5 ms·
Oh sorry I wasn't clear. The reason is that successfully completing a simple programming exercise puts you in the top 15% or so of resumes that get sent in for
by josephg 7y ago
Oh sorry I wasn't clear. The reason is that successfully completing a simple programming exercise puts you in the top 15% or so of resumes that get sent in for most programming roles.
When you apply for a company, they have to assume you aren't very good, because most people who apply aren't very good. (Because people with strong skills get snapped up, and people with weak skills spam their resume everywhere they can.). Figuring out who's worth spending time interviewing is a hard problem in itself. And there's no silver bullet here - people lie about their work experience all the time. There are so many user accounts on github with copies or forks of random people's code, with basically no changes. I suspect they exist support lies on resumes.
I don't think it distorts the market, but it is annoying. A recruiter I talked to a few years ago said she thinks its crazy we don't use an agency model for programmers like actors do. The idea there is that good programmers pay a small percentage of their salary to a manager, who's job is to find you the best roles that suit your skills and negotiate pay on your behalf and so on. She tried to set up a business doing just that but she couldn't get enough clients to make it work. Good programmers balked at the idea of paying a few % of our salary to someone in an ongoing way, to look after our career. Having to prove your skills in each and every interview, and form those social connections on your own? Thats a choice we make.
- pdimitar 7y ago> (Because people with strong skills get snapped up, and people with weak skills spam their resume everywhere they can.) It's extremely saddening how prevalent this prejudice is. But what if I am still looking for work and companies literally don't reply to my applying to them? I might be the next John Carmack but if nobody gives me a chance (for reasons outside of my control and unrelated to my proficiency) then according to you I suck. :( It's very broken to assume that skilled people get snapped up immediately so whoever is available must be mediocre (or bad). It is an awfully imprecise assumption!
- hinkley 7y agoOr what if I’m being picky? I made a mistake of expediency in accepting my current job, and it’s not the first time. Several people I trust have been trying to talk me into applying to more places and turning them down if I don’t see what I’m looking for on their end. But they tend to overbook and one of the first things to go is your opportunity to ask questions. Which is, really, as good a way to learn about someone as most of the techniques we try. You only have ten or fifteen minutes to ask the company questions. What did you hunk was worthwhile to expend that time on?
- pdimitar 7y agoNot sure what part of my comment you replied to exactly? I also am kind of picky although I am not sure how wise that is in the current crisis.
- hinkley 7y agoYeah that's a fair question. I think it depends on the context. To be picky, you could just send out a lot of resumes, and I as a prospective employer wouldn't have any clue how many you've sent, as long as you are still at your old company the whole time. However if you have a good emergency fund, your old company folds, and you are being picky, people start to suspect you are unemployable after a bit.
- josephg 7y ago> It's extremely saddening how prevalent this prejudice is. Prejudice? Look, companies wouldn't be advertising for roles if they didn't think qualified candidates (like you?) are out there. But its a numbers game; of course there are more unqualified people looking for work than qualified people at any given moment. Qualified people don't get snapped up immediately; but they aren't usually actively looking for work for long. And they often are picky about which places they apply to - for good reason. A highly qualified candidate might apply for 3 roles, get 2 offers and accept 1 of them. A weak candidate might apply for 50 roles. If those are the only two people sending out resumes - (or in general the pool has 50% strong candidates and 50% weak candidates), still only 6% of resumes will come from strong candidates. Thats not none. And I really hear you about how frustrating it must be for companies to not even bother to reply - I mean, thats pretty rude. But ... what behaviour do you expect? What would you do with a pile of 100 resumes if you expected only 6 of them will be strong candidates? Should they bring all 100 people in for interviews, just in case there's a young John Carmack amongst them who has terrible resume writing skills? (I've interviewed 2 people who fit that description out of the 400 or so I interviewed in the last year. They definitely exist. But finding those people is prohibitively expensive for most companies.) Flawed? Yes. Biased? A little. Prejudiced? That seems like a stretch. Can you think of a better system? That conversation seems more interesting than just complaining about it.
- pdimitar 7y agoWhat I extract from your reply is what I am actively trying to teach myself: DON'T. TAKE. ANYTHING. PERSONALLY. Yeah? BTW I am not exactly young -- 40 y/o with 18 years of professional experience (not claiming anything about quality). I was just objecting to your general premise that if somebody isn't snatched immediately then they must be mediocre because I've witnessed programmers times better than me (whose sole efforts turned entire companies around) slag around jobless for 6 months and not being able to move beyond 2nd interview even if EVERYBODY told them they like their expertise and demeanour and that they are a good cultural fit. But you are very likely correct that it's a numbers game and that various circumstances prevent companies to actually actively look for the gems. So again, I do my best not to take anything personally.
- clarry 7y ago> A recruiter I talked to a few years ago said she thinks its crazy we don't use an agency model for programmers like actors do. The idea there is that good programmers pay a small percentage of their salary to a manager, who's job is to find you the best roles that suit your skills and negotiate pay on your behalf and so on. Such things do exist (at least in some form) but I haven't had a good experience. Same old story: like everyone else, they're looking for seniors, turning down juniors, and complaining about shortage of talent.
- sanderjd 7y ago> When you apply for a company, they have to assume you aren't very good, because most people who apply aren't very good. Is this a problem for other professionals? Why not? When an accountant with a successful career spanning 15 years applies to a new job, does the company "have to" assume that know exactly nothing? It does distort the market. It trades off against the desire to switch jobs, which distorts the availability of job switchers. When I get an email from a recruiter, I'm not just thinking "would that job be better for me?", I'm also thinking "am I willing to practice and perform the whiteboard code ritual right now?".