15 ms·
"raises the question", not "begs". That means something else. http://begthequestion.info http://begthequestion.info
by sneak 7y ago
"raises the question", not "begs". That means something else.
http://begthequestion.info http://begthequestion.info
- chrbr 7y agoNever knew that. Today I learned something!
- alexilliamson 7y agoYou're doing God's work. That site is hilarious.
- _ph_ 7y agoThanks for the information, I am a non-native speaker and only picked up the expression from the net. I have to admit though, that I fail to understand the reasoning on that page other than "it means something different".
- sneak 7y agoDon't sweat it, it's a common error made by native speakers too, myself included until I learned about it. :)
- zimpenfish 7y agoIt's really not an error anymore because it's been in common usage for years.
- rriepe 7y agoLet them be. If we didn't have prescriptivists, everything would literally mean nothing.
- zimpenfish 7y agoAnd if that was the common usage that people agreed on and understood, that would be perfectly fine. It's literally how language works!
- throwanem 7y agoPeople who complain about this are mostly just being preciously prescriptivist, and they typically do a shockingly poor job of explaining the issue. To "beg the question", canonically, is to argue in a way that only makes sense if whatever you're arguing to support is true. It's a difficult sort of fallacy to provide examples for because it's quite rare, so most examples you see tend to be constructed for the sake of complaining about the supposed misuse of the phrase "beg the question", and so either trivial or incomprehensible or both. Too, the phrase "beg the question" itself relies on a rather outmoded sense of the word "beg", whose rarity in modern usage makes the prescribed meaning of the phrase very difficult to intuit compared to the supposedly incorrect one. All of which begs the question: why should anyone care what complaints linguistic prescriptivists make in the case of this phrase, any more than in the case of any other?
- earthboundkid 7y agoSomeone mistranslated Latin into English 300 years ago and now some nerds are mad that people are misinterpreting the mistranslation. Best to just ignore the whole thing by never writing "begging the question." Always write either "raising the question" or "circular reasoning" depending on what you mean.
- ableal 7y agoIt's somewhat like the phrase "it beggars belief" - it means that 'belief' is left in a very poor condition, begging alms ...
- vortico 7y agoThis is my only grammatical pet peeve, so thanks for the link. I'll be posting that around some. :)
- zimpenfish 7y agoIt's daft wrong-headed prescriptivism contrary to all common sense and usage. It just screams "I don't care about actual language, just silly pedantry".
- vortico 7y agoThe reason it's my pet peeve is because I use "begging the question" in its correct form all the time to describe an otherwise difficult concept. Once you put a name on something, it's much easier to understand and talk about. But when the name is confused with a much simpler concept "raising the question", it kills the original meaning so I have to explain the concept in far more words. For example, "The man is assuming a fact for granted and using a fact that follows in order to prove the original fact." is much more wordy than saying "The man is begging the question."
- boffinism 7y agoNah. "Beg the question" is used as a term of art in academia to mean one thing, but it is also used in common parlance to mean something else. See also 'fruit', and whether or not tomatoes are displayed in the vegetable aisle.
- jimktrains2 7y agoBotanically it's a fruit. Culinary its uses are more aligned with those of a vegetable. Fruits and vegetables aren't opposite things. Fruit is a term of art in botany, but it's lay usage is fairly close to that. The word vegetable can be fairly broad to include almost any edible part of a plant. This is why I'm a vegetarian and not a vegetarian and fruitarian. Culinary vegetable is often used as a "soft opposite" of fruit because they often require different preparations and uses. The interesting thing about "begs the question" is that it's a matter of who is doing the begging (asking). Classically your answer is asking for your premise, so you're sort of working backwards and likely circularly. In modern usage, the answer is asking for more research. Sometimes people use it to mean dodging a question, which I'm not quite sure why and would consider wrong usage.
- hyperdimension 7y agoOff topic, but well, as the saying goes, "Knowledge is knowing a tomato is a fruit. Wisdom is not putting it in a fruit salad."
- slavik81 7y ago"You need better pickup lines. An introduction like that begs a slap in the face." "Stay away from that switch! Running the factory lights at night begs a German bomb right on top of us." "I beg your pardon?" "That's an interesting link, but it begs the question, 'why does an archaic idiom invalidate the plain meaning of a phrase?'" The English language is well prepared to deal with ambiguities. There are countless words and phrases with multiple meanings. This one is not even confusing! One is always followed by the question it raises, which makes it quite obvious what they meant.
- ARandomerDude 7y agoImproper user of "begs the question" is like nails on chalkboard for me. Still, this has to be the best counterargument I've read. Well done.
- screye 7y agoThis is one of those cases where the popular (initially incorrect) use of the word has far outstripped the one this link mentions. It's like the word 'literally' (whose bastardization is both far more egregious and hilarious) Even Google now reflects the 'incorrect' use of beg as the primary meaning of it: beg - raise a question or point that has not been dealt with; invite an obvious question Unfortunate, but true.
- mcphage 7y ago> It's like the word 'literally' (whose bastardization is both far more egregious and hilarious) "literally" has been used to mean "figuratively" for hundreds of years, by plenty of famous authors. The idea that "literally" should only mean "actually; without exaggeration or inaccuracy" seems to be the actual recent invention.
- ryandvm 7y agoI like to be a grammar Nazi as much as the next guy, but honestly I'm over this one. It seems that the logical fallacy definition of "begs the question" has now become a recursive example of question begging itself. The only reason it means self-referencing argument is because 10% of the population believes it does. I'm half-convinced this was all just some linguist's April Fool's prank gone awry. The reality is the literal definition of "begs the question" is commonly accepted, well understood, and frankly, makes a hell of lot more sense. I'm fairly certain that it is the only definition for that term that is held by a majority of English speakers. If that doesn't make it the official definition, then what does? There is no English Language Preservation Organization. If most people think that is what it means, then that is what it means.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 7y agobegs the question has multiple meanings now because we say it does.