like the result of the Deep Dreaming app.
- ufmace 7y agoObviously this is going to turn into one of those back-and-forth wars of more effective adversarial clothing designs versus improved detection algorithms. What I really wonder is, which one comes out on top in the end, or at least most of the time? Will designs and/or fashions get weird and effective enough that it just isn't practical to recognize people in general in public with computerized algorithms? Or will the algorithms win, with these being 95% ineffective and also resulting in drastically more attention from ordinary people and any human authorities who happen to be watching?
- tartoran 7y agoIf I could pixelate my own skin on a whim I wouldn’t worry about the shirt. Unconfortably I think eventually we’ll become fully traceable and privacy will be a thing of the past.
- ColanR 7y agoTangential topic. Are masks of the type worn to protect against covid-19 effective against being identified on camera? Because this seems like an amazing excuse (in terms of a silver lining on a very dark cloud) for facemasks as 'anonymity wear' to become mainstream.
- markhall 7y agoYes/No. Here, probably. Elsewhere, no. In China, their facial recognition has got so good that they can track people even with face masks on: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/03/how-china-built-facial-recognition-for-people-wearing-masks/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/03/how-china-built-...
- aledalgrande 7y agoAlso if you add gait recognition, you can add as many masks and hoodies as you want, but you will not escape recognition.
- FridgeSeal 7y agoWould wearing some kind of full length cloak or burqa-sequence garment that obscures a lot of movement be a plausible counter? Obviously they can’t obscure everything about your gait, but I imagine they’d take away enough useful information to make it significantly harder.
- aledalgrande 7y agoProbably, but at that point you'd stand out to humans! Imagine being at an airport...
- ShiftedClock 7y agoFor now, but if everyone was wearing one it could work.
- 7y ago
- hattar 7y agoWouldn’t wearing something like this just make you much more of a target? Maybe I don’t understand these things well, but it seems if I were trying to track people I’d make the very small minority wearing something like this a target group. Another way of thinking about it, if I’m the only person in my community wearing these weird patterns, aren’t I even more identifiable than I would be otherwise?
- dillonmckay 7y agoOnly to humans.
- leib 7y agoIn China police are sent notifciations if undesireable people are seen on camera in their jurisdictioin. I imagine for those people the ability to move around undetected would be very much worth the garish pattern. I also question just whether the average policeman would be able to tell whether clothing was designed to be untrackable
- vkreso 7y agoIt's called Streissand effect! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect
- jwilk 7y agoRelevant XKCD: https://xkcd.com/1105/ https://xkcd.com/1105/
- holidayacct 7y agoIt's pointless, here is why: https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/fyrqi2/til_that_there_are_long_distance_piezoelectric/ https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/fyrqi2/til_that...
- mikece 7y agoI’ll buy five!!
- pedalpete 7y agoI was hoping for something that thwarted the processing in the CCD (chip that captures light in digital cameras AFAIK) instead of something that just thwarts the recognition algorithms. Of course, if the camera still captures a perfect image, that image or video is always around to be processed at a later date.
- starky 7y agoCCD cameras haven't been the preferred camera sensor for more than a decade at this point. The entire industry moved to CMOS a long time ago. You might find CCDs in use today in specific scenarios like where you need global shutters, but even then, you can buy CMOS sensors with global shutters that outperform those CCDs.
- pacala 7y agoThis is futile. The cat is out of the bag. There is no technological counter to AI + ubiquitous sensor networks. There are AI systems out there that can identify you by gait. Possibly already in your phone, ostensibly to help detect if the phone is carried by someone else. Straightforward to connect to the 24/7 video surveillance network that is built all around us: ring, self-driving cars/drones that double as corporate spies, video checkout, etc. Furthermore, radars are coming to your phone in the near future: https://atap.google.com/soli https://atap.google.com/soli. There is no way to hide from such radars picking up everything that moves: your gait, your breath, your heartbeat. Oh, and the gait, breath and heartbeat of anyone near you, whether they agreed to the 500 pages EULA surrendering their privacy or not.
- kitotik 7y agoHi fellow jaded cynic! I can’t disagree with anything in your post, but I would add that there always opportunities to be a pain in the ass. Maybe not all systems can be toppled, but most can certainly be hacked, abused, slowed down, obscured, damaged, re-purposed, stolen, rebooted, copied, exposed, hidden, rendered obsolete, improved, deleted, etc. I see your defeatism and raise you a giant middle finger!
- bernardlunn 7y agoI agree. Messing with the system can be fun even if ultimately futile. Also the fact that AI can sometimes be stupid can sometimes lead to good trading opportunities.
- mirimir 7y agoPrivacy in meatspace is dead. Totally dead. Hopeless. Never coming back, unless technological society crashes. Privacy online is all that remains. In meatspace, I strive only to be unremarkable. In my case, just a tired old man. Nothing to see here. My cover story, I suppose, is using a VPN service to hide my porn addiction. Edit: I recommend Vinge's True Names.
- aaron695 7y agoWear a fking mask. The claim Hanwang's software works is dubious at best. And they also admit with sunglasses it totally fails. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-facial-recognition/even-mask-wearers-can-be-idd-china-facial-recognition-firm-says-idUSKBN20W0WL https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-facial...
- Noos 7y agoOne of the more memorable stories I read as a child was "A Bowl of Biskies Makes a Growing Boy" by Raymond F. Jones. In it, the intelligent, scientific teen with an aptitude for chemistry discovers the government is lacing breakfast cereals with drugs to quell the populace. The boy discovers it, weans himself off the drug, and then eats mostly from the health food store to avoid it. But the government uses that store to round up anyone who discovers the truth, because it's a sign plain as day you have. Stuff like this makes me think of that story. If anything, a motivated government could just train policeman on what patterns or clothing break camera recognition and stop people based on it. Or if you have an obscured plate, they don't need the camera if it's the law not to have it. This really only works if we have pervasive but more or less harmless surveillance by benign or robotic actors. But this is kind of like that health food store in that all the technical solutions in the world can't stop a motivated agent. You have to eat somewhere, and you have to exist in more than just image recognition databases.