3 ms·
A technique that I learned from casting actors is: you don't have to be the candidates enemy to find out if they fit. If you ever find yourself trying to active
by atoav 7y ago
A technique that I learned from casting actors is: you don't have to be the candidates enemy to find out if they fit. If you ever find yourself trying to actively make the candidates life harder for no reason, you are doing it wrong (e.g. asking trick questions, expecting weirdly specific answers, etc)
Instead give them multiple different hard (but realistic for the position) problems and be on their side every time to guide them. Try to get them to do the best they can and observe them all the time.
This way you can get good feeling for how they are as a person, how they react to guidance and teamwork, and false negatives where a simple miscommunication leads to wrong solutions and a bad result, despite the candidate actually beeing good, are reduced.
If they constantly and heavily rely on your guidance that is a bad sign. If they actively fight against your guidance, this is bad as well. But in the end you are ”casting” them for a certain position within an existing "cast", and sometimes a person who initially needs more guidance will do great after a while if they are in an environment where they can receive it, while people who actively avoid guidance could work just fine in a position where they don't get too much anyways etc.
The opposite of this approach would be to ask an actor which pieces of [insert obscure european postramatic theatre director here] they know and if they know none assuming they can't act. Bonus points if the project doesn't have any connection to the topic asked at all. If anybody ever does this, it says more about the person asking, than the person answering. No — try really hard to get the best out of the candidates in the most accurate emulation of the job you want to give to them, and have a grasp of what they will get up to speed with in no time and what actually will get worse (e.g. personality traits). And if you areninsecure about someone give it another shot in a second round.
- pmiller2 7y agoI think you’ve got it right. The best interviews I’ve participated in felt like working with someone for an hour or so. As for the opposite scenario, you’ve got that right as well, except that the interviewer is a 25 year old, recently graduated theater major.
- atoav 7y ago> As for the opposite scenario, you’ve got that right as well, except that the interviewer is a 25 year old, recently graduated theater major. Insert there what you want, hehe. It always reminds me of one teacher I had, who always wanted to get oddly specific answers on his (always a little to unspecific) questions. He was so happy when nobody could answer it, he probably forgot what his job actually was. Behaviour like this tells more about the psyche of the interviewer than it tells about the candidate. Sometimes a behaviour like this is also the interviewers way of making sure the candidate doesn't expose them as the fraud they deep down feel they are: "See they didn't know that oddly specific bit (that I know!), so they must be worse than me – thank god!" In case of my teacher he felt insecure enough to feel the need to one-up teenagers and instead of teaching them something. Interviewers are only human after all as well. But it shouldn't be the candidates job to rub interviewers in the right way in order to make them comfortable with their own shortcomings as it shouldn't be the pupils job to massage teachers into actually teaching them something.
- m463 7y agoYou know, I screwed up an interview that was using your technique once. The person gave me a piece of paper with a program on it with a number of problems, and asked me to find them. But she was too involved with my problem solving, sort of looking at me as I worked through it, and I was sort of off-balance. I was almost about to say wait, let me do this on my own, but it was hard for me to be sort of rudely assertive because it was an interview. Meanwhile other interviews where the person would give me a problem and ignore me would have me doing fine.
- atoav 7y agoUh that sounds bad. But it wasn't at all what I meant — with actors in a casting you do let them play — but when they are done you either give them a hint and repeat it or you move on to a new thing and tell them what they should focus on. What you should not do is constantly interrupt while they are doing their thing. Of course you watch them. Beeing watched is part of their job — it isn't for a programmer or someone in tech. However it can also be hard for actors to feel watched. Contrary to popular expectation they are often not extroverts — this is why it is key to develope some sense of trust beforehand, e.g. I tell them that I will guide them and do all I can to get the best result from them. So I usually make it about solving the problem and not about them.
- m463 7y agoI understand your point and what you're saying and I like it. You want a wholistic interview process that treats the interviewers with respect and mimics what the actual job will be like, not some artificial interview scenario. It was just sort of an anomalous interview for me. I remember being asked, are you sure there's nothing more wrong with the program? and I looked back and couldn't see anything. And she pointed with her pencil and said "how about this?" and I was "Oh, yeah I see that now". After the interview, of course I was kicking myself. A friend of mine interviewed for the police, and he told me one of their questions. It was something along the lines of "You pull over a person for drunk driving, and when you get to the car, it's your mother. What do you do?" My friend said "You call another car to take your mother home" and I was thinking "what??? that seems so..." and he said, "Look, they don't want someone on the force who will throw their mother in jail." sometimes the answer to a novel situation - during a test - only dawns on you later.