2 ms·
Anecdotal evidence: Several times in my life I've had the strange luck of being told the internal workings of a decision after I was rejected for a job. Usuall
by pdimitar 7y ago
Anecdotal evidence:
Several times in my life I've had the strange luck of being told the internal workings of a decision after I was rejected for a job. Usually somebody from the interviewers liked me but couldn't convince the others, and subsequently decides to find me on LinkedIn and send me a direct message.
The messages have been eerily similar and are usually like this:
"Hey Dimi, I want you to know that I think you would be a perfect senior dev for our team. But the other guys said you were awkward part of the time, you didn't feel like you'll fit with the rest of us, and one of them heavily emphasised that you hesitated before answering one question very specific for our work... and when I pressed them to elaborate further they just angrily told me that I don't get it.
I wish you luck in your future searches but you should know that if it were up to me you'd be working with us now."
You can lose your balance for a minute while being evaluated live by several people? You can hesitate before answering a trick question about a niche project? Imagine that.
It's really bittersweet to get these internal insights and can make you want to pull your hair out -- but it did give me the perspective that most of the people charged with hiring go by a gut feeling and personal sympathy.
- non-entity 7y agoHeh, I'd rather hesitate on a question and give any answer than boastfully blurt out something that's incorrect
- pdimitar 7y agoSame, and apparently if you can't fake 100% confidence you are not good enough for some. Oh well. In the end it all works out well because you are not stuck with a company you dislike (and they with you). But during the process... it's painful and takes a toll on your mental health while you're going through all that.
- frankzinger 7y agoYeah almost anything is possible so one really has to try not to obsess about it too much. I know it's hard. I can't say I'm able to do it either. Anyway, my anecdote: we were interviewing for a C developer position. The next candidate was in his 50s. Our project leader took a dislike to him the moment he saw his resume. No idea why but I assumed it was either his age or that this project leader knew him and didn't want to work with him for some personal reason. The project leader arrived to the interview at least 40m late. In that time this candidate impressed me (as the C guy) very much and I said 'hire' immediately. However, as presaged, the project leader said no. This candidate had no way of knowing what had happened. He definitely could tell I was impressed so he probably assumed it was his age. Just imagine how he must've felt. I probably should've contacted him to let him know how messed up the our process was.
- pdimitar 7y agoNot sure how legal this is (the giving insights into your internal processes to a stranger part) but since there are no trade secrets involved I'd imagine it's quite safe. As I said above, it can be really bittersweet knowing the details but I'd advise you to strive to show maximum sympathy -- including contact them privately and let them know what and why happened. It's a little comfort for somebody who is about to run out of savings to hear "sorry that our process is so effed up, dude, and best of luck in the future!" but I can assure you that it helps them make peace with that past further down the line.